• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Discuss the language of religion in Frank McCourt's "Angela's Ashes" and James Joyce's "A Portrait of the Artist as a Young Man" in relation to one another and to the various uses of language in general, taking into account the importance of this language

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Discuss the language of religion in Frank McCourt's "Angela's Ashes" and James Joyce's "A Portrait of the Artist as a Young Man" in relation to one another and to the various uses of language in general, taking into account the importance of this language in an Irish context. When attempting to formulate concrete lists that define the usages of language, one of the first usages that frequently arises is 'language to inform'. Another frequently mentioned usage is 'language to persuade', and the list goes on for far longer than this besides. Along with various forms of media, as well as human speech itself, religion is no stranger to the use of language (written and spoken) to its own advantage. When combined with the 'language question', which is constantly up for discussion in Irish history, the issue becomes further convoluted. There is much to be said about how James Joyce and Frank McCourt treat these issues in their respective novels (A Portrait of the Artist as a Young Man [hereafter referred to as Portrait for brevity] and Angela's Ashes), even though this is by no means the principal topic of either novel. The main discussion shall centre on the language of religion and how both authors present it, but for some of the paper, the importance of the Irish language itself in a religious context shall be given due attention. In terms of language and Christian belief, one particular list begins thus: "1. Sentences expressing commands, injunctions, exhortations, wishes etc., such as 'Thou shalt love the Lord thy God', 'Let us love one another' and so on. 2. Sentences expressing moral views, such as 'Brethren, these things ought not so to be', 'It is not good for man to be alone' etc."1 The remaining points highlight sentences expressing factual truths, sentences expressing analytic truths, and sentences that inform the reader about the supernatural and metaphysical. ...read more.

Middle

Both authors use other languages as metaphors to further illustrate this point. Towards the end of Portrait, Dedalus describes a conversation with Ghezzi, which "began in Italian and ended in pidgin English" [Joyce, 283], which in itself denotes the confusion and transience often associated with the language of religion (not to mention language in general). Both novels make great use of Latin (and in particular, memorising it ritualistically without necessarily memorising the meaning) to much the same end. This obsessive quality associated with Latin can also be found in many of Seamus Heaney's language poems, demarcating Latin as something deeply associated with Ireland and Irish language in general as well as the language of the church. One critic, though, dismisses Latin as merely "a starting point rather than a model"7 - this seems greatly erroneous in light of all of the Latinate references in both texts and the way this is made to tie in with Irish. This quotation from Angela's Ashes seems fairly representative of how both authors choose to demonstrate this line of reasoning: "We have to know them [the prayers and creeds] in Irish and English and if we forget an Irish word and use English he goes into a rage and goes at us with the stick. If he had his way we'd be learning our religion in Latin, the language of the saints who communed intimately with God and His Holy Mother, the language of the early Christians, who huddled in the catacombs and went forth to die on rack and sword, who expired in the foaming jaws of the ravenous lion. Irish is fine for patriots, English for traitors and informers, but it's the Latin that gains us entrance to heaven itself. It's the Latin the martyrs prayed in when the barbarians pulled out their nails and cut off their skin inch by inch." [McCourt, 130] The reiteration of Latin, Latin, Latin relates directly to other anecdotes in both novels: McCourt's father taking the part of priest to ...read more.

Conclusion

Equally, when Stephen is at the university, Latin is used as a joke-his friends translate colloquial phrases like "peace over the whole bloody globe" into Latin because they find the academic sound of the translation amusing. This jocular use of Latin mocks both the young men's education and the stern, serious manner in which Latin is used in the church. These linguistic jokes demonstrate that Stephen is no longer serious about religion. The two central texts on which this paper concentrates are positioned at a key crossroads of Irish literature. It is hardly surprising that the two authors give such diverse messages in their works regarding the language of religion itself, for the history of the use of language in the church is nothing short of convoluted. Ireland imposes a set of oppressive binaries, namely in the form of religion and nationalism, from which the authors can escape only through the ambiguity of language. Both authors portray confusion in this area, with Stephen Dedalus in Portrait ironically using rather hieratic language as he attempts to elevate himself and his life above and beyond what religion can provide. McCourt, however, is more philosophical as the language of religion becomes clearer with age, pointing out that the ambiguity of language is used in a great many other contexts, such as the euphemistic terming of death as 'going to sleep'. The two authors successfully demonstrate how language is an instrument of control as well as of communication, with linguistic forms allowing significance to be conveyed and distorted; they also successfully demonstrate how hearers can be both manipulated and informed, and (in some cases) manipulated while they suppose they are being informed.13 The many fluctuations between Irish, English and Latin in the church's history of this period leave many question marks over religious language for both authors. Ultimately, though, the language of religion is ultimately manipulated for personal or political gain - either by the church, to stop their children 'leaving the flock'; or, in the case of Joyce, by the protagonist Stephen Dedalus, in order to justify his desertion of religion altogether. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our University Degree Other Authors section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related University Degree Other Authors essays

  1. Gabriel Garcia Marquez uses a non-omniscient first-person narrator in his novel, Chronicle of a ...

    Clearly, the Marquez's choice of a first-person narrator was to establish subjectivity. Of the scarce comments made by the narrator with intention to assess the case, the majority if not every comment is far from objective. Not only does he exclaim that "[his] personal opinion is that [Santiago] died without

  2. Nancy Mairs Essay Synthesis of Mairs Three Essays on the Argument for the ...

    'Because a difficult life is more complicated than an easy one, it offers opportunities for developing a greater range of response to experience: a true generosity of spirit' (Mairs 114, Doing It the Hard Way). She went for the personal growth that carrying out difficult tasks stimulates (Mairs 109).

  1. A close reading of an extract from Aphra Behn's "Oroonoko".

    She has capitalized a number words throughout the excerpt, many of which stand within sentences. This suggests that she has put certain emphasis on them and wishes the reader to take note.

  2. Symbolism in Lord of The Flies

    His fatalistic view of humanity is directly conflicted with the rationalism on which Golding was raised. His father's optimism held that humankind can be perfected with enough effort and anti-social tendencies. On the contrary Golding perceived human nature as equal parts, good and evil.1 Lord of the Flies is an

  1. Gail Jones, Sixty Lights, set in Australia, India and England in the 19th Century, ...

    dwelling on the past, she moves on to the prospects of the future. This futuristic and unconventional thought process is in its essence modernist. Lucy, although from the Victorian era, is a modernist character, unhindered or swayed by the conventions of her social construct, searching, discovering and capturing the truths that are imbedded in the world.

  2. With reference to Judith Butler's Precarious Lives, explain how Chris Abani's novel The Virgin ...

    Certainly the way Abani describes the ?weaving into a tapestry? implies Butler?s concept that our body belongs to society, that society, or rather governmentality seeks to control and defend us against anything that threatens our Western livelihood. This livelihood is represented by the ?steps? that form the unique elements of society, more importantly American society.

  1. 'Burmese Days' by George Orwell

    ?He did not speak of his sympathy for the Burmese? and follows the ?White man?s code of silence in the East?. Holderness et al assert that if one takes the novel as a critique of imperialism, one cannot ?find in this text a critique of racist assumptions?.

  2. Analysing Four American Short Stories - Joyce Carol Oates: Capital Punishment (1992)

    Is my daughter all right?? in the third paragraph and ?She isn?t hurt? You?re sure?? by the bottom of the same page. t isn?t until she is older, toward the end of the short story, that she seems to regard him with more respect.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work