• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

"Representation makes dummies of us all" - How is this sentiment reflected in Carol Ann Duffy's poetry?

Extracts from this document...


"Representation makes dummies of us all" How is this sentiment reflected in Carol Ann Duffy's poetry? "There is no terror in the bang, only in the anticipation of it" 1 Carol Ann Duffy's poetry is often criticised for being very simple, in both the lexis and the manner in which it is delivered. However, time must be taken to read the 'unsaid', that is, the words that are not written on the page, which create textured, layered poems. Poems such as 'We Remember Your Childhood Well' (The Other Country : 24) exemplify this; one side of the conversation is represented, but it is the other voice, the other story, which intrigues the reader and it is left to them to imagine the missing dialogue. "The whole thing is inside your head" is particularly chilling to try and presume what the absent voice has experienced. The combination of both the spoken and unspoken at once, creates more depth to poetry and it is this that the reader has in mind when trying to understand it. The Alfred Hitchcock quote above explains exactly this, how a reader will anticipate the unsaid, sometimes to a more extreme degree than the reality. The question is, how a poet, or indeed any other author, can reasonably represent a character, feeling or message to their reader accurately if each reader will individually interpret their poem, novel or text. A reviewer for the Sunday Times wrote; "So often with Duffy does the reader say 'Yes, that's it exactly' that she could well become the representative poet of the present day" (Selected Poems : Reverse Cover). ...read more.


'Recognition' from Selling Manhattan is another example of the use of word association ad distorted structure to construct images. Cheese. Kleenex. It did happen. I lay in my slip on wet grass, laughing. Years. I had to rush out blind in a hot flush [...] (Selected Poems : 41) The speaker falls into broken sentences and selects just key words to describe the events. The reader is then forced to do the reverse; take the words and create the situation around them, like having a blank canvas with a few outlines upon it, and recreating a painting. Of course this is not always achievable and if put into practise, every painting would be different. Thus, the reader may not recreate the same scene that Duffy was imagining when writing. It seems that in trying to represent character and identity, Duffy achieves only in restricting the view the reader has. As in 'Education for Leisure' Carol Ann Duffy often confuses the reader by representing two, or sometimes more, personas within the same character. The best example of this is in 'Psychopath' from Selling Manhattan (Selected Poems : 43-6). The first persona is enforced from the start, in the title. We are told that the speaker is a "Psychopath", the judgement is already made for us, though whether this is an accurate reflection of the character is questionable. There is an odd juxtaposition between this preconceived perception and the beautifully lyrical manner in which the character descries his actions and thoughts. The opposites are continued throughout the poem; from the fairground bright lights and happiness, to the talk of r**e and s****l acts, the innocent girl and the knowing speaker. ...read more.


However, the reader must accept these perceptions and opinion as, after all, this is what is written; there is no second opinion. Ultimately, the acceptance of these words makes us dummies, with no choice but to accept, attempt to interpret and try to understand, and enjoy Carol Ann Duffy's poetry. Word Count : 2013 Primary Texts Duffy, Carol Ann., 1985. Standing Female n**e. Anvil Press : London Duffy, Carol Ann., 1987. Selling Manhattan. Anvil Press : London Duffy, Carol Ann., 1990. The Other Country. Anvil Press : London. Duffy, Carol Ann., 1993. Mean Time. Anvil Press : London Duffy, Carol Ann., 1994. Selected Poems. Penguin : London. Duffy, Carol Ann., 1999. The World's Wife. Picador : London Secondary Texts Bakhtin, M.M., 1981. Holquist, M. ed., Emerson, C., trans. The Dialogic Imagination. University of Texas Press : Austin Connell, P.E., 2005. Raising the subject : Indeterminacy in the poetry of Carol Ann Duffy. University of Hull : Kingston-Upon-Hull Freud, S., 1948 (1901). The Psychopathology of Everyday Life. Ernst Benn : London Gregson, I., 1996. Comtemporary Poetry and Postmodernism. Macmillan : Basingstoke Kenigan, J., 2004. Notes from the Home Front : Contemporary British Poetry. Essays In Critcism. (54,2) Michelis & Rowland., 2005. The Poetry of Carol Ann Duffy : Choosing tough words. Years Work of English Studies, (84,1) pp. 764-853 Porter, E., 1999. "What like is it? Landscape and Language in Carol Ann Duffy's Love Poetry. Neohelicon, (26, 1) pp. 79-80 Robinson, A., 1988. Instabilities in Contemporary British Poetry. Macmillan : Basingstoke Thomas, J.E., 1998-9. The intolerable wrestle with words: Carol Ann Duffy. Bete Noire, (6) pp.78-88 1 Alfred Hitchcock - Source unknown 1 200607924 Contemporary Poetry Professor Reid ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our University Degree Other Poets section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related University Degree Other Poets essays

  1. "Preface to a Twenty Volume Suicide Note Analysis

    The writer also uses vivid images to reach the reader. One particularly powerful image is the scene of the speaker's looking into his daughter's room; the action is doubled in his daughter's "peeking into her own hands." Not only is this image the climax of the poem, but can also be interpreted as a symbol of continuity.

  2. Discuss the importance of the ideas of roots and rootlessness in post-colonial writing by ...

    He witnesses the changes made to the society and is not quite as how he remembers it. The title 'Homecoming' is ironic as it reflects on who Walcott is thus represents his 'roots'. Walcott comes from Anse La Raye, a Quarter in St Lucia, where there are mainly fishers and agricultural workers.

  1. Dylan Thomas' The Hand that Signed the Paper

    Thomas uses metaphor and metonymy throughout this poem. He metonymically links kings and fingers to nations at war; the titular hand is linked to the convention at Versailles of Britain, France, Italy, Japan and the United States. Reviewing the first stanza, Thomas is able to distill a years-long war down to a single sentence using these techniques.

  2. Displacement and Doubt in Post-Colonial Literature. Olive Seniors Gardening in the Tropics is ...

    country in which I grew up in as I have internalized this landscape. Not lost on me as a child was the fact that the beautiful landscape marked a lot of hardship and pain and so on." 3 The landscape and scenery of her homeland symbolized the painful experiences by

  1. Charles Simics Butcher Shop is a poem of four-line stanzas that shows how the ...

    Metaphorically , through a difficult act of thinking those things that surround people all the time are wrested from their "unmeaning" state and are made to mean something.

  2. This essay is mainly focused on Elizabeth Bishops poem One Art, and the recurrent ...

    Up to this point it seems as if the poet is trying to provide the reader with a guide devoted to the mastering of "art losing". Suggesting that by following her simple advices, the reader can, too, achieve such art.

  1. In What Way Imagist Poetry Influences Modernists

    One of the lines in H. D.'s poem "Epitaph" also illustrates her obsession with the Greek culture, "Greek flower; Greek ecstasy /reclaims for ever". What is more, it is known that H.D.'s poems achieved an unprecedented success and she was regarded as "the purest imagist" (David 1976, p.339). Her poems were usually composed of short sentences.

  2. The Death of Marilyn Monroe, by Sharon Olds, on the surface speaks about the ...

    The author also gives no setting, but she sets the tone pretty straightforward to imply the impact of Marilyn Monroe was a prominent death for these ambulance men. The lines more often than not are not complete, with the remainder of the sentences placed at the start of the following line.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work