• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Official crime statistics can be knocked down and so far sideways those responsible criminologists ignore them. Discuss.

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Official crime statistics can be knocked down and so far sideways those responsible criminologists ignore them. Discuss.

Name of module: Criminal Justice Policy

Name of lecturer: Coretta Phillips

Date of submission: 7th November 2002

Name of student: Sharon Ingrid Kwok (200210386)

Introduction

Social scientist has been aware of the pitfalls and limitation in official crime statistics. Arguments have surrounded the official crime statistics to be sideways, and they can be distorted by social and institutional factors.  (Reiner, Maguire and Coleman et al) In this assignment we will analyse the problems surrounding the interpretation of official crime statistics and illustrate how they are constructed and consequently where their systematic biases lies.

Dark figures-non-reported and non-recorded criminal behaviour

The core problem interpretating the official statistics on crimes that have been recorded by the police arise from the fact that they are incomplete and biased. For an event to be recorded and known to police category it has to overcome two hurdles: Addressing of Issues and Appropriate handling of procedures.

Criminal behaviour must come to the attention of the police and should be recorded as such by the police using his appropriate procedures. Many criminal events may fail to enter the record at either stage. They may not come to be known to the police at all, even they do, the police may not record them as crimes for variety of reasons. Therefore, the problems of non-reporting and non-recording lead to the official crime statistics becoming unreliable. (Reiner, 1996)

Many offences will fail to become apparent to police due to various social factors.  Awareness is such a problem. Some individuals, organisations or government bodies may not be aware that a crime has been committed against them.

...read more.

Middle

Apart from the question of the coverage of the official crime statistics, many technical problems exist in the precise construction of the figures that may hamper the recorded numbers misleading and unreliable. (Reiner, 1996) The basic problem is transforming complex incidents into precise numbers of offences for the purpose of recording rates of crime. There are important questions to ask whereby the method in which the individual crimes are counted. Some kinds of offence tend to be repeated many times within a short period, to the extent that there may be several separate actions or people involved they may consider to form part of one concerted criminal behavior. The number of offences that should be recorded is a matter of interpretation and judgment, without a clear counting guideline, consistency will be unattainable, (Reiner, 1996) thus it will generate difficulty in comparison.  

In 1980, an attempt was introduced to establish clearer rules -The instructions for the preparation of statistics relating to crime by Home Office; (Reiner, 1996; Coleman et al., 1996) nevertheless there is still room for ambiguity and discretion about accounting for crime which could bring about variations in figures.

The general rule is now that if several offences are committed ‘in one incident’, only the most serious is counted, with the exception when violence is involved, in which case the rule is ‘one offence for one victim’. (Maguire, 1997; Reiner, 1996) Though, with regard to the other offences there is only the guideline that a number of incidents which form part of the same series should be counted as one offence. This clearly

...read more.

Conclusion

The official crime statistics, like the core object of the study-crime, is ultimately, a socially construct: (Maguire, 1997l; Coleman et al., 1996) The social culture affected people reporting behaviour; the criminal justice bureaucracies’ practice and culture influenced the recording and counting method.  By understanding more about the official crime statistics, it can help us to understand some important aspects of process of criminal justice bureaucracies as well as the role of the public. Furthermore, as we understand more about the elements of the way in which the official picture of crime is produced, it can enlighten us to develop a picture of crime, which is different from the official one, as well as to understand more about the structure and culture of society in a broader sense. (Coleman et al., 1996) However, what we have to bear in mind is, we need to understand how the data were complied and what they represent, hence, aware the pitfall of official crime statistics when we use it in developing criminological theories. To the extent, a better understanding in all forms of statistics is essential in developing theories.

Bibliography

Coleman, C. and Moynihan, J. Understanding Crime Data, Milton Keynes: Open University Press, 1996

Davis, J., Frances, P. and Jupp, V. Invisible Crimes, Hampshire: Macmillan, 1999

Davis, J., Croall, H. and Tyrer, J. Criminal Justice: An Introduction to the Criminal Justice System in England and Wales. Essex: Longman, 1995

Maguire, M. ‘Crime Statistics, Patterns and Trends, in M. Maguire, R. Morgan and R. Reiner (eds.) The Oxford Handbook of Criminology, Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1997, second edition.

Mayhew, P. ‘Researching the State of Crime: Local, National and International Victim Surveys’. In R. King and E. Wincup (eds.) Doing Research on Crime and Justice, Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2000

Reiner, R. ‘The Mystery of the Missing Crimes’ in R. Levitas and W. Guy (eds.) Interpretating Official Statistics, London: Routledge, 1996.

...read more.

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our University Degree Statistics section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related University Degree Statistics essays

  1. Stochastic Applications of Actuarial Models with R coding

    based on . MATLAB is used to find the exponential of the matrix R and the appropriate probabilities are extracted from the matrices P(3) and P(5). For the 10 year probabilities, the solution of P(t) will change every year after 5 years due to changes in transition rates matrix.

  2. How to lie with statistics

    This claim played crucial role in the final decision of the jury and O.J.Simpson was acquitted in 1995. Let's analyse this case more formally, instead of using common sense. But for that we need to introduce some probability theory concepts and theorems.

  1. How statistical interpretation can cause data to appear misleading

    Leading questions such as "do you agree that..?" and double barrelled questions for example "do you agree that smoking should be banned because it can cause cancer?" can provide misleading results, as with the latter question the individual may agree that smoking should be banned, but not because it can cause cancer but for another factor such as

  2. Dress code study. The method of random sampling in this investigation was cluster ...

    10 conditions satisfied nq = 60(0.433) = 25.98 nq ? 10 Mean, � = 34.0 Standard deviation, ? = 3.84 What is the probability that majority of the female ABC University students wish to abolish the restriction of wearing shirt with sleeves not reaching wrists? Pr (x ?

  1. Hypothesis method

    A week before one of my friend and I went to the store and collected the data asking some customer and the store keeper. The objective of this study was to test whether being vegetarian influences the amount spent in Supermarket store.

  2. Factors predicting disclosure of chronic illness status in the workplace and general well-being for ...

    As general well-being questionnaire includes items such as 'how often have you become easily tired' (i.e., 'worn-out' factor) and 'how often have you been tense or jittery' (i.e., 'up-tight' factor), the higher the score, the worse the perception of general well-being.

  1. Does the data indicate that the revised (one week) forecast is significantly more accurate ...

    As is showed clearly in the previous graph, the rate of decline might follow the rules of linear regression, therefore, we assume the equation is Y= a + bX, where x is number of years and y is the rate of decline.

  2. HND business decision making

    These figures were then calculated using quartiles and percentiles. Using quartiles to analyse further into the results, it shows the variance in the data given if we take the analyse further and uses inter quartile range analysis. From the data it shows swimming has the least variance with one 1 inter quartile range where as football, aerobics and basketball have a range of 9.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work