• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Critically Assess Jinnah's view that India was made of two nations.

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Critically Assess Jinnah's claim that India was made of two-nations Muhammad Ali Jinnah, who is seen as the founder of Pakistan was earlier in his career an ambassador of Hindu-Muslim politics and member of the Indian National Congress in the 1920's.1 However, in 1934, after a period of exile, he radically shifted his ideas, became leader of the Muslim League and pushed the demand for Muslim Separatism.2 In March 1940 he put forward the two-nation theory that was used as a basis for his demand for Pakistan and the creation of a separate Muslim state within India.3 He believed that India was made of two nations, those of Hindus and Muslims. The Muslims formed a minority group in India, and he believed that they deserved a separate state that would satisfy their needs. However, whether this two-nation theory was valid and successfully put into practice is controversial. In order to fully assess Jinnah's claim for a separate state, an examination of the background leading up to the two-nation theory and the 1930's and 1940's in India is required. This idea that India was made up of two nations was not something new. Its roots lie in the late 19th and early to mid 20th Century in the form of the Aligarh movement and kali fat movement.4 Sayeed Ahmad Kahn, who was the leader of the Aligarh movement, was the first person to express this idea.5 The Aligarh movement was set up following the creation of the Anglo-Mohammedan College that for the first time was able to educate the Muslims who were not only seen as a minority but also backward in society.6 It not only helped embed or foster their sense of Islamic identity but also enabled them to make their distinction from the Hindus who were the majority group.7 Also, Mohammed Iqbal, the poet in the 1930's again expressed this idea of a separate Muslim Homeland.8 However, at the same he also expressed where this separate homeland for the Muslims should be ...read more.

Middle

the leader of Sikhs, Tara Singh in 1942 and 1943 to discuss the future of the Sikhs and their demands.42 However, this did not come to fruition as "Mr Jinnah rejected the idea of a separate state for the Sikhs or for any other minorities within a country that Muslims proclaimed as their homeland. Self-determination for national groups in zones where there is a majority was one thing; Self-determination for scattered minorities was another. There could be little question of separate states for non-Muslim communities in Pakistan as for a scattered Muslim community in the United provinces".43 Jinnah's rejection in terms of a separate homeland for the Sikhs is significant in undermining the two-nation theory because by determining his theory on religion in which Muslims and Hindus were concerned, Jinnah had overlooked the fact that these were not the only two religious groups in India. Also, it must be remembered that a nation is defined as a "large aggregate of communities and individuals united by factors such as common descent, language, culture, history, or occupation of the same territory, so as to form a distinct group of people".44 The Two-Nation Theory was based on religion alone, and therefore it did not take into account these other features.45 The Muslims only had a link through Islam.46 Despite this, The Muslims were divided and did not all share the same culture, language and ethnicity.47 These issues particularly came to surface where the Bengali Muslims were concerned. The Bengali Muslims did not believe that they had any similarities between themselves and the other Muslims of India.48 They believed that there was no difference between a Bengali Muslim and Bengali Hindu.49 Gandhi particularly compared the Bengali Muslims when he had said that "A Bengali Muslim speaks the same tongue that a Bengali Hindu does, eats the same food, has the same amusements as his Hindu neighbour, They dress alike. I have often found it difficult to distinguish by outward sign between a Bengali Hindu and a Bengali Muslim." ...read more.

