• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

It must be admitted that the Republican Government of Spain has waged war very ineffectually (Liston Oak, May 1937). Comment.

Extracts from this document...


It must be admitted that the Republican Government of Spain has waged war very ineffectually (Liston Oak, May 1937). Comment. The political and military situation facing the Republic after the military rising of July 1936 was not as hopeless as one is sometimes led to believe. Yet the final result was a resounding and b****y defeat for the forces of the Republic. To some it is easy to place the woes of the Republic squarely on foreign intervention, or in the British and French cases - Non-Intervention. However, it could be argued that the major cause of the collapse of the Republic was the ineffective handling of the war effort by the Republic itself. The start of the military rising was not an example of a well-oiled military plan. The insurrection suffered from poor communication between the conspirators, with Hugh Thomas commenting that 'morale was low.'1 It could be argued that the most important period of the war was the first 48 hours of the rising. The earliest means of suppressing the insurrection open to the Republic, since the reliability of the constitutional forces could not be guaranteed, was a wholesale arming of the trade unions and the left-wing parties. ...read more.


Among the victims were women in nightclothes and children in pyjamas.13 Reports would also reach other European states of the murder of priests, nuns and the burning of churches. Although Nationalist repression would be as b****y the damage was less of a concern to a military government. The international standing of the Republic would never recover with disastrous consequences for the long-term diplomatic efforts of the Republic. What is clear is that taking quick decisions was never easy in Spain and with the dissipation of authority by the proliferation of committees and workers militia the Republic had difficulty in establishing co-ordinated central control. There was also the conviction among most groups on the left, particularly the anarchists, that military discipline was not something required by a committed revolutionary. The communists disagreed, and as there influence spread with the arrival of Russian military aid the scene were set for what became known as 'the war within a war.' A 'war-inept military and civil leadership - warring political factions',14 these problems typified the early days of the Republic. This division in Republican ranks might not have been disastrous had their opponents also been divided. ...read more.


p55 8 Browne, Harry, Spain's Civil War, p39 9 Hills, G, The Battle for Madrid p56 10 Hills, G, The Battle for Madrid p50 11 The navy's inaction could be explained by the lack of officers and the fact that the German pocket battleships Deutchland and Admiral Scheer were screening the ships transferring the Army of Africa. Beevor, A, The Spanish Civil War, p63 12 Thomas, H, The Spanish Civil War, p227 13 Hills, G, The Battle for Madrid, p44 14 Browne, H, Spain's Civil War, p44 15 Indeed it could be argued that only one military force at that time could manage such attacks, the German Whermacht. It would take several years of war, and many setbacks before the officers and men of the British, American and Russian armies could even come close to perfecting co-ordinated attacking warfare. 16 Ten different calibres: 6.5, 7, 7.62, 7.65, 7.7, 7.707, 7.92, 8, 8.03 and 11mm. Gerald, Howson, Arms for Spain The Untold Story of the Spanish Civil War. (London: John Murray 1998) p29 17 Howson, G, Arms for Spain, p29 18 Howson, G, Arms for Spain, p109 19 Howson, G, Arms for Spain, p109 20 The Spanish are credited in inventing modern guerrilla warfare in their successful campaign to evict Napoleon from their soil. 1 John McDowall Spanish Civil War ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our University Degree 1920-1949 section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related University Degree 1920-1949 essays

  1. To what extent did the Tsarist and Soviet governments control and influence music in ...

    �� The two versions are reproduced in appendix one. 1 A note on dates: as the completion dates of works by Dmitri Shostakovich in particular are frequently unclear, all compositions have been dated by their premi�res, except where explicitly stated otherwise. 2 Maes, Francis (1996), A History of Russian Music: From Kamarinskaya to Babi Yar, pp.203-4, University of California

  2. Prohibition: The Experiment That Failed.

    The government averted its eyes from the gangsters and acted as if it didn't see anything unusual going on (Feinstein 12). Many significant underworld figures created names for themselves during the 1920's largely due to "secretive" distribution of alcohol. An important example is John Torrio.

  1. In considering the process of change in the German Government 1890-1991, how far can ...

    However Morris fails to acknowledge that the Government enjoyed much success via various treaties. The defeat of WWI is the key turning point due to the various clauses, resentment and fury of Germans as shown by Aldcroft that "Germany harboured a burning resentment against the victors and was determined to

  2. Ireland Nationalists

    Secondly, the preservation of Irish national built heritage shows the distinction from British past, such as The Hill of Tara and Newgrange. Therefore, the first 'invented tradition' analysed is the common goal of the Irish cultural nationalists: to establish that the people of Ireland had a rich and ancient culture which justified their sense of nationhood.

  1. The Rejections to Bombing Auschwitz-Birkenau: A Genuine Concern of Military Sacrifice or Simply the ...

    current plans, other missions were carried out which required similar if not more aerial involvement than would be necessary to b**b the death camps and railways. For instance, during the same time period in which the War Department rejected the initial request to b**b the railways, a fleet of Fifteenth

  2. Representations of women during WWII

    While female labour was crucial to the war effort, this number constituted an increase of between only five and seven percent, and is perhaps not as significant as has been suggested. While historians have documented the increased sense of female independence and liberation which resulted from greater work opportunities, to

  1. What were the Repercussions of the Korean War for the Global Cold War Strategy ...

    to world stability or US interests, at least immediately following the Second World War. In saying this, however, there was a concerted push from a number of military statesman for a "hard-line" attitude towards the Soviet Union, as realised by the NSC-68 document, which outlined the extent of the Soviet

  2. Explain and critically examine Britain(TM)s policy of non-intervention in the Spanish Civil War

    In Britain policy of adherence to the Non-Intervention Pact signed by the European governments in August 1936 was defended by the right-leaning Baldwin government on the grounds of the need for containment of the war in a politically volatile Europe.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work