• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Evaluating Archaeological reports - Wilsford Barrows and Surface Mine near Whittonstall cemeteries

Extracts from this document...


Introduction: In this assignment I will be analyzing and critically evaluate two different archaeological reports, the first one is a survey report about Wilsford Barrows cemetery and the second one is a geophysical survey about surface mine near Whittonstall. So I will discuss and assess how effectively each report succeeds as a 'level 3 report' as defined by the English Heritage. Comparing and considering these reports I am going to see their relative effectiveness at conveying archaeological information and interpretations. Finally, considering the practical/field work on which these reports are based I will try to interpret and recommend the current issues that may have been developed around access to that works. 1. Stonehenge World Heritage Site Landscape Project Wilsford Barrows Archaeological Survey Report by Mark Bowden According to this archaeological survey, Wilsford Barrows it's a group of major importance cemeteries located in Stonehenge. Even though the Wilsford Barrows group surveying near a monument of great importance and numerous studies conducted around this (Stonehenge), unfortunately has received less attention than most other major barrow groups and has not been the subject of modern excavation (aerial survey or geophysical survey) ...read more.


chain from a cauldron or similar and Imported objects are also represented including the very rare glass bead etc.), dimensions for the graves, burials and cremation and raises the questions and the discussions that were created around them. He, also, provides us with some photos of the area (a map, an ordnance survey antiquity model, two aerials photographs, and a survey plan), an image with a grave good and some tables with data found in the excavation. According to Level 3 report from English Heritage, this archaeological survey report of Mark Bowden gives us all the information that we need to understand the time, the space, and the conditions of this excavation. The scale of the images that have been used were correct (1:1000 or larger). It was really easy for me to read and understand it but I think that the range of measured and annotated drawings as well as photographs and reconstruction/phased diagrams was poor, I needed more. ...read more.


survey but in order to be able to reach some results, concerning the Level 3 report, we must take the guidelines outlined by English Heritage and by the IfA. The scale of the images that have been used were correct (1:1000 or larger). Is not difficult to understand this survey but when it comes a time for considering the pictures, if you do not know about magnetometer data you can't interpret them. This was the only difficulty that I encountered. Conclusion: Both surveys can be said that they were effective, and depending on the way of writing, convey to readers archaeological information and interpretation. You can get the main point. I think that both of them can be characterized as Level 3 report, but both of them have some deficiencies. I would personally prefer the first survey because it was easier to me to understand it, it was clearly and I have read it more easily. But I would prefer to contain more images of the findings and more area maps. I hope that through this assignment I was able to answer the points that I have raised in the beginning. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our University Degree Ancient History section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related University Degree Ancient History essays

  1. Book Comparison: Mark, Silverblatt, Linebaugh, Rediker

    The upper class, in contrast, viewed themselves as saviors to the expropriated who could no longer support themselves without the rights to land and property, once an inalienable right of everyone. When the proletariat rebelled against the authority of the upper class, they were severely repressed and forced back into labor.

  2. Discussing the biblical historiography of images of the Jew in the ancinet world

    Discussion The Jews living in the Babylonian and Persian Diaspora were not just subject to the standard difficulties associated with being exiled to an alien environment. Presumably, guilt over being the cause of divine retribution in the first place, combined with the repeated explicit threat of further punishment in Jeremiah's

  1. How Can Archaeologists Identify and Interpret The Remains of Religious Activity?

    the focusing of the celebrants' attention by light, smell or construction; evidence of a 'boundary zone' area that contains the meeting point between the temporal and spiritual worlds and is therefore often shielded in some way from desecration; the presence of the deity in images or a vessel through which

  2. "Europeans were less interested by the New World than their Classical Heritage"

    almost saintly status, it was some time before Columbus could even have been sure that his Christian name would be recorded correctly by writers. Benzoni noted that their classical forebears would have erected a statue in his honour suggesting a lack of appropriate monuments to his memory (although Francis Bacon kept a statue of him)

  1. Were the Stoics Effective Critics of Slavery?

    Secondly, and more importantly, discussion on slaves was a useful philosophical tool to illustrate that a free man according to classical standards could be a slave unless he seeks virtue. Apart from the slaves who managed to become philosophers, Stoicism like all philosophy was the pursuit of the upper classes.

  2. The Roman World 509 B.C. To A.D. 180

    (It is not coincidental that the predominantly working-class population of Corinth was anti-Roman, and that later, after the city was resettled, they would welcome Paul "teaching Christ" for a lengthy eighteen months.) The Romans also supported oligarchic factions in all Greek states, and placed Greece under the watchful eye of

  1. What types of military installation are represented in the archaeological record, and what were ...

    Many of these forts can be found in good condition on Hadrian's Wall. They were permanent bases for the legions, and also served as crossing points of the Wall, around which grew civilian settlements. A good example of this model can be seen in Housesteads fort on Hadrian's Wall, a diagram of which is shown below.

  2. With reference to one specific excavation of your choice, describe and illustrate the various ...

    However, without drawings and maps there is little evidence for sites. Also, looking at drawings and maps gives us a direct correlation into its observation and "site's context" (Barker 1986: 57). In particular at Wroxeter there are three such productions spanning from 1721 to 1812 giving us insight into what

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work