• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Discuss how Paul Willis has examined the purpose of education in Learning to Labour (1977). You must direct your response to issues in Education Studies.

Extracts from this document...


Discuss how Paul Willis has examined the purpose of education. You must direct your response to issues in Education Studies. Real or fictitious, we are instantly drawn to characters that possess similar qualities to our own, such as personality traits or life experiences or maybe even physical characteristics. Quite often we feel we relate to that individual in a personal way. It makes a biographical or back story line that much more interesting. For these reasons, the story of Paul Willis has appealed to me a great deal. Due to this enhanced and enthusiastic curiosity, I have thoroughly enjoyed researching for the following essay that you are about to read. On occasion similar individuals come into direct contact. 'Learning to Labour (1977)' by Paul Willis was critically acclaimed for his ethnographic account of the lives of twelve white working class boys floundering their way through the British education system. Willis related to these boys, and it was reciprocated back to him, perhaps making it the reason it was such a success. With this essay, I intend to explore the ways in which Willis analysed the intention of education. Drawing on his experiences, four key themes will be examined, with a fifth deep-rooted in an underlying manner throughout this paper. Firstly, with Willis displaying a typically Marxist viewpoint, I will investigate the ways in which he scrutinizes the cultures and cultural constructs within the whole schooling experience. His work was monumental but it did have its criticisms. Secondly, what are the effects of social class on individual education? Is there an escape from the restrictions of class via education? Can Paul Willis personally relate to this subject? Thirdly, what does Willis say about the development of sub-cultures within education? Focussing on the white working-class, Paul Willis examines particular factors within an educational setting that have an adverse effect and thus, cause the creation of non-conformist sub-cultures. ...read more.


Armaline & Farber (2000) consider this in their article 'Reconsiderations': 'this 'penetration' into the ideology of schooling efficacy and the deep structure of socio-economic functioning was not so much a conscious insight as a lived experience, a felt, sensed experience reinforced by working-class culture in general and family and neighbourhood life in particular (p.164)'. Further on in their writing, Armaline & Farber display an objective of rectifying the role of the schooling system applying, even somewhat manipulating, the teachings of Paul Willis to their advantage: 'We think the messages of Willis and Weis can be used to conceptualize reform beyond mere reintegration of students into an objectifying and dehumanizing social enterprise devoid of social vision rooted in the concern for participatory political and economic democracy. We also believe it is our responsibility as educators and citizens to engage in this reform debate by infusing the insights of the likes of Willis and Weis not only into our own writing and teaching, but also into the broader public discourse (p.167)'. On the other hand, they do note that Paul Willis is concerned with the role of the teacher within the educational context of social relationships and delivery of information: 'Willis saw the authority of the teacher based on an exchange, a trade-off of official knowledge for respect, guidance of control (Willis, 63-64). Within that exchange, the teacher (any teacher) was seen to occupy a higher position due to superior knowledge and held the key to a series of other exchanges in which the student was supposed to take part (p.163)'. To venture a guess, Paul Willis may have come across some exceptional teachers in his rise through the educational ranks. What does Paul Willis say about the development of sub-cultures due to education? Focussing on the white working-class, Willis examines particular factors within an educational setting that carry an adverse effect and thus, cause the creation of non-conformist sub-cultures, represented by his term, the 'counter-culture'. ...read more.


in plans to attend higher education. Willis believes that personal motivation needs to be encouraged, even raised from the individual by influences from within the social and cultural world. After all, he irrefutably targets the social relations and connections of the 'counter-culture' and the member's peer groups, which are proved by the conclusion of Collier et al: 'In addition to having appropriate educational qualifications for university entry, the profile of a 'typical' potential working-class participant would be a young person who believes he/she has the ability to pass a degree and is prepared to postpone earning money to go to university. They are likely to have received considerable encouragement, especially from their families (p.259)'. 'The models imply that an effective strategy for widening participation in higher education may require rather more than increasing the number of available degree places for suitably qualified candidates. It points to the importance of earlier formative experiences, primarily in educational contexts but also within the family, in developing self-belief in one's capacities and abilities, positive attitudes towards education and studying, and the fostering and encouragement of personal motivation to continue in education (Collier et al, 2003, p.260)'. Just like the 'lads', I identified with Paul Willis. I hail from a similar background and upbringing and share many of his beliefs. Seeking to become a school teacher myself, I had a personal curiosity into the insights of Willis towards the subject matter displayed throughout the themes discussed in this essay. The themes of structure and institution, social class and the creation of sub-groups, all within the framework of Education Studies, link cohesively with the work and influence of Paul Willis. During the introduction, I challenged you, the reader to consider personal motivation throughout the key themes. By doing this, did it change your perspective at all? A high degree of personal motivation allows for an individual to conquer any hurdles they face in the achievement of their objectives. Paul Willis displayed a great deal of personal motivation to reach his goals. Can you now relate to his optimistic view of education? Word Count: 3154. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our University Degree Applied Sociology section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related University Degree Applied Sociology essays

  1. Marked by a teacher

    Since all sorts of gender inequality continues to exist today, and some of the ...

    4 star(s)

    In this way, influences from the family structure allow children to acquire basic skills in accordance with their genders. The United States places women and men unequally. These variations among gender relations might be considered to be biologically-rooted dispositions. It could be that men, on average, are more aggressive than

  2. Bureaucratic Structure and Personality.

    'A common destiny for the people who work together, sharing same interests especially since there is little competition as far as promotion is in terms of seniority' (P546)

  1. The humanistic approach

    it is usually not so clear-cut as to which stage one may be at, often we may have one foot at one level and one in another. Two steps forward may often mean two steps back. This is a problem when trying to use the humanistic approach to try to

  2. This essay will explain what social divisions are and why interrelationships amongst them are ...

    leisure activities, fears of having drinks spiked or the threat of s****l assault. Women co-produced a narrative account of material risk practices associated with their particular social position and constructed themselves as active risk-takers. In this respect, narratives were performative of feminine identities transgressive of traditional restrictive gender stereotypes, illustrating

  1. The Gender Divide and Achievement

    One I have already mentioned is state intervention and funding by the government to help pupils in need, especially boys. Research found that the most worrying underachievement was amongst boys from low-income homes and by the end of 1998, failing boys were being described as the 'public burden number one'

  2. Popular Culture Essay. In my essay I will scrutinise feminism in advertising. We live ...

    This cause s****l violence which forces women to reduce their movements and this type of popular culture which creates an environment is not acceptable in society. Feminists need to come up with more powerful arguments that the ones mentioned above to solve this matter that is rising from stereotyping and showing women as s****l objects.

  1. Critically explore some of the issues that should be considered when conducting research in ...

    ?Childhood studies research emphasizes the need to recognise children as agents not objects to represent children?s voice and to have children properly involved in all stages of research?(Gregory et al 2005,p.98). Informed consent is vital when it comes to research involved with children, as Informed consent is required to protect privacy.

  2. Reasons for Working. How does paid employment affect your identity?

    my bank branch, retail outlets?). I have even felt the need to do this myself, by presenting an enthusiastic, smartly dressed and professional self to potential employers in order to get a job, rather than presenting my ?everyday? self. According to Grace and Woodward (2006)

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work