• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month
  1. 1
  2. 2
  3. 3
  4. 4
  5. 5
  6. 6
  7. 7
  8. 8
  9. 9
  10. 10
  11. 11
  12. 12
  13. 13
  14. 14
  15. 15
  16. 16
  17. 17
  18. 18
  19. 19
  20. 20
  21. 21
  22. 22
  23. 23
  24. 24
  25. 25
  26. 26
  27. 27

Marxism versus Sectarianism - "The dogs bark: therefore the caravan is moving." (Arab proverb) - An alien method.

Extracts from this document...


��ࡱ�>�� �����������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������[email protected] ��0�bjbj�2�2 (��X�Xu���������������tttt8� �ttuv88888888�������$�R= ��88888��88/���8�8�8��8�������8, �����t8d��E0u�� �� ���b����� �� 88�88888�Marxism versus Sectarianism By Alan Woods "The dogs bark: therefore the caravan is moving." (Arab proverb) An alien method My attention was recently drawn to an article signed by Luis Oviedo, entitled The Counterrevolutionary Position of Socialist Appeal (in Prensa Obrera n� 826). Having read the article, I could not decide whether it was the product of bad faith or simple ignorance. Certainly, the method used is contrary to every basic principle of Marxism and above all Trotskyism, which comrade Oviedo and the Partido Obrero (PO) claim to defend. The Argentine PO has had some success in recent years. In its ranks there are good militants who sincerely wish to advance the cause of Trotskyism and the socialist revolution in Argentina and Latin America. Its members have undoubtedly done some good work in developing the movement of the piqueteros. All this merits our sincere respect, and we believe that in our past polemics with the PO we have always maintained a scrupulous and respectful attitude. This is not a little detail. The inability to answer criticisms and differences in a democratic and comradely way will undermine the party and prevent it developing beyond a certain limit. All internal differences and criticisms will be stifled and silenced. This means that all the good work done by the members will be undone sooner or later. The reason for this is not at all diplomatic. We are not liberals but Bolsheviks, and we maintain the genuine traditions of the party of Lenin and Trotsky, which we have defended against revisionism for more than seventy years, nationally and internationally. It should be added that revisionism comes in all the colours of the rainbow, and contains not only a right but also a "left" colouring. Why were the great Marxists so scrupulous in answering the ideas of their opponents? ...read more.


on "How to work in the SP" when he says the following: "So far as the criticism of the centrist leadership is concerned, it is very important to pay attention to this: that this criticism should not lose itself on side issues which can only irritate the Socialist following, but should be concentrated upon well chosen and important questions. There is a certain danger that our comrades will react in meetings with mockery and contempt to the centrist superficialities and platitudes. From the very beginning this may create an unfavourable atmosphere for us. For the simple member who does not have the necessary political training, it is difficult to raise himself to the level of our criticism, and therefore irony (even the most deserved) can have a disturbing, suspicion-arousing, and exasperating effect upon the rank and file. This gives the centrist leaders the opportunity to mobilise these sentiments against us. Therefore, the greatest patience, a calm, friendly tone is indispensable." (Trotsky, Writings, 1935-36, p.268.) From the same letter, it is clear that Trotsky was unhappy with the way the French Trotskyists had carried out work in the SP: "Besides in France, also, far too much energy was expended upon the frequently purely phraseological 'exposure' of the leaders, and too little for a more deep-going work at the base, especially among the youth." (ibid, p. 267.) All these criticisms can be levelled at the PO and the other ultra-left groups. They have not understood a single line that Trotsky and Lenin wrote. Luis Oviedo does not like our article. Why does he not like it? Because it criticises the leaders of the COB in a constructive way - in a way that could actually find an echo in the rank and file of the union. It does not call them traitors or inform the rank and file that their leaders are the same as the bourgeoisie! ...read more.


