While most noir films conjure up images of terror in black-and-white settings, 'Leave Her To Heaven' manages to fall into the noir category despite its lush technicolor scenery and handsome interiors.

Authors Avatar

Do Ngoc Trang PHAM

Course: BA Film and TV Production

Module: Cinema Landmarks

Essay title: Taking one film screened in the module analyse its narrative structure and the film techniques or style used to realise this.


'Leave Her To Heaven' (directed by John.M Stahl, 1945) was certainly regarded as one of the most successful noir films during the 40s for its very dark story but was depicted in glorious technicolour. The story with popular author Richard Harland (Cornel Wilde) meeting Ellen Berent (Gene Tierney) , an alluring woman on a train. Ellen quickly charmed Richard with her dazzling looks and strong personality; soon, despite her own engagement to a prominent lawyer, she proposes their marriage. The new couple move to Richard's secluded lakeside lodge, where they also had to take care of his crippled younger brother, Danny (Darryl Hickman). As the weeks go by, Ellen's near-obsessive love for Richard begins to brood anger, hatred and jealousy, culminating in the cruellest of acts.

The plot of 'Leave Her To Heaven’ is extremely complex, however, the narrative structure, the film techniques and style have intelligently used to deliver the whole message of the film to the audience.

'Leave Her To Heaven' starts with a man’s having just been released from prison. As he comes back, the local people react as if something terrible were happening. The whole story behind this man is then revealed by his lawyer through a flashback.

This is a very classic start in noir film, the audience is introduced to the dark world of crime, a world full of shadows and fears. The narrative structure of 'Leave Her To Heaven' is the conflict and resolution structure. According to Ken Fuson of the Des Moines Register, every story at its heart is a story of conflict and resolution and the story of 'Leave Her To Heaven' has established its conflict early and clearly. The conflict is that what happens to the successful author Richard Harland who is sentenced to a term in prison. The story then is unfolded with the flashback.

Also, the flashback is introduced with a little blur to notify the changes in time and place and the voice over in the background connotes that the story is told from the lawyer's point of view. The blur-editing is used wisely throughout the film in order to introduce jumps in time and changes in spaces. These help to get the storyline develop quickly.

The opening sequence of the lawyer's story is on the train where Richard sees a woman reading his book. She drops the book and Richard helps her pick it up. From that moment, the woman holds the gaze at Richard. A close up at the woman's face to emphasises her emotions but somehow is “mental” expression, the shot also focus on the gaze and shows tensions. The woman is reading Richard's book but does not recognise him , instead, she stares at him for his appearance, a resemblance of her deceased father. Later on, when they get off the train, he finds out that the woman, with her mother and sister, is back for her father's funeral. A close-up shot at her sister's face to establish the girl's interest in Richard. Throughout the film, there're quite a few close-up and mid-shot of Ruth – the woman's sister that also introduce Ruth's affair on Richard. For example, the sequence where Ruth plays the piano and when she is doing gardening in Back To The Moon. These are to explain Ruth's confess to Richard at the end of the film that she has always loved him.

Join now!

As mentioned above, the family come back for funeral but Ellen, the woman, wears a fur coat while her mother and sister wear “normal clothes. Fur coat is the symbol of wealth and success but it seems not only inappropriate for funerals but also to hide the body and the characteristics of Ellen, something that is “different” from others.

In the story, Ellen is really different from others. She is a “psycho”, a mentally ill woman who “wants to have her husband – Richard all to herself at any price”. The reason behinds this is never fully explained. ...

This is a preview of the whole essay