• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Critically discuss the proposition that the Treaty of Lisbon has completed the evolution of the EU legal system

Extracts from this document...


David McCabe 11090596 Words: 2837(excluding footnotes and bibliography) Question: Critically discuss the proposition that the Treaty of Lisbon has completed the evolution of the EU legal system 1 Introduction: 1.1 In the aftermath of WW2 the leaders of Europe faced many challenges, economically, politically and socially. It was in this aftermath that the framers of the original EC treaties sought to create an economic union which was to promote trade and commerce within the continent and thus encourage propensity and co operation in a land which had been haunted by war after war. Also in this aftermath, the Council of Europe was founded in 1949 to ensure the protection of human rights and thus ensure the atrocities of authoritarian governments did not re-occur.1 This paved the way for the creation of the Convention of human rights (referred from now on as the ECHR) which enshrined a set of common goals and standards to the countries which agreed to abide by the Convention. The European court of Human rights (referred from now on as the ECtHR) was also established as a mechanism to which human rights cases and states in breach of the Convention could have the issues adjudicated. 1.2 Upon the creation of the EEC, fundamental human rights were not considered part of its mandate, promoting stronger economic ties and breaking down trade barriers was to be its primary function. However, as the EC grew and successfully achieved its goals, it morphed into an institution which incorporated a wider mandate. This transformation can inherently be traced back to the early case law of its legal arm, the European Court of Justice (EUCJ), and the landmark decisions which it handed down.2 This 'judicial activism'3 has paved the way for what we now recognise as the European Union and its unique and thriving legal system. 1.3 In the Lisbon treaty, the EU has been given a legal personality and will finally ascend to the Convention of Human rights. ...read more.


The protection of equality between men and women does not, however, prevent the maintenance or adoption of measures providing for specific advantages in favour of the under-represented sex (i.e. positive discrimination). 4.5 It should be noted that the rights in the ECHR are considered to be a minimum standard of protection. It is recognised in article 52(3) of the Charter that the EU might provide a higher standard since it provides that "this provision shall not prevent Union law providing more extensive protection" .The result of this provision could be that the EU and national courts will build on and develop the ECHR rights through the Charter. 4.6 Another important issue is whether the ECJ has now been empowered to review any provision of national law in the light of the Charter. Even in areas where the EU can legislate, the reach of the Charter is not boundless. The Charter settles that national authorities, when acting outside the scope of EU law, are not bound by its provisions since it provides that the national authorities must respect EU fundamental rights "only when they are implementing Union law". In other words, it is still a condition for the EU courts in exercising their jurisdiction that the relevant national measures fall "within the scope" of EU law. The individuals haven't now gained the right to institute judicial proceedings on the basis of any provision of the Charter, in any situation, against any measure adopted by national or EU public authorities. 4.7 The EUCJ does makes clear that EU fundamental rights are binding on national authorities when they apply provisions of EU law which are based on protection for fundamental rights, or enforce and interpret EU rules or invoke EU derogation rules relating to the fundamental economic freedoms such as the free movement of goods 5 Has the aforementioned changes mentioned above completed the EU legal systems evolution? ...read more.