Conclusion

34 Jinnah,Address by Quaid-i-Azam Mohammad Ali Jinnah at Lahore Session of Muslim League, March, 1940 (Islamabad: Directorate of Films and Publishing, Ministry of Information and Broadcasting, Government of Pakistan, Islamabad, 1983) ,p.9 35ibid.,p.9 36 The break down of the Gandhi-Jinnah Talks, 1944, Indian Independence, British Library, http://www.bl.uk/reshelp/findhelpregion/asia/india/indianindependence/indiapakistan/partition2/index.html (Accessed 01/01/2010) 37 The break down of the Gandhi-Jinnah Talks, 1944, Indian Independence, British Library, http://www.bl.uk/reshelp/findhelpregion/asia/india/indianindependence/indiapakistan/partition2/index.html (Accessed 01/01/2010) 38 S.M Burke, (eds.) Quaid-i-Azam Mohammed Ali Jinnah: His Personality and Politics, 1997 2nd ed. (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2003), p.246 39 Judith M. Brown, (eds.) Modern India: Origins of an Asian Democracy,1985, (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1994), p.340 40 Brown, p.340 41 ibid., p.341 42 Anon, The Muslim League and the Sikhs, The Times, November 17th, 1942 43 Anon, Muslim League and Sikhs, The Times, November 17th, 1942 44 Oxford English Dictionary (OED), http://dictionary.oed.com/cgi/entry/00321434?query_type=word&queryword=nation&first=1&max_to_show=10&sort_type=alpha&result_place=1&search_id=kQgl-gOKMTl-7042&hilite=00321434 (Accessed 01/01/2010) 45 Burke, p.246 46 Akbar, p.37 47 ibid.,p.37 48 D.N Panigrahi, India's Partition: The Story of Imperialism in Retreat (Routledge: New York, 2004), p. 306 49 CWMG, no.71, pp.388-9, Harijan, 6th April 1940, cited in, D.N Panigrahi, India's Partition: The Story of Imperialism in Retreat (Routledge: New York, 2004), p. 153 50 ibid., p.153 51 D.N Panigrahi, p. 306 52 Anon, Bengal Muslims' Views, The Times, April 9th, 1946 53 Anon, Bengal Muslims' Views, The Times, April 9th, 1946 54Panigrahi, p.306 55 Mohammed Ali Jinnah, Speeches as Governer-General of Pakistan 1947-1948 (Lahore: Sang-e-Meel Publications, 2004) p.18 56 ibid., p.17 57 Mohammed Ali Jinnah, Address by Quaid-i-Azam Mohammad Ali Jinnah at Lahore Session of Muslim League, March, 1940 (Islamabad: Directorate of Films and Publishing, Ministry of Information and Broadcasting, Government of Pakistan, Islamabad, 1983) ,p.9 58 Jinnah,p.17 59 Wolpert, p339 60 Jalal, The Sole Spokesman: Jinnah, the Muslim League and the Demand for Pakistan, p.2 61 ibid., p.2 62, Bose, Jalal, Modern South Asia: History, Culture, Political Economy, p.154 63 Bose, p.154 64 ibid., p.154 65 ibid., p.154 66 Burke, p.246 67 Akbar, p.37 68 Bose, Jalal, ,p.155 Mark-James Fisher Primary Source Essay HIST 2008: British India 1857-1947 Dr. Pippa Virdee Page 1 ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our University Degree 1920-1949 section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related University Degree 1920-1949 essays

  1. Why US hegemony in the 20th century was inevitable.

    and hence massive internal destruction, and despite large economic and military losses they had geared up to fight the war to such a degree that they had the largest military that the world had ever seen at the end of the war.

  2. Do Historical Films help or hinder our understanding of the past? Discuss with reference ...

    past because although some historians agree that visual material needs to produced alongside a wide range of written material18, this could perhaps make the audience consider whether the producer is taking Fest's book19 as its factual representation rather than just 'one' of its interpretations (or representations)20, by therefore taking a subjective, rather than objective, position.

  1. Book Review - The New Deal by Paul K. Conkin

    The idea of Roosevelt as a pragmatist then, was more along the lines of, as Conkin puts it, his practicality. There is certainly an argument for suggesting that pragmatism was used by the New Deal apologists as a euphemistic term for Roosevelt's lack of direction and inconsistent policies, but Conkin's

  2. What were the Main Features of the Stalinist System

    Once Stalin had purged the secret police he no longer depended on any single institution and could freely manoeuvre between the institutions of power. After the Purges Stalin had succeeded in converting the party into an instrument of him and his clique.

  1. To what extent did the Tsarist and Soviet governments control and influence music in ...

    Wilson, Elizabeth (1994), Shostakovich: A Life Remembered, Faber and Faber (1995). Misc. Weinstein, Larry (director) (1997), Shostakovich against Stalin: The War Symphonies. Webpages The Prokofiev Page: prokofiev.org Notes: * "Formalism" was a fairly generic term of abuse used by the r�gime against its cultural opponents, generally applied to works perceived as modernist.

  2. The Moyne Commission was a waste of time. Critically discuss the view. The Moyne ...

    The social structure of most West Indian Colonies is put forward by the fact that the agriculture which is mostly their mainstay was discovered and long continued on a comparatively small number of black people who does labour. The possibility of the freed slaves choose to buy land of their

  1. Analyze the factors that gradually influenced the emergence of the Two Nation theory in ...

    Historical Background Self Awakening of the Muslims with the development of irreconcilable differences with Hindus Hindus and Muslims had co-existed in peace for centuries but with the arrival of British into the subcontinent in 1857 the discrepancy in status of Muslims and Hindus widened and gave rise to socio-economic, political,

  2. Stalin's Personality cult

    Soviet Union ? a giant of a man responsible for massive projects of industrialization. And the Stalinist purges, when tens of thousands of innocent people suffered, are glossed over as implicitly necessary for the security of the state. Poets wrote praises to Stalin and artists were forced to produce works that glorified him and the Soviet State.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work