• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Can we write about the tragedy of Hamlet in any meaningful fashion

Extracts from this document...


Can we write about the tragedy of 'Hamlet' in any meaningful fashion? It is highly problematic to use the word 'tragedy' when referring to Shakespeare's works. 'Hamlet' has long been considered the best example of what one would call a tragedy out of all Shakespeare's plays, yet this generalisation, as it proves to be, is the most troublesome of all. Perhaps the reason for this lies in the unknown extent of Shakespeare's familiarity with what one would call traditional tragedy, whose routes lie in the principles set down by the Greeks and Aristotle. Aristotle, in setting down the so-called rules of tragedy in his 'Poetics' talks of an essential element; 'Hamartia', fundamental in the downfall of the prominent (usually this prominence is reflected in a high up hierarchical figure, perhaps of the nobility)'tragic hero' and which, furthermore the character must recognise. This fall from grace marks a reversal of the character's fortune, placing great emphasis on an element of fate; the 'strumpet fortune' that Hamlet so frequently refers to. Aristotle, echoing the Greek view that tragedy is didactic also talks of a fundamental element, Catharsis, at the tragic hero's downfall where the audience's emotions are purged and purified. Taking this into account, the links between Shakespeare's dramatic works and Greek tragedy are nevertheless unproved and tenuous. It is likely, however, that elements of 'tragedy' would have filtered through somehow, perhaps through Latin literature, in the form of works such as Horace's 'Ars Poetica'. In an attempt to best balance such uncertainties, it seems that one must reject Aristotle as the only guide and furthermore, in attempting to incorporate 'Shakespearean tragedy', all one can do is make comparisons to his other plays, which are considered to be 'tragedies'. 'Hamlet' can be separated from other tragedies because of the further idea, which percolates through the play, of the revenge tradition. This provides the play, at least in terms of plot with a sense of additional inevitability that Hamlet, the 'revenger', will get his revenge. ...read more.


His militaristic father (even his father's ghost wears military attire) represents all the things he views as lacking in himself; strength, nobleness, swiftness of action and stability, hence his frequent comparisons, "but no more like my father than I to Hercules." This distinction echoes the Rennaissance view of men as separable into two character-types, men of action and conversely men who are passive. Indeed when he says, "O villain, villain, smiling damned villain! My tables..." there is an evident paradox where he immediately recognises his colourful use of language in the ironic announcement of his changed self; Shakespeare implying that Hamlet is defined by his scholarly character, and perhaps is unsuited fundamentally to the role he must play. The tendency to delay, which many people unwittingly refer to as Hamlet's tragic flaw is rather unconvincing. Hamlet frequently shows recognition of what he views to be a flaw in his character and for this reason people perhaps assume that this is his tragic flaw. One must question, however, the extent to which he truly delays, whether his descriptions of himself as 'gutless' are fair; and in doing so it appears that the flaw is merely a product of Hamlet's own abusive self-analysis, perhaps as much a figment of his imagination as he fears his meeting with the ghost might have been. Hamlet makes the decision to act mad, in an attempt to deter the suspicions of the people surrounding him, particularly Claudius; "as I perchance hereafter shall think meet to put an antic disposition on". He takes further steps to remove suspicions and safeguard his plan by making Horatio swear not to hint at the truth, "at such time seeing me, never shall... by pronouncing of some doubtful phrase as 'Well, we know'... this do swear." In making the decision to put his love for Orphelia aside, so that he can focus upon the task of revenging his father's murder he shows further decisiveness in making what is understandably a difficult choice. ...read more.


