• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

A Comparison between Strindbergs Miss Julie and Henrik Ibsens A Dolls House

Extracts from this document...


A Comparison between Strindberg?s Miss Julie and Henrik Ibsen?s A Doll?s House Miss Julie which was published nine years after Ibsen? realist play A Doll?s House, is an example of naturalist movement which tried to show that heredity, environment and social conditions rather than hard work shape an individual?s fate. Strindberg considering himself a naturalist and being an opponent of Ibsen?s ideas in A Doll?s House, wrote Miss Julie with a naturalist pessimism and rejected the idea of women being independent and liberating themselves from the unfortunate situations they were in. The physical worlds of the two plays are somehow the same. In both cases the space is an interior one and the scene is a single room fully described by the author. However Ibsen has used more props on the stage in order to make it more lifelike. Time plays an important role in the two plays. As the time passes the peaceful happy mood of the beginning of the play changes to a nervous one and the protagonist approaches her doom. We can feel the same anxiety that the central characters feel from passing of the time. ...read more.


My father, my mother, I myself? I myself? I haven't got a self at all, I haven't got a thought which I don't get from my father, I haven't got a passion which I don't get from my mother, and the latest phase the equality of men and women that I got from my fiance, whom I called a scoundrel for his pains. How then can it be my own fault?? But Nora doesn?t understand her problem until the last pages of the play when she observes the reaction of her husband to her secret. The second difference between these two characters is their treatment of the problem. Miss Julie completely knowing her problem never takes a chance to leave her father and to find her true identity. Even when she is obliged to leave the house and flee because of the so called shame she has brought to her father, she asks Jean to accompany her although she hates him. She can?t be independent from men, she finds it impossible to leave home and live on her own, she can?t think and act independently and she even begs Jean to give her orders. ...read more.


She suggests that changing the places of males and females in society or even mixing them causes catastrophe, and he also elaborates the naturalistic belief that one has no role in making his or her own future. Another difference between the two plays may be in the approach the writers have taken to build up to the final incidents of the plays. Strindberg uses not logically organized dialogues as it may happen in natural life. But in A Doll?s House there are lots of carefully chosen sentences uttered by character that all in all may give us a clue what the character will do in the future. For example Helmer?s fine speeches about how he hates borrowing money and being in debt and his criticizing Krogstad for the crime he has committed, all ironically point to his possible reaction to finding out about Nora?s secret. As a conclusion, we can say that Miss Julie written as a response to A Doll?s House tries to question the feministic values of Ibsen?s work and for this reason either intentionally or no has been influenced by A Doll?s House. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our University Degree Other Play Writes section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related University Degree Other Play Writes essays

  1. Langston Hughess play Mulatto: A Tragedy of the Deep South, opens on Colonel ...

    Norwood beats the young Robert, a beating that he never forgets. Norwood also sends Robert away to school for six years, so he does not have to be around him. However, this backfires on Norwood. Since Robert has been heavily educated outside of the plantation, when he returns he finds

  2. It is misleading to see Ibsen as a critic of society. His plays ...

    The way in which she pays back the loan is also quite admirable, I have had some other sources of income, of course. Last winter I was lucky enough to get quite a bit of copying to do. So I shut myself up every night and sat and wrote through to the small hours of the morning.

  1. An analysis of the dramatic structure of Kalidasa's "Abhinjanasakunthalam"

    The Nandi is thus an embryo of the play. (Lockwood & Bhatt 1) A mere read through would not reveal the inner meanings of the Nandi because many ideas are just suggested, which makes it all the more complex for even a well read reader to grasp.

  2. Simmilarities and Differences between the Vladimir and Estragon and Pozzo and Lucky Pair ...

    When Beckett started writing he did not have a visual image of Vladimir and Estragon. They are never referred to as tramps in the text. Estragon is given perhaps the most minimal description in the play. He is only described as wearing "rags", walking with a limp and being lighter than Vladimir.

  1. Japanese Americans. It is best to examine the Issei, Nesei relationship by looking at ...

    But you made so many mistakes. It was a mistake to have ever left Japan. It was a mistake to leave Japan and to come to America and to have two sons and it was a mistake to think that you could keep us completely Japanese in a country such as America.

  2. Dandyism and Moralism in Oscar Wilde's An Ideal Husband

    Why don?t you take him for your model? LORD GORING: I think I shall father [?] This scene is ironic in the way that, on one hand we have Lord Caversham, who comes to talk of a serious matter to his son, whom he wants to convince that he has gained an age were he ought to get

  1. Womens Depression; The Other Side of Look Back in Anger

    Same is Jimmy?s approach with Helena Charles in the first few days of her living in Porters? apartment. Jimmy shows his provoking and humiliating abuses and comments upon her also, as he calls her a ?bitch?, explains that she is one of his ?natural enemies? and such like comments.

  2. Pygmalion. It is the desire to obtain an education, or at least the appearance ...

    However, in Eliza?s situation an education as a child was not feasible, for with a mother no longer in the picture and a

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work