How far is 'Haymaking' typical of Thomas' poetry?

Authors Avatar

James Williams               How far is ‘Haymaking’ typical of Thomas’               January ‘03

poetry?

‘Haymaking’ is very typical of a poem by Edward Thomas. This is shown through many common devices that are present in ‘Haymaking’ as well as many of his other poems. I shall outline and elaborate these on these devices in this essay.

‘Haymaking’ is a description of a snapshot in time. There was a thunderstorm the night before and the reader is initially led to believe that the storm is the reason that everything is so still in the poem, but half way through the poem, Thomas begins to describe the activities of the Haymakers who are having a break in silence as they “leaned on their rakes”. So the stillness of the poem can work on many levels. There is the idea of the ‘calm after the storm’ and the Haymakers having a rest. Also, however, there is the fact that the poet, Edward Thomas, is writing his poem from a snapshot in time where if he was describing a photograph, everything would be still in the picture.

One of the most recognisable devices that Edward Thomas uses in his poetry is referring to England as “old”. This could imply many things. Thomas could use the term “old” in the literal sense that it is ‘ancient’, ‘unchanging’ and with a ‘sense of permanence’ in the world even though it has been threatened by war. It could also mean that England has grown wise due to its age and has experienced many things. As well as these ideas, Thomas comes across as very patriotic towards England. In ‘Haymaking’, Thomas refers to “All is old” so although he doesn’t actually say that England is old, we as the reader know that he is subtly including England. In ‘The Manor Farm’, Thomas directly refers to England as “Old already” with the use of a capital letter for “old” which helps to directly associate the word “old” with “England”.

Join now!

Throughout much of his poetry, Thomas uses very in-depth descriptions of features of England such as the countryside and nature in general. He doesn’t just describe things literally as he sees them either. It is as though his descriptions are more his point of view of things. Such as in ‘Haymaking’ when he is describing the water in the mill as having “tossing crystals, happier than any crowd of children”. An identical device is used in the opening sentence to “The Manor Farm” where Thomas is describing the mud “ran and sparkled down each side of the road” as ...

This is a preview of the whole essay