• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

With reference to the works of two or more comparative lawyers and other sources, critically discuss the proposition that the comparative method drives integration rather than separation among legal systems:

Extracts from this document...


Q With reference to the works of two or more comparative lawyers and other sources, critically discuss the proposition that the comparative method drives integration rather than separation among legal systems: Introduction We are living in a globalised world which has seen a massive rise of wealth in countries such China, India and Brazil. Africa has been the fastest growing economy in the world for the past few years. This has been achieved mainly through increased international trade between countries from every continent in the world. We also live in a world where there is a belief that every human being has certain fundamental rights and is enshrined in numerous trans-national treaties. In this essay I will attempt to demonstrate that the comparative method of looking and dealing with law, does in fact encourage integration of legal systems. This convergence of legal systems stems from integration of the world as whole. This facilitates international transactions, increases the general welfare, promotes the diffusion of culture1, and leads to international understanding. From the economic point of view, uniformity and simplicity may reduce the transaction costs and significantly avoid uncertainties connected with the use of conflict of laws rules. The Issues that I am dealing with: The basis of my argument is that the world, in order to sustain this period of globalisation must incorporate methods in which countries can do business with each other, dispite their vastly different legal systems. In this essay I will firstly look and how, through necessity, there has been a huge growth in international commercial arbitration. ...read more.


In arbitration proceedings, the purpose of the proceeding is more a question of 'finding the truth' than 'settlement of the dispute'. It is important to remember that international arbitration agreements frequently provide for prior compulsory mediation. If the parties are unable to compose their differences with the assistance of a neutral mediator, then the purpose of arbitration is not to try to bring them together but to decide who should prevail and to what extent. The parties to arbitration will more likely accept the arbitrator as an impartial person to decide who should prevail if the arbitrator does not interfere actively in the proceedings and behaves in a somewhat reserved manner, as common law judges typically do. Finally, the purpose of 'finding the truth' as opposed to 'settlement of the dispute' is also important, because the arbitrator's decision cannot be corrected as easily as in court proceedings, where often an appeal is possible and the decision at first instance can be controlled by a higher court. Of course a civil law arbitrator will apply common law principles only if this is more effective to him and he will follow civil law rules for the rest. Thus the area of international commercial arbitration is not merely a place of clash and confrontation between common law and civil law but actually also a real point of intersection where common law and civil law are fused together to a certain degree. How the creation of the EU has integrated legal systems: The creation of European Union (EU) ...read more.


Volume 29 page 43, Dennis Campbell 6 See 'Some reflections on Teubnerian and Kelsenian Legal theory'- Conflict of laws (2007); for an excellent academic critique of the legal theory behind the choice process in ICA. 7 See 'A common layer's view of his civilian colleagues' 57 Loisiana Law Review 227 (1996); for a firsthand account of the process of drafting these agreements and examples of the comparative method in action. 8 See Comparative law of international arbitration by Jean-Fran�ois Poudret, S�bastien Besson 9 W Van Gerven "ECJ Case-Law as a Means of Unification of Private Law" (1997) 2 European Review of Private Law 293. 10 A Common law for Europe by Gian Antonio Benacchio, Barbara Pasa 11 For example, Resolution on Action to Bring into line the Private Law of the Member States, 1989 O.J. C158/400, and Resolution on the Harmonization of Certain Sectors of the Private Law of the Member States, 1994 O.J. C205/518. 12 See O Lando & H Beale (eds) Principles of European Contract Law (Kluwer, The Hague, 2000). 13 "rules of law which in principle have no legally binding force but which nevertheless may have practical effects" as defined in 'Soft Law' ELR 14 14 The State of the European Union: Law, Politics, and Society Vol. 6 (2003) p221 15 Zweigert K, Koetz H, supra note 40 at 261 16 See EC Competition Law Essay By Veronica Hagenfeldt 17 Nippon Yusen Kasha v. Karageorgis 1 W.L.R. 1093 at 1095-1095. 18 See Perspectives for the unification and harmonisation of family law in Europe By Katharina Boele-Woelk ?? ?? ?? ?? ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our University Degree European Union Law section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related University Degree European Union Law essays

  1. Predatory pricing strategies in the European union: A case for legal reform.

    the former's temporary loss-making strategy could not have constituted a rational business decision. [FN17] Perhaps it should have defined the relevant market as comprising neighbouring countries, from which imports to the United Kingdom could originate. The intent element and the AKZO decision In its AKZO decision, the Commission rejected the

  2. EU Freedom of Establishment. In this essay I will discuss the definition of establishment ...

    suspect that migrating companies may try to evade local laws and regulations. 4.5 In the Daily Mail case6, the newspaper publisher wanted to move its central management and control to the Netherlands but also to maintain its legal personality and status as a company in the UK.

  1. Discuss the rules of Competition law and how the European Commission enforces these Laws.

    Negative Clearance The easy way for an undertaking to make sure that it complies with the Treaty is to ask the commission before it goes into an agreement. They will get a formal notification that the agreement does not fall into the scope of Article 81 (1)

  2. How far has the creation of a single market in goods resulted in the ...

    Such classification by the court was probably eased by Directive 70/5034 was issued to deal with defining the scope of MEQRs both distinctly and indistinctly applicable. This created into Treaty Article 3735 but then deleted by the treaty of Amsterdam.

  1. Critically discuss the proposition that the Treaty of Lisbon has completed the evolution of ...

    However, the EUCJ soon became extremely active in following 'a vigorous policy of legal integration, particularly in the first decades of the Community's existence,'4 giving substance to the 'framework' Treaties, expanding Union competences, enhancing the effectiveness of Union law and developing the principle of supremacy5, the doctrine of direct effect6 and the general principles of Union law7.

  2. European Law

    it to the commission to deal with the matter, and in turn creates a more contributory role for citizens in Community enforcement of law. Secondly, an action may not be brought at all because some employees are not even aware of their rights.

  1. EU Law

    referred to an arbitrator and no public authority is involved in the decision to choose arbitration, then the arbitrator is not a court or tribunal for the purposes of Art 234. This was a reference from a privately appointed arbitration body which was refused despite the fact that the Arbitrator's decision was based on law, including Community Law, was binding.

  2. EU Law - Albatros Pool problem case. Mark and Sunita must be advised that ...

    Mark can be advised that it is the Foster case which establishes that a public body is defined as any body made responsible for providing a public service under the auspices and control of the state "which has for that purpose special powers beyond which result from the normal rules applicable in relations between individuals".

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work