• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Utilitarianism Analysing the validity of its criticism in Dickens' "Hard Times".

Extracts from this document...


Tutorial Assignment DevDutta Roll No. 0877 B.A. (Hons.) English Utilitarianism - Analysing the validity of its criticism in Hard Times In the beginning of the 19th Century, Jeremy Bentham gave a systematic account of the previously fragmented philosophy of Utilitarianism. His approach towards the social constructs that governed pleasure and pain, or reward and punishment, was founded largely in hedonism. He held that humans were ruled solely by pleasure (or the absence of it) and therefore all actions must be weighed in regard to acquisition of maximum amount of pleasure for the maximum number of people. Utilitarianism deconstructs every action and evaluates it with the help of logic and facts. It stresses the importance of an individual's happiness before others. This theory in principle was appealing to many. He set down seven factors for the weighing of pleasure - Intensity(the amount of pain/pleasure), Duration(duration of time), Certainty(how much an action is likely to cause pleasure), Proximity( how close the feeling would be to the action), Fecundity( how likely it is to cause further sensations), Extent( the number of people affected) and Purity(the amounts of opposing sensations involved). Bentham went further to suggest that fundamental morality must also be defined not from a socially ethical perspective but rather from an analysis of the consequent pleasure/pain to be generated from it.Thus, in his view, laws needed to be flexible according to society's changing perception of pain and pleasure. ...read more.


Sissy Jupe is another very important character, because she is one of the sole representatives of 'Fancy' or rather, a value system based on emotional judgment, in a town full of Utilitarian dogma. We see that after all events have transpired, Sissy is the one who 'survives' with the ideology she started out. Also, Dickens was very concerned about the welfare of the poor working class people. In his novels, they are always victims of an unfeeling capitalist system which only takes interest in squeezing maximum output for minimum wages. Stephen Blackpool is a classic example of a simple, honest worker who falls victim to the politics of a class division between rich and poor. He is essentially a martyr for the cause of integrity. It is important to note that even the workers' union shows the same selfish attitude as Bounderby. Thus it is not suggested that working class people do not have baser human qualities. Dickens has artfully demonstrated the monstrous nature of a generation that is taught to embrace egoism and to discard emotion. Tom and Bitzer are the pitiful epitomes of Utilitarian upbringing, in Dickens' viewpoint. Tom secretly hates the system he has been forced to swallow, but is ultimately a spineless, selfish man who does not have any moral standing and tricks his own friend and employer. ...read more.


Mill also actively voiced his concern for the apparent disregardof intellectual pleasure that first-generation Utilitarianism advocated. Mill argued that people could only enjoy subtle forms of pleasure if they were given the capacity to do so, through education. Saying that momentary intercourse was better than a long-lasting relationship, because it provided higher pleasure, was wrong on the account that it ignored the intrinsic value of emotional happiness and security brought about by love (not l**t). He said that the 'desirable' in Bentham's philosophy should not be seen as 'what can be desired' but rather 'what ought to be desired', paving the way for intellectual betterment through the guidance of higher rationality. In conclusion, it is the opinion of many critics that Dickens has ably mocked hedonistic ideology, but his criticism does not do justice to the benefits of Utilitarian self-analysis. Also, Bentham wrote some important treatises on social issues, including a call for the emancipation of women, because in his philosophy both men and women deserved equal happiness because there was no significant intellectual disparity between the two sexes. It was only because women were denied education that they could not voice their problems in the public forum. Mill furthered this treatise and made efforts to actualise it, laying grounds for the philosophical backbone of the feminist movement. Merely focusing on hyperbolic flaws of utilitarianism, Dickens' Hard Times unfairly disregards the many finer attributes of Bentham's rationale. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our University Degree Other Authors section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related University Degree Other Authors essays

  1. In Crime and Punishment, both Sonya and Dunya are the embodiments of Christian virtue, ...

    Before she enters the street as a prostitute, Sonya asks Katerina, "What, Katerina Ivanovna, must I really go and do such a thing?"4 Her question to Katerina is reminiscent of Jesus' prayer before his arrest, anticipating his crucifixion. Jesus asks, "O My Father, if it is possible, let this cup

  2. The Thematic Parallels Between Crime and Punishment and The Brothers Karamazov

    Inspired by Ivan' s convictions of antireligious amorality, Smerdyakov, blind to Ivan's feeble devotion to the theories that he himself advocates, kills Fyodor in a world that he believes has no God, a world in which "everything is permitted."3

  1. In what ways, and to what extent, does Mrs Dalloway illustrate Woolfs intention to ...

    Woolf wanted fiction to get at something abstract, to use the mundane events of life to somehow create the bigger picture, there were no massive and life changing events in Mrs Dalloway, Woolf didn't use conventional methods to build tension and drama, even Septimus's eventual suicide was played down, the plot was purposely based around a party.

  2. Diaspora in Junot Diaz's "The Brief Wondrous Life of Oscar Wao".

    On Oscar's last trip to Santo Domingo, however, he decides to 'sacrifice' himself to the f*k� in order to be the last person in his family to suffer from the curse. Due to the f*k�, Oscar's story ends as bloodily as his ancestors' did.

  1. Du Bois theory of propaganda and African American media portrayal is supported by events ...

    The newspapers coverage of Bigger?s case is heavily imprinted by racial prejudice and intolerance. Bigger falls victim in the hands of media which seek to benefit from his situation. Wright portrays the media as one of the forces that leads to Bigger?s execution, as the sensationalist press stirs up a furor over his case in order to sell newspapers.

  2. Sorting, Longing, Seeing and Saving: An Analysis of Magical Devices in Harry Potter ...

    each individual, and Harry?s Patronus takes on the shape of a stag. In Prisoner of Azkaban, we learn that Harry?s Patronus is a stag because of his father?s animagus form, also a stag. This enhances the deep connection he has with his parents, as he draws on them for positive memories and strength.

  1. Comparing Julian Barnes A History of the World in 10 Chapters to Elisabeth ...

    In doing so, she comes to a description of the characteristics of this ?subdivision of postmodernist fiction? (Wesseling vii). An interest in history can be found in Barnes? work as well, for instance in the novels Flaubert?s Parrot (1984), Staring at the Sun (1986)

  2. Assess the extent to which Great Expectations is a realist novel

    Furthermore the revelation of Magwitch as Pip?s benefactor show that despite being a convicted criminal he still has a true conscience and is capable of performing worthy actions. Both of these examples point to the idea that a person?s label or positioning in society is far less important than their

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work