to the profoundest pit", is a marked contrast to Hamlet. The eventful clashing of these forces, in the form of a confused duel between Hamlet and Laertes, marks a purging of emotion and undeniable catharsis that is evidence of tragedy. Fortinbras has it in mind to take back his father's lost land as revenge for his own father's death and his decisiveness leads Hamlet to reflect that true greatness lies in this character trait; "readiness is all". Old Hamlet killed Old Fortinbras on the day Hamlet was born and this ushers in an important element of fate. It seems that the tragedy of 'Hamlet' lies in the fact that he is unfit for the task that circumstance and fate has provided him. It might be argued that he has a tragic flaw, yet it seems more accurate to refer to him in terms of a failed revenge figure than a tragic hero. The nature of the revenge figure, who has the duty to murder is extremely different from both Aristotelian and other Shakespearean versions of tragedy. In 'Hamlet', Shakespeare displays what Keats describes as "negative capability." He shows openness in his work. It is significantly not didactic in that there is no specific moral and thus the play is left open for the audience to interpret how they wish. Keats praised Shakespeare for the complexity and variation of his works and also for their 'suddenness', viewing his works to mark the birth of 'modern tragedy'. The uncertainty, which swamps almost every aspect of the play, is married to the idea of exploration and debate. Shakespeare's 'Hamlet', however, contradicts a great deal of the essential qualities, which define 'tragedy', and whist there is a structure it is very loose. For this reason, it seems, that one is merely playing with words when questioning the nature of tragedy in 'Hamlet', and furthermore that, in spite of the multitude of tragic elements punctuating the play, one must inevitably and controversially conclude that it is impossible to fit 'Hamlet' into the genre of Tragedy. ?? ?? ?? ?? Alexander Phillips - 1 - ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our University Degree Hamlet section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related University Degree Hamlet essays

  1. Thomas Kyd - Bring out the significance of play within the play in Kyd's ...

    and Bel-imperia stabs herself also. The audience is under the impression that the stabbings are only an illusion. After the killing Heironimo appears on the stage with the dead body of his murdered son Horatio. He makes a long speech narrating the whole story of the murder of Horatio and the revenge that he has been contemplating and that he has at last taken.

  2. The Effects of Ambiguity in Hamlet

    When also betrays a possible promiscuous side she tells Laertes Do not as some ungracious pastors do,/Show me the steep and thorny way to heaven,/Whiles like a puff'd and reckless libertine/Himself the primrose path of dalliance treads,/And recks not his own rede.

  1. Hamlet and The Spanish Tragedy - a brief comparative study -

    It makes the situation even more complex. In the Spanish tragedy, Bel-Imperia is a central person, a positive heroine. Several lines depart from her, and she is one of the reasons why the ghost of Andrea is suffering.

  2. Definition Of A Hero

    The willingness to help comes from one's conscious and a deep gut feeling that comes from doing the right thing. Courage is very important, without it a hero will not be able to use their willingness to help. Courage gives a person the strength to go through with an action to help others where others would run.

  1. Endgame" is written in the unique style associated with Samuel Beckett's works- a minimalist, ...

    The broken, abrupt and often unfinished sentences, as well as the isolated phrases, also show the character's uncertainty and loneliness. 546692 EN1021, Reading Literature The opening of a play often adheres to certain dramatic conventions, however Beckett turns upside down the idea of coherent narrative structure and refuses to follow

  2. Portrayal of women in 'Hamlet'

    Shakespeare did not want to place great emphasis on the love story; if Hamlet had been madly in love with Ophelia, it might have interfered with the main storyline. She had to be a subordinate character, unequal to Hamlet in spirit or intelligence; otherwise she would have been more inspiring and able to help Hamlet.

  1. Several modern dramas have had a strong social impact shortly after production and/or publication. ...

    Critic Kenneth Tynan also agreed with Hobson's review of the play. Tynan opened his review of the play with ' a special virtue attaches to plays which remind the drama of how much it can do without and still exist.'

  2. 'El medico de su honra is best considered as a play to be read, ...

    Amy R. Williamsen comments 'No one analysis can encompass all the possible interpretations of a play and their performative permutations'. Contradictions are resolved as the director goes down a certain route to show his vision of Calder�n's work, a work that to a large extent relies on the variety of

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work