• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Franz Boas: Successes and Failures at the Museum of Natural History

Extracts from this document...


Franz Boas: Successes and Failures at the Museum of Natural History America in the early twentieth century carried with it an idealism that was deeply rooted in religion. The Christian white male was the dominant decisive force with an army of Negro slaves that were scientifically of a lesser intelligence and much inferior race. In contrast to this, Boas's study was inspired by the previously tolerant and broad-minded German science. "Franz Boas had come of age in a far more liberal scientific tradition" (p50). While his American counterparts measured skulls to determine racial intelligence, Boas's mentor Rudolf Virchow "prevented racial prejudice from gaining 'scientific' support..." (p50) Although by 1887 Boas was an acknowledged expert in various fields such as Indian linguistics, mythology, and art, he was not the first choice for the department of anthropology at the Museum. He was a young anthropologist with radical and liberal attitudes towards science and what he considered scientific experience. ...read more.


(p55) Nonetheless Boas's success lies in the museum's Hall of Northwest Coast Indians. The hall, after opening in 1899, was inspired by a German sense of romanticism and religiosity (p55). He overrode the traditional method of display for a stimulating new look at history as contextual evidence. Artifacts were neither placed in evolutionary displays that ranged from the primitive to the modern nor exhibited by type - baskets, utensils, etc. Instead, they were placed in an area with other artifacts from