4 E. VOS, Regional Integration through dispute resolution: The EU experience (2005) 5 See Flaminio Costa v ENEL [1964] ECR 585 (6/64) 6 See NV Algemene Transporten Expeditie Onderneming van Gend en Loos v Nederlandse Administratis der Belastingen Case 26/62 [1963] ECR 1; [1963] CMLR 105 7 See Stauder 29/69 [1969] ECR 419 8 K Alter and S. Menunier 'Judicial Politics in the European Community' (1994) 26 Comparative Political Studies 9 See: Legal Reasoning of the Court of Justice in the Context of Principle of Equality, between Judicial Activism and Self-Restraint; by Pollicino - German Law Journal, pp. 283-317, 2004. 10 P. Pescatore, 'Les Droits de l'homme et l'int�gration Europ�enne' (1968) 4 Cahiers de Droit Europ�enne 629-673, 657. 11 29/69 [1969] ECR 419 12 11/70 [1970] ECR 1125 13 4/73 [1974] ECR 491, �13 14 Case C-185/95 P [1998] 15 I Pernice, 'Multilevel Constitutionalism in the European Union' (2002) 27 EULR 511 16 S. Douglas-Scott; 'A tale of two Courts: Strasbourg, Luxembourg and the growing European human rights acquis' (2006) 43 Common Market Law Review 629 17 Reflections on the Architecture of the EU after the Treaty of Lisbon: The European Judicial Approach to Fundamental Rights ELJ,Vol. 17, No. 5, September 2011; page 572 18 Pursuant to Art 218, para 10 TEU, the opinion may be sought by the Commission, Council or EP 19 Art. 6(1) of TEU 20 The EU and Issues of Human Rights Protection: Same Solutions to More Acute Problems? rederic van den Berghe European Law Journal, Vol. 16, No. 2, March 2010 21 The Charter of Fundamental Rights and the Environmental Policy Integration Principle (2011) Springer 22 The EU Charter of rights and the right to equality: S Peers (2011) 23 EU law module, notes from class 5 24 Caslav Pejovic: CIVIL LAW AND COMMON LAW: TWO DIFFERENT PATHS LEADING TO THE SAME GOAL 25 http://channels.isp.netscape.com/news/story.jsp?idq=/ff/story/1001/20111124/1707.htm 26 http://www.zerohedge.com/news/walk-thru-upcoming-european-treaty-changes-redemption-fund-plan-z-endgame 27 Sonia Morano-Foadi and Stelios Andreadakis: Reflections on the Architecture of the EU after the Treaty of Lisbon: The European Judicial Approach to Fundamental Rights by European Law Journal, Vol. 17, No. 5, September 2011, pp. 595-610 ?? ?? ?? ?? ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our University Degree European Union Law section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related University Degree European Union Law essays

  1. What are the outer limits of Article 28 EU?

    Similarly in Commission v Italy36 the description of 'chocolate substitute' contravened with Article 28, because it could affect consumer perception of chocolate, because the substitute may be seen as inferior37. These cases show that Dasonville has a very wide approach, and has a negative standpoint, which the court tried to

  2. The democratic deficit is a concept created by the euro sceptics regarding the European ...

    Every new financial plan has to be approved by the Parliament. The Treaty also abolishes previous distinction between 'compulsory' and 'non-compulsory' expenditure. The result is that Parliament and the Council determines all expenditure together. This change creates a new balance between the two institutions when approving the EU's budget.

  1. The Luxembourg Compromise is, in fact, an agreement in case very important national interests ...

    Whilst in Defrenne v SABENA10, the Court resolved that derogation from Treaty provisions would have no legal effect. However with the Luxembourg Compromise having effected such Community matters so significantly, directly and indirectly, that the Court would be unable to declare which decisions were to be invalid.

  2. Predatory pricing strategies in the European union: A case for legal reform.

    This might especially be the case where the predatory devices adopted by the powerful firm are coupled with other measures directly aiming at the segregation of the national markets of the Union. [FN12] Predatory Pricing Cases in the European Union: An Insistence on Short-Run Analyses and Intent Data Market power

  1. EU Freedom of Establishment. In this essay I will discuss the definition of establishment ...

    4.3The Klopp case can illustrate this point. Klopp5concerned a German national, who was a member of the D�sseldorf bar. He wished to practice in Paris as an advocate while remaining a member of the D�sseldorf bar and he had passed the French Bar Exam.

  2. Critically evaluate the impact of the E.U. Directive on Copyright in an Information Society, ...

    how can a service provider be held liable for the infringement of one of its subscribers, if it is almost impossible to control what information is posted on newsgroups and on webpages. Censorship in this case could be a way of controlling privacy.

  1. How far has the creation of a single market in goods resulted in the ...

    creates a formula for the courts to follow in defining scope of MEQRs. MEQRs are defined to be those which are "capable of hindering directly or indirectly, actually or potentially, intra-community trade". A requirement of a certificate of origin on imported whisky was held to be a prohibited MEQR in this case.

  2. EU Law - Albatros Pool problem case. Mark and Sunita must be advised that ...

    the retailer is able to prove to the satisfaction of the Department of Environment that the finished product has been manufactured from trees that have not been felled from endangered tropical forests. Superstore Ltd objects to the plastic bag tax and the restriction imposed on hard wood products.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work