• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Modernity's Madness and Manifestations of Masochism and Malice: A Demand for Irrational Self-Love, Forgiveness, and Faith.

Extracts from this document...


Modernity's Madness and Manifestations of Masochism and Malice: A Demand for Irrational Self-Love, Forgiveness, and Faith Word count 3349 Fyodor Dostoevsky's birth-year representatively embeds him in two events that determine Russia's course for the next hundred years; Alexander Pushkin, at sixteen years old, became Russia's first national poet in 1815 and in 1825 the Decembrists' failed coup d'etat of Nicholas I, the country's one shot at democracy and exoneration from serfdom, initiated a 'Frozen Society', marked by harsh censors and absence of reform. Nikolai Gogol appropriately arrived in St. Petersburg from rural Russia in 1837 when Pushkin died following a duel in timely fashion to claim Pushkin's title. The trinity of Russian Romantic writers not only share styles which coalesce to form the great tradition now known as Russian Literature, but would also uniquely define themselves as representatives of their people. That creating and finding identity in St. Petersburg, both Russian capital and 'Window to the West', was perplexing and difficult for its people is demonstrated by a cursory analysis of the aforementioned writers' related, while idiosyncratic, tendencies and meaningful characters. Joseph Frank, in his five volume oeuvre, explicates the natural influence of Pushkin and Gogol on Dostoevsky. Russian literature from the 1830s was strongly influenced by Germanic Romanticism and the school's "dissonance between the ideal and real", and this is obsequious in Pushkin's The Bronze Horseman and The Queen of Spades and Gogol's Nevsky Prospect, The Overcoat, and The Diary of A Madman. The main characters in three of these five end their lives and the story in suicide, and all five are clearly insanely mad as the conclusion nears as a result of the shattering of their projected ideals on reality. A contemporary, N.A. Polevoy, described his artistic aim, "to show that the mad dreams of the poets do not fit in with the world of material existence"; the 'dreamer' "becomes a symbol of the failure to grapple with and master the demands and challenges of life". ...read more.


Dostoevsky's exposure of idealist radicals' 'advanced ideas' and their implications are read as "a declaration of Dosteovsky's supposed adherence to Nietzsche's philosophy of 'amoralism' and the will to power" or "the revolt of the human personality against all attempts to limit its inexhaustible potentialities3" (Frank, 219) - but Nietzsche was only twenty years old when NfU was published, and his ideas had surely not been successfully communicated by then; most of Nietzsche's works were first published shortly before his death in 1900. Nietzsche actually proclaimed that "Dostoevsky was the only psychologist from whom I had anything to learn"4. The Underground Man: Sick and Spiteful Immediately following the aforementioned beginning of NfU, the narrator speaks of his "liver's being diseased" and his refusing to see a doctor. He continues by admitting that he really doesn't know a thing about his illness and later he describes his 'hyperconsciousness' is a disease "but so is being conscious at all. I insist on it. But let's leave that alone for a minute (1,6)"5. His "'reason,' which would prompt him to seek a doctor out of self-interest is evidently thwarted by some other motive" (Frank, 220). He continues his address about his spite, describing that it was "begging to be let out, but I would not let them, would not let them, purposely let them"6 (4). Frank remarks that this man is not evil and perverse 'by nature', but he is a "character innately deformed and distorted" (221), and that he "enjoys the experience of his own degradation", admitting "to being an unashamed m*******t [my emphasis]" (222). He continues by proclaiming this as inevitable and begins his 'rant' on 'laws of nature' and the "inertia7 which results directly from these laws" which, consequently, one couldn't change (7). "Spite is not a valid cause for any kind of action, and hence it is the only one left when the laws of nature make any justified [my emphasis] response impossible" (223). ...read more.


