• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Compare and contrast the poems 'East moors' by Gillian Clarke with R.S Thomas' Welsh Landscape.

Extracts from this document...


Compare and contrast the poems 'East moors' by Gillian Clarke with R.S Thomas` Welsh Landscape. Both Gillian Clarke and R.S Thomas were born in Cardiff in 1937 and 1913 respectively. Before becoming a poet, Gillian Clarke had been a part-time lecturer and also an editor, she is very much a poet of place, in her case, Wales, and likes to see herself as being the voice of the Welsh people. All of her stories are true and she portrays her experiences very well through the language used in her poetry. She is now a tutor on the university of Glamorgan's M.A in writing. Thomas was a Welsh clergyman and poet whose lucid, austere verse expresses an undeviating affirmation of the values of the common man. Thomas was educated in Wales and ordained in the Church of Wales (1936), in which he held several appointments, including vicar of St. Hywyn (Aberdaron) with St. Mary (Bodferi) from 1967, as well as rector of Rhiw with Llanfaelrhys from 1973.He published his first volume of poetry in 1946 and gradually developed his unadorned style with each new collection. ...read more.


The impression that I get of East Moors is that it is a dark miserable place where if you are not local you are not welcome; it strikes me as a typical Welsh steelworks village, which only the close knit local community can understand. Being a country parson for many years meant that R.S Thomas was more than accustomed to the countryside, and it is the countryside which was the chosen setting for 'Welsh Landscape'. R.S. Thomas was very much influenced by the romantics Wordsworth and Coleridge, who themselves, concentrated more on the country than the town and who wished to convey their own emotions. Thomas was a typical example of a poet who stubbornly ignored critics and voiced his own controversial opinions that modern poetry must be urban. Words and phrases such as 'wild sky', 'rivers', 'tractor', 'hum of machine', 'strung woods', 'owls', and 'fields corners', all suggest that R.S Thomas` poem is set in the countryside. Both poets use nature in their poem to help emphasise the mood. Clarke uses it by saying '...an icy rain is blowing through this town.' ...read more.


East Moors is structured with a touch of ballad, it has formal verses and firm endings to the stanzas. Gillian Clarke said she wanted a poem with stanzas of the same length because she felt that it is a kind of song. She has very much achieved this with her poem, because, not only is it like a song, it has strong, authoritative endings to each stanza. The structure of both poems adds to their impact and makes them even more effective. It's been enjoyable reading both poems and learning about the backgrounds of both poets Gillian Clarke and R.S Thomas. My personal favourite poem was R.S Thomas' Welsh Landscape because I agree with it entirely, I believe that Wales is indeed a great nation in danger of losing everything that it has going for it, if they don't do something about it fast, and Thomas sums this up well in the last line when he says that the Welsh people are 'worrying the carcase of an old song'. This illustrates that they are still hanging on to their reputation of being the land of song, and it seems almost unsettling to him. That's why I personally preferred R.S Thomas' Welsh Landscape over Gillian Clarke's' East Moors. Adam Hughes 10MPB ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our University Degree Thomas Hardy section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related University Degree Thomas Hardy essays

  1. In what ways does Hardy respond to the demands of writing public poetry as ...

    "bedrenches the wagonette", and reduce "A time of such quality" to a mere "phantom figure", contrasting the events to the extent that it

  2. A vision of the future?

    We reached the surface, but instead of hearing yelling and the sounds of gunfire all we saw was the hundreds of members of the rebellion standing around in the same state of confusion. The truth dawns on us as we see Commander Lee standing at the fore of the group - it was a drill.

  1. A comparrison of Lore and Cyndyllan on a tractor by R S Thomas

    The weather is depicted as an enemy of Job. In the first quatrain the weather's cruelty is reinforced by the dramatic use of a pair of metaphors; "After the slow poison And treachery of the seasons" The imagery seen at the beginning of Cynddylan On A Tractor is of Cynddylan moving from the old to the new.

  2. The power of imagery

    The third stanza speaks of The Sea of Faith. If the sea is humanity's religious faith, then the "earth's shore" portrays the irreligious world, expanding as the sea's tide, having turned, retreats. In the next stanza, The Sea of Faith, which lays like a belt around the earth's land, becomes "...

  1. The Effects of Thomas Paine's Common Sense

    This says that the king is wiser than those in commons who were already more intelligent than the king. This presents much confusion and ambiguity to the American Colonists about the English Constitution. As if to show that them that the Constitution and this idea of a king are not what some people may seem to believe they are.

  2. How does Thomas Hardy present men and women and their relationships in the three ...

    This adds to the humour of the story, as can be seen when Tony is trying to respond to the advances of Hannah, whilst Milly and Unity are within earshot. He "whispered very soft, 'I haven't quite promised her, and I think I can get out of it', he then quietly adds that he will ask Hannah to marry him.

  1. An exploration of the importance of setting in 'Tess of the D'Urbervilles' by Thomas ...

    Tess's personal fatalism is a typical characteristic of her upbringing in rural poverty; she was 'reared in the lonely country nooks where fatalism is a strong sentiment.' Proulx's literary style is unusual, in comparison with Hardy's, but in a world where authors strive to find original structural devices, 'The Shipping News' is not so remarkable.

  2. Dylan Marlais Thomas.

    the relationship of his own body to the world of nature is a major preoccupation. While the first verse uses natural imagery of flowers and trees, the second of rocks and streams, the third begins with the imagery of water but moves to imagery of earth ('quicksand' while evoking life

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work