Does the simplicity of Simon Armitage's work detract from the complexity of the social issues he deals with in Kid and Killing Time

Authors Avatar

Does the simplicity of Simon Armitage’s work detract from the

complexity of the social issues he deals with in Kid and Killing Time

Born in 1963 in Huddersfield Yorkshire, Simon Armitage is often grouped with Tony Harrison, Ted Hughes not only because of his heritage, but also because of his style.  Many of his poems are social commentaries with a straight forward and somewhat cynical outlook, typical of the ‘northern poet’.  Armitage uses a simplistic style of writing, common lexis and usually quite overt subject matter.  His anthologies range in topics, including the largely biographical Book of Matches which incorporates numerous stories about his childhood, both serious and light-hearted.  Armitage was commissioned to write Killing Time for the millennium and it was later dramatised and shown television on the 1 January 2000.  It is a thousand line poem reflecting on the previous years events; sometimes comic, satirical and dry, and at other times extremely powerful and serious.  It is questionable, therefore, how Armitage can combine his simple style with a poignant and sombre subject matter with any degree of success.  His collection Kid contains similar style poems, as well as some more optimistic poetry, so by comparing Killing Time with a selection of poetry from Kid, Armitage’s methods of merging two seemingly opposing factors will become apparent.

Perhaps Simon Armitage’s most well known poem is named just that; ‘Poem’. On the page the poem appears to be of a regular pattern; three stanzas consisting of four lines and a final couplet to finish.  The obvious anaphora of ‘And’ at the start of every line of the quatrains make the poem appear to flow on the page, that is, without looking at the subject matter.  The lines end in a half rhyme throughout the stanzas, ‘nurse’, ‘church’, ‘worse’ and ‘purse’ (Kid 29 : 9,10,11,12).  It is safe, therefore, to say that Armitage has used a very basic yet effective structure for ‘Poem’.  However, when we read the poem and take in what Armitage is describing, this comes as a shock.  The initial three lines of each verse are normal, mundane even; ‘And what he didn’t spend each week he saved’ (Kid 29:6) but when the reader arrives at the fourth, they receive a surprise change of tone.  Or rather, the tone does not change at all, and this is what astonishes the reader.

And every week he tipped up half his wage.

And what he didn’t spend each week he saved.

And praised his wife for every meal she made.

And once, for laughing, punched her in the face.                        (Kid 29 : 5-8)

With three lines of pleasant description of this man, we do not expect the fourth to be such a sharp variation or said in such an unfeeling way.  Yet, if the reader contemplates the three situations this man is in, his unexpected reactions are not really so alarming.  These types of situations occur everyday all over the world and this is summarised in the last couplet; ‘sometimes he did this, sometimes he did that’ (Kid 29:14).  Armitage seems to be implying that every person has different sides to their personalities, often oppositions, and sides that we are not proud of.  These will never change, so are accepted and when ‘they rated him’ (Kid 29:13) ‘they’ did not condemn his actions, but showed indifference.  The simplicity of the style of ‘Poem’ helps Armitage draw attention to the fourth lines in each stanza.  By also separating the couplet at the end the ‘moral’, almost, is clear to the reader.  Although here Armitage’s message is not as significant as in some of his other poems, the combination of short, sharp lines and cutting, shocking subject matter work together to convey it effectively.  

Join now!

        With a similar apathetic outlook, ‘Robinson’s Life Sentence’ (Kid 56) explores the monotony of everyday life.  Immediately the title of the poem alludes to the tedium and inescapable nature of life.  In an interview with The Independent newspaper, Simon Armitage admitted to ‘“a general feeling that life itself is meaningless – that there is no big scheme of things”’ (Knight 2002) and ‘Robinson’s Life Sentence’ is a true reflection of this sentiment.  ‘Sentence’, though, brings an image of something that will end, something that will eventually terminate, and to some extent this is true; of course life will end for ...

This is a preview of the whole essay