Who was the most tragic figure, the Underground Man or the Grand Inquisitor? The underground man battles with egoism and altruism (Frank, 221). Ivan battles with reason and faith, to which Alyosha responds, "Your poem is in praise of Jesus, not in blame of him - as you meant it to be." But the younger, na�ve, and innocent does not see precisely the despair, or the One Question15 that incites Ivan's declaration that he will end his life at thirty years of age. Alyosha its affecting Ivan after their lunchtime rendezvous has concluded, "How will you live?... with such a h**l in your heart and your head, how can you?" An Irrational Conclusion Madness results from development of the rational self, which necessitates evil to demonstrate it's autonomy over the 'best rational decision'. But there is the other side to the paradox too, that Man has an awareness of the self while also recognizing, to some relative degrees, Man's place in the world with which we live. The problem lies in that this world of which we are a part may only be a totalitarian ideal, and the malefits of a separation of ideals from reality has been shown in the above. How is one to respond? to others? and the World? Dostoevsky, I believe would say faith and forgiveness - revenge is only a perpetuation of evil, and a manifestation of individual freedom therefore; one only desires revenge from when the 'self' is offended. But selfless love has no offense, no aggression. The rational necessarily involves a self, for whom the advantage is calculated. Dostoevsky explicates the dangers of a 'hyperconscious self' via the Underground Man, and the Grand Inquisitor, a product of his last work. So years of masterpieces, thousands of pages, and years in labor camps after a truly revelationary experience have afforded a truly irrational conclusion - please forgive him. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our University Degree Philosophy and Theology section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related University Degree Philosophy and Theology essays

  1. Primary Source Analysis of a document from the New York Daily Tribune, written on ...

    The document was also beneficial to the abolitionists cause because it had shown the ideas, opinions, and the existence of literate African Americans. For the duration of the interview between Frazier, the twelve ministers present, General Major Sherman, and Edwin M.

  2. Zionism has never seriously posed this question: Why, during these two thousand years, have ...

    In sum both the intimate and the more remote images of redemption display a marked tendency towards passive, miracle centred messianism. This direct confrontation with Zionism greatly contributed to the sharpening this traditonal passive posture and raising it to consiousness, bringing it from the margins to the center a times

  1. The Influence of Repentance on the Self and Society. In his essay Of Repentance ...

    The general population tends to look past the consequences of a two-faced life, a life of hurting the people one cares for and being labeled a deceiving, manipulative person for the benefits of this lifestyle.

  2. Marx once famously wrote, Hitherto, philosophers have merely interpreted the world; the point is: ...

    Hence, for Marcuse, the challenge becomes to release the individual mind from the bondage of 'false needs': if this were attained, then revolution would be spontaneous (Marcuse 2010:44). This view is significantly contra Marx, who theorized socialist society as a realm of individual freedom and human flourishing without either the

  1. Morality is the refuge of the weak. Discuss with reference to Platos ideas on ...

    In a rather Hobbesian style, he suggests that the natural world is governed by the law of Force, without any restriction, and thus any man-made rule which intervenes in this process is unnatural. Like Hobbes, Callicles writes that social and moral norms are most often the results of contracts made

  2. A Discussion on the Defence of Compatibilism

    series of events and circumstances will determine the ?choice?, and knowledge of these events and circumstances will even allow us to predict the choice to be made. Suppose free will wins, and without consequence our person makes their choice. Take it back a step.

  1. Platonic love. The Symposium and the Phaedrus. Each of these works is a ...

    It is also stated that love is neither beautiful nor ugly, which, as Socrates connects, relates to good and evil. The continued motif is that Eros is the middle ground of several different qualities. Diotima elaborates to affirm that Eros?s parents are Resource and Need.

  2. The Myth of Mental Illness

    That is precisely what is so remarkable about sanity. The sane person prides himself on his ability to be unaffected by important facts, and interested in unimportant ones. He refers to this as having a sense of perspective, or keeping things 'in proportion'." The speculations schizophrenics spout as to the true nature of reality are not delusions so much as speculations distorted by misunderstanding of their own mental condition.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work