• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Not an age of reason, but a revolt against rationalism. (Peter Gay) Discuss this characterisation of the Enlightenment.

Extracts from this document...


Not an age of reason, but a revolt against rationalism. (Peter Gay) Discuss this characterisation of the Enlightenment. There is a carving by Giovanni Lapi that depicts Justice rejecting the death penalty1, this is a simple characterisation of the Enlightenment, taking one of its many aspects and displaying it in a plain form. The Enlightenment, which can, for argument's sake, be given the epoch of 1750-1800, is the movement that helped to change the outlook humans have on the world. Peter Gay asserts that the movement was spurned from the dissatisfaction contemporaries had with the previous period of intellectual thought: rationalism. The quest here is to discover what the Enlightenment was, and whether or not it was a movement bent on the rejection of rationalism. Benedictus Spinoza is a prime example of a rationalist, writing most of his works in the 1660s and 1670s. His book Ethics, Demonstrated in the Fashion of Geometry was so titled because he lay out his argument in the form of a mathematical proof, typical of the Rationalists. Rationalism was essentially an attempt to clarify the confusion that was brewing over the question of Christianity, and this was attempted via pure thought. ...read more.


The Enlightenment certainly was not purely and ideological and spiritual movement, it was the first intellectual movement to capture the imagination of society as a whole. "Indeed it may be helpful to see the Enlightenment as precisely that point in European history when... the secular intelligentsia emerged a relatively independent social force."3 The most important point in Porter's statement, is that these people were a 'social force', this meant they were influencing society through their teachings, writings and ideas. The phrase Enlightened Absolutism was coined not by eighteenth century scholars, but by modern historians who decided that the domestic reforms required after the wars in Europe coincided conveniently with the plethora of absolute rulers at the time. The Enlightenment saw the concept of patrimonial and legal despotism as the most desirable form of rule as it was the most reasonable. The idea of and Enlightened despot or absolutist is somewhat flawed, in as much as it is very difficult to find a ruler who both deemed himself to be part of the Enlightenment and believed in the fundamentals of the movement, such as faith in science. ...read more.


The fact remains that the age with which the Enlightenment is associated, that is 1750-1800, was without doubt an age of reason. From Bayle to Berkely, the enlightened individuals were putting their faith in science and their senses to discover answers about the world. Rationalists had done the same, but put their faith in their mind and thoughts instead of senses. Both groups were striving away from the irrationality of the Church, searching for a feasible explanation for human existence, which the Church could not provide. It took millions of years for man to discover reason, for it to take a further fifty or one hundred to discover a different kind of reason, does not amount to revolt. It is my belief that for the Enlightenment to reach its conclusions, the existence of Rationalism was necessary to inspire further thought. Similarly, it is my belief that the Christianity's existence was paramount to the emergence of Rationalist thought. None of these things are a revolt against the other, but an augmentation of their ideas. The revolt against rationalism cannot replace the age of reason, for they are one and the same thing. For mankind to be at the intellectual point we are in the twenty-first century, it was necessary for the Enlightenists to be reasonable in their search for an alternative path to rationalism. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our University Degree Buddhism section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related University Degree Buddhism essays

  1. Choderlos de Laclos: Les Liaisons Dangereuses - In what ways may "Les Liaisons Dangereuses" ...

    the spectrum with Valmont blaspheming that he shall carry away his intended victim (Presidente de Tourvel) "from her God". It is to possible to explain the libertine actions of the Marquise and the Vicomte by suggesting that it is a lack of these morals and traditional values that spurred them on to so ruthlessly pursue their goals.

  2. The development of the Enlightenment.

    But still, when it comes to religion, they all participated in one project. They always tried to replace those different traditions and religious beliefs that ruled the mankind with a new moral that had a rational and universal authority.

  1. The Eighteenth century saw a radical change in the way the church and state ...

    Therefore, it is totally legal. Thus, one who takes property, when it is according to the king's law that obtains in the municipality, does not do so as a robber."3 This interaction was similar on an economic scale. Jews of course had to interact economically and this did happen, but again it was subject to a stringent set of laws.

  2. Comparison between Christianity and Buddhism

    In it Buddha spells out a concrete way of living which will eventually lead to the goal of "Nirvana" (salvation). It is a path of positive intentional discipline, a structured way that governs all of life. Through the fourth truth Buddhism becomes a technique.

  1. Buddhism: The Concept of Dukkha

    This theory of Anatman accepts the existence of five aggregates (Skandhas). The Skandhas include physical processes (rupa) like solidity, fluidity, heat, motion i.e. material sense organs and their corresponding objects and mental processes (nama) which includes the last four aggregates.

  2. Summarise and discuss the origin and development of Mahayana Buddhism.

    Buddhahood, and this is what is referred to as Nirvana.18 This self existent body, or emptiness in reality is all that exists. All the other levels of the Buddhas nature are used as aids to assistance humanity gain this awareness of emptiness.

  1. Religion is both a problemwhere its structures of dominance have oppressed women, as ...

    In the Hindu religion women have fought for years to gain status in society. Previously, women were considered as homemakers and were responsible for looking after their homes and families. They were held responsible for serving their husband, taking care of their family and doing all household chores.

  2. Reality, Morality, and the Afterlife: A Comparison of Christian and Bhuddist Thought

    Indeed, Christianity persecuted and all but wiped out the Epicureans around the fourth century CE (Mulder). Not until well into the Renaissance would pure naturalism be taken seriously again. Perhaps the strongest New Testament scripture against naturalism is Colossians 2:8: "See to it that no one takes you captive through

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work