• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

The aim of this essay is to analyse the main strategies of differentiation employed within secondary science to aid effective pupil learning and to reflect upon its

Extracts from this document...


Aspects of Differentiation within Subject Specialisms The aim of this essay is to analyse the main strategies of differentiation employed within secondary science to aid effective pupil learning and to reflect upon its ability to achieve intended learning outcomes. The main focus of this study will be to evaluate the mode of differentiation by grouping and its interplay with various other forms of separation due to differences. Secondary data will be used to gain an overall perspective of methods of grouping and its implementation, attitudes towards the variety of grouping strategies and outcomes of the various approaches. Primary data will give an insight into various strategies in action and will aim to take an in depth look at aspects of differentiation within the science department of a mixed comprehensive school (school X). Research for this study includes primary data obtained during placement at school X, and secondary data from a variety of reference sources. 'We can define differentiation as any process which divides pupils into subgroups which are then exposed to different educational experiences. Differentiation then covers a great range of phenomena from the allocation of pupils to different classes, subjects, sets, streams, bands or tracks within the same school, to the different treatment of pupils in the same classroom.' (Smith 1981). Differentiation by ability grouping has had a long history as a key practice within UK schools. The definition above points to a number of methods which have been employed in education over more than half a century. 'Streaming' was the favoured practice of the 1950's, and continued to dominate into the 1960's spreading beyond the realms of the secondary school into junior schools. Equality in education became the dominating policy of the 1970's and 1980's and thus a surge in the adoption of a mixed-ability grouping strategy was seen at this time. Ability grouping reappeared in the 1990's with government policy stating 'setting' as a preferable approach (Boaler et al 2000). ...read more.


There appears to be the risk of considerable problems with both mixed-ability grouping and setting. The DfEE's concerns that mixed-ability grouping was failing to address the needs of every child (Boaler et al 2000) would not be misplaced if also attributed to setting. Certain areas in both methods of grouping need addressing to ensure optimum success. The Key Stage 3 National Strategy 2002 highlights factors which may encourage greater success for setting they include, 'close teamwork, cooperative planning and careful monitoring by science staff to make sure that pupils can move from set to set as their progress demands and that expectations for all pupils are suitably high' (www.standards.dfes.gov.uk). It may be pointed out that to address the needs of every child a more individualistic approach may be required whatever the adopted grouping strategy (Postlethwaite 1993). Ireson et al 2002 also points to this fact and stresses that, 'Teachers may need to be reminded that sets are not homogenous'. Thus in addition to differentiation by grouping other forms of differentiation with a more in depth regard for the individual must take place. If it is to be taken into account that even in a setting environment groups 'are not homogenous' (Ireson et al 2002) then consideration as to whether or not a pupil may need to be given a separate task or if a different outcome needs to be expected should be taken into account. This problem was highlighted by OFSTED, 'secondary schools need to give attention to matching work more effectively to the knowledge and skills of pupils of different abilities' (OFSTED 1993). 'Differentiation by task involves students within the same classroom either receiving different tasks or using different routes to complete the same task' (Hall 1997). This strategy was observed in practice at school X, separate worksheets were used to provide the same learning outcome for all pupils and were mainly used as an aid to pupils of lower ability, those with literacy problems or those who were struggling to keep up with the pace of work of the rest of the class. ...read more.


Pupils within set 1 gave a high priority to practical and computer work, those in set 3 also favoured practicals but also placed poster creation as a preferable activity, set 5 had slightly different preferences moving away from practical work to select posters, videos and computer work (Appendix 9a-c). The results indicate a high priority for kinaesthetic and visual tasks rather than linguistic activities. However the survey is but a brief snapshot to give an indication of the variety of learning styles which can be found within any one year group. The investigation has taken into consideration a number of methods of differentiation namely grouping, task setting and learning styles. With regard to grouping, extensive discussion and evaluation of the research available fails to appropriate a clear preferable technique of group organisation. The general consensus from the point of view of teachers is that setting provides a preferable environment to achieve learning goals (Hallam et al 2003). This is however purely based upon what is perceived as a more congenial teaching situation and fails to take into account other issues raised such as the creation of low self-esteem for low ability pupils and anxiety for high achieving students (Boaler 1997). Differentiation by task setting appeared successful within the confines of limited practical research secondary studies viewed this method with a greater air of caution gathering worrying findings as to the effects on low ability pupils (Hall 1997). Focusing on individual differences with regard to learning style appears to attract considerable praise and seems to be a method that can only enhance the quality of education within the classroom although it may have its limitations within the stringent framework of the national curriculum. In overview differentiation is summed eloquently by Turner and DiMarco (1998:110), 'Adopting a differentiated approach to teaching is a matter of being on the lookout for opportunities to guide, encourage and support your pupils in as many ways as possible, using whatever resources, processes and tactics seem appropriate. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our University Degree Teaching section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related University Degree Teaching essays

  1. Evaluate Strategies for creating a positive learning environment and analyse the extent to which ...

    A positive learning environment gives the children the opportunity to raise their self-esteem. By meeting the children's emotional needs helps them to become well adjusted. Curry and Johnson (1990:53) believe that "self -esteem is not a trivial pursuit that can be built by pepping children up with empty praise and cheers of support.

  2. The contribution assessment makes towards pupils learning There are different types of assessments ...

    This is a key example of where assessment is preventing the opportunity of further learning and the development of mathematics within the school. Another implication of summative assessment is the effect on a pupil's motivation. In this teach to the test culture pupils experience repeated practice tests which in some cases reinforce the low self-image of the lower-achieving students.

  1. PGCE - Professional Practice Modules - Contextualising Theory in Practice.

    2. Learners actively construct their experience. "We attach our own meanings to events. While others may attempt to impose their meanings on us, we ultimately define our own experience." (Boud et al, 1993, p10) This proposition highlights the importance of a learner's personal and cultural history.

  2. Critical Review: Teachers' Expectancies: Determinants Of Pupils' IQ Gains, Rosenthal and Jacobson.

    Confounding variables have been considered in the design, with the second IQ test conducted by both the teacher and an independent school administrator to control the teacher's influence on the results when testing the class. However, experimental effects were one confounding variable that did affect the research.

  1. This portfolio will help to illustrate and address how the current influences of play ...

    Rudolf Steiner http://www.life-changing-inspirational-quotes.com/inspirational-education-quotes.html John Dewey (1859 - 1952) John Dewey's theory of play is similar to Froebel's in that he thought early childhood education should be child centred which means based on the children's interests and that they learn best through play and real life experiences and that school life should grow out of home life and teachers/practitioners'

  2. Will be discussing and reflecting within my own practice, outlining verbal and non-verbal communication, ...

    This has proved to be an effective way of communicating with my learner's, as it enables them to feel that their needs are being addressed and also gives the learner more ownership of their programme and responsibility for their own learning.

  1. This essay examines and discusses various issues surrounding the school environment for learning.

    This helps them to feel more settled in their new environment, and motivates them to produce continual good work for the display board. Classroom displays not only praise children for their good pieces of work, but also ?brighten up? and personalise the room for the pupils.

  2. Self-reflection Essay. For TMA 01 I had to look at myself and my setting. ...

    Since finishing this assignment I have really tried to reinforce the Key Worker system in the Nursery by encouraging staff to make sure there is a strong bond between them and their key children. We can encourage this by the Key Worker welcoming the child in the morning, having healthy

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work