We invite all members of the PO, and all others who wish to fight for the ideas of Lenin and Trotsky, to enter into a comradely dialogue with us. Do not depend on the false interpretations of your leaders! If you wish to know the truth, contact us and find out for yourself! London, December 17, 2003. This document was downloaded from Coursework.Info - The UK's Coursework Database - http://www.coursework.info/ This document was downloaded from Coursework.Info - The UK's Coursework Database - http://www.coursework.info/ This document was downloaded from Coursework.Info - The UK's Coursework Database - http://www.coursework.info/ This document was downloaded from Coursework.Info - The UK's Coursework Database - http://www.coursework.info/ This document was downloaded from Coursework.Info - The UK's Coursework Database - http://www.coursework.info/ This document was downloaded from Coursework.Info - The UK's Coursework Database - http://www.coursework.info/ \}}}u}v}�}�}Y~Z~�~�~=>�����������������hx�hx�OJQJhx�hx�CJOJQJ%hx�hx�OJQJfHq� ����)hx�hx�CJOJQJfHq� ����hx�h 9Ihx�hx�mHsH h 9Ihx�*kl|}, - � � Q R ����78����STRS� �����������������������������gd 9I}���� � {#|#�$�$T'U'y'z'�*�*#-$-w/x/4050�0�0�0�0�2�2�4�4�6�6�9:�����������������������������gd 9I:;;>>AADD�F�F�G�G�L�L�N�N�Q�Q�R�R�T�T�W�W1Z2Z�[�[k^�����������������������������gd 9Ik^l^�_�_ccxeye�g�g�i�i�i�illoo�q�qMuNu1w2w�w�w-|.|�|�|�����������������������������gd 9I�|�}�}z{ �!�ÆÇi�j�ÜÝ��������ÒÓ��������W�X���������������������������������������gd 9I� ���×Ø��������J�K�����o�p����� ����2�3�������طٷ�����������������������������gd 9Iٷ����#�$�������������������������������������<�=�����H������������������������������gd 9IH�I�c�d�+�,�b�c����� � �����������{�|�h�i���������������������������������������������gd 9I����������E�F�F�G�w�x�����������Y Z � � � � ��c�����������������������������gd 9IcdEFopQR������>?w x "###�#�#�%�%�&�&�'�'i(j(�����������������������������gd 9Ij(�)�)**�,�,�.�.�0�0�3�3�6�6�8�8-<.<�>�>�@�@aCbC4F5F�I�IZL�����������������������������gd 9IZL[L�N�N�P�P�R�R:U;U;W<W1X2X%\&\P^Q^�`�`mdndydzd�f�fiimm�����������������������������gd 9Im�o�o�q�q�t�t�w�w�z�z�{�{�|�|}}v}w}x}y}�}�}�}�}Z~[~��������������������������$a$gdx�$a$gdx�gd 9I[~\~]~�~�~�~�~>[email protected]����������������������gd 9I$a$gdx�$a$gdx�&1�h:p 9I��/ ��=!�'"�'#��$��%��[email protected]�D NormalCJ_H aJmH nHsH [email protected]�D Default Paragraph FontRi�R Table Normal�4� l4�a� (k�(No [email protected]�D 9I Plain TextCJOJQJ^[email protected] x�Header ���!4 @4 x�Footer ���!`�o"` x�watermark header$a$CJOJQJfHq� ����N�o2N x�watermark footer$a$ CJOJQJ�w����� ���z� ���z� ���z� ���z� ���z� ���z� ���z� ���z� �� �z� �� �z� �� �z� �� �z� �� �z� ���z� ���z� ���z� ���z� ���z� ���z� ���z� ���z� ���z� ���z� ���z� ���z� ���z� ���z�8 |�(�7�F-U�c�q���!�Ҫҹ����|���s��Y*�9oH�Ve�s�wN �?jC� � O � � n�n��1�[hr�V�:����� :k^�|�ٷH���cj(ZLm[~�����������������\}uuwuyu�u�u[v]v�v�v?wAw�w�wC�u�wu�w��alex� 9Ix��@uȷ��[email protected]��Unknown������������G��z ��Times New Roman5V��Symbol3&� �z ��Arial7&� � �VerdanaG5�� �����h�MS Mincho-�3� fg?5� �z ��Courier New"1���h!R��!R��!R��v?�6��v?�6��$�������4�u�u3�� H�?������������������ 9I��Marxism versus SectarianismTCoursework.Info Coursework - http://www.coursework.info/ - Redistribution ProhibitedTCoursework.Info Coursework - http://www.coursework.info/ - Redistribution Prohibitedalexalex�� ��Oh��+'��0x���$4��� ( 4 @ LX`hp�Marxism versus SectarianismUCoursework.Info Coursework - http://www.coursework.info/ - Redistribution ProhibitedualexewoUCoursework.Info Coursework - http://www.coursework.info/ - Redistribution Prohibitedu>Downloaded from Coursework.Info - http://www.coursework.info/is Normal.dotfalexl.d2exMicrosoft Word [email protected]@Þ§}��@Þ§}��@Þ§}��v?�6�� ��Õ.��+,��D��Õ.��+,��|8���H����� ���� � �UCoursework.Info Coursework - http://www.coursework.info/ - Redistribution ProhibitedoUCoursework.Info Coursework - http://www.coursework.info/ - Redistribution ProhibitedoUCoursework.Info Coursework - http://www.coursework.info/ - Redistribution Prohibitedoqv���uA Marxism versus Sectarianism [email protected]���+K_PID_LINKBASE CopyrightDownloaded FromCan RedistributeOwner�A4http://www.coursework.comcoursework.comehttp://www.coursework.com -No, do not redistributecoursework.com/ !"#$%&'()*+,-./0123456789:;<=>[email protected][\]^_`abcdefghijklmnopqrstuvwxyz{|}~������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������Root Entry�������� �F�+�����1Table���������WordDocument��������(�SummaryInformation(�����DocumentSummaryInformation8�������������CompObj������������j������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������ ���� �FMicrosoft Word Document MSWordDocWord.Document.8�9�q ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our University Degree 1700-1799 section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related University Degree 1700-1799 essays

  1. &amp;amp;#147;The French Revolution was simply a product of Enlightenment thought.&amp;amp;#148; How accurate is this ...

    a reaction to the age of religious salvation and centuries of universal sin. Enlightenment thinkers enthused about the importance of mankind and professed that he was the master of his own destiny. Instead of living in constant fear of divine retribution people had the right and the ability to live their lives as they believed was correct.

  2. Through examining the historians Georges Lefebvre and Alfred Cobban, what are the underlying factors ...

    He stated that "the social structure (as a result of the revolution) is...difficult to change."28 This perception of the lack of change as a result of the revolution arises through the emphasis of continuity which revisionist historians place on historical progression.

  1. To what extent did diplomacy effect the rise of the modern state from 1648-1815?

    The 'interests of state' were no longer decided by the king alone (they had not been for some time in England), but by wealthy merchants, financiers, holders of title and inherited wealth, and the royal family. This devolution of foreign policy to bureaucrats and numerous groups helped to make policy both more predictable and more conservative."

  2. The Heads of a Plan document is a key primary source in determining why ...

    This proposal was the origin of the idea of a settlement in Australia, although originally no convicts were mentioned. In this document Matra discusses the potential commercial advantages to Britain of a settlement in New South Wales. He mentions the good soil, advantages of flax cultivation, trade with China and

  1. Stalin's rise to power

    Through 'Socialism in One Country', Stalin was able to promote himself as being a true 'patriot' and only looking out for Russia. Due to the number of factors involved in Stalin's rise to power, there has been a range of different interpretations to the rise of Stalin.

  2. Was the industrial Revolution a good thing?

    There were also many more infectious diseases including typhoid, spread by lice and tuberculosis, carried by bacteria in the air. There were no vaccinations or cures to these new diseases, so nothing could be done but to let the children and other sufferers die.

  1. Was the French revolution a Bourgeoisie revolution?

    Between 1726 and 1791, 90% of the farmers-General of Taxes often considered the supreme example of Bourgeois men of wealth were noble.6 Revisionists believe that the Bourgeoisie aimed to enter into the nobility. A lot of evidence can support this theory.

  2. Why did the Industrial Revolution Occur in Britain First?

    crisis would have been unavoidable, and industrial growth would have come to a premature end. The quality and the quantity of Great Britain?s coal supplies coupled with its relative shortage of wood pushed it to make a transition from organic sources of energy to the more efficient inorganic sources of

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work