• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Discuss The Similarities And Differences In Themes And Ideas As Shown In 'Stone Cold' And 'A Modest Proposal'.

Extracts from this document...


Discuss The Similarities And Differences In Themes And Ideas As Shown In 'Stone Cold' And 'A Modest Proposal' Homelessness was a problem 200 years ago as it is now. Authors Jonathan Swift and Robert Swindells try to eradicate this feature in books. Jonathan wrote an effective pamphlet where homeless children make good food! And Swindells' book, intended for children, wrote a day to day life of a homeless teenager, but the only catch is there is a serial killer on the loose... In this essay I am going to compare these 2 pieces, Swift's written in 1729 and a 20th century pamphlet and Swindells' in 1993, a 20th century book. I am going to compare the ways the writers have treated the issue of 'homelessness' and how successful they have been. Robert Swindells book for children, 'Stone Cold' portrays and effective experience of life on the streets. Link the main character is a normal 16 year old lad. He has just left school with no credible GCSEs. His dad ran away with a mistress when he was 14, but now his mum, 'Sheila', has a new boyfriend, 'Vince', whom Link hates. The new man is his mother's life is too much for link and the fact that he and Vince are enemies isn't making matters any better. Link is slowly driven out his home in Bradford. ...read more.


His constant reference to words for the homeless, 'blighters', 'dossers', 'junkies' makes him a much more credible and fun character than Link. Most of his speech patterns (sentence structure) are short, clipped sentences' Swindells main aim in Link is to make the reader appreciate their life. He tries to make the reader understand and empathy the issue of homelessness and at times through the character of Link does this extremely well. But Swindells main aim in Shelter is to produce the plot in the novel and to make it exciting. He does this successfully and at most times Shelter is a more powerful character than Link. Shelter's aim is to ridicule the homeless from the streets of London whereas Link happens to be on the streets of London because of small problems at home. Shelter is a more credible character and that is why the book looks more like a 'thriller' where a serial killer on the loose. A Modest Proposal was written in 1729 by Jonathan Swift. Swift was born in Dublin 1667. At the age of 27 he became a clergyman. A modest Proposal was written as a pamphlet. In the pamphlet Swift tries to argue the points made in A Modest Proposal through logic and reasoning to raise the issue of homelessness. The arguments made in A Modest Proposal are: He argues that children would provide excellent food for the people of Britain as he writes, "A young healthy child well nursed is at a year old a most delicious, nourishing and wholesome food whether stewed, roasted or boiled." ...read more.


The book looks more like a thriller than what Swindells intended for it to be (a book raising the issue of homelessness). This is due to the character of the serial-killer being a more credible character thus undermining the issue of homelessness. But Stone Cold does provide a very good insight into the lives of homeless people and has an effective ending where Link is still homeless, but Shelter the killer gets life in prison, which means Shelter gets a roof over his head, a bed and three meals a day whereas Link is still on the streets. A modest proposal is very successful at trying to raise the issue of homelessness. Swift uses the style of 'logic and reasoning' to provoke people and draw attention to child poverty and homelessness. The use of satire in the first person style adds to causing outrage and offence to make people aware of the issues and also to attack the landlords and the rich by satire. I think overall A Modest Proposal is more successful than Stone Cold in trying to raise the issue of homelessness due to the fact that Stone Cold, after reading, looks more like a 'serial-killer' type thriller whereas A Modest Proposal raises the issue of homelessness more effectively by Swift's use of satire in trying to cause outrage and offence to make people aware of the issues of homelessness. Adam Laher Batley High School For Boys ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our University Degree Jonathan Swift section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related University Degree Jonathan Swift essays

  1. Satirical Pre 19th century Poetry

    In this extract, 'Milchisedeck' represents Henry VIII, 'Moloc' is a false God, which exists in the form of a bull, which is again referring to Wolsey and 'mercyfull' to 'mercyless' the better Henry VIII was, the worse Wolsey grew. If John Skelton was caught being disrespectful towards the royalty, he could have been beheaded for treason.

  2. How does Swift satirise human behaviour within Book IV of Gulliver's Travels?

    enormities, he dreaded lest the corruption of that faculty might be worse than brutality itself."10 Again Swift shows the flaws of humanity and the contrast between reason and corruption, therefore satirising humans' concept of reason. The Houyhnhnms attack both man and Gulliver's pride which concludes Gulliver's belief in the Houyhnhnms perfection.

  1. 'A modest proposal could be read by an insensitive reader as a cruel, inhuman, ...

    It is these emotional detached feelings that lead to the atrocities committed against the Irish citizens. Swift's proposal is also interspersed with words such as 'souls' and 'desponding spirit' too. This choice of emotive vocabulary is in sharp contrast to the depersonalising language previously used.

  2. Compare book 4 of Gulliver's Travels with the rest of the text.

    As a result of the combined experiences in the lands he has visited and his enlightening experience with the horses, Gulliver has awakened. He has stepped out of Plato's cave and seen the sun; he no longer wishes to stare at the shadows with the others.xiv When he returns home,

  1. This paper explains that Gulliver's voyage to the land of the

    Gulliver is grief-stricken but agrees to leave. He fashions a canoe and makes his way to a nearby island, where he is picked up by a Portuguese ship captain who treats him well, though Gulliver cannot help now seeing the captain-and all humans-as shamefully Yahoo like.

  2. The importance of the Fens as a surrounding context in Graham Swift's Waterland

    Also at the very end of the novel, when he dives into the water he does not emerge as he is 'returning' to where he belongs, he becomes one with the environment. Describing the phlegm as 'Neither liquid nor solid; a viscous semi-fluid.

  1. 'The two basic modes of satire are good-humoured teasing and savage attack.' Discuss The ...

    Here we have two examples of Pope's use of the heroic couplet to comment on what he considers to be faults in society. Having the tortoise and elephant "unite" creates a pleasant atmosphere of harmony, most notably, though, in the animal kingdom as opposed to the human world.

  2. Discuss satire in Jonathan Swift's novel Gulliver's Travels - Part IV.

    In the end, all Gulliver wanted to do is to stay with the Houyhnhnms and learn more about them. When he was finally forced to go home, he was disgusted to see how the 'Yahoos' at home lived. He saw the potential of what the human lifestyle could be and wanted nothing to do with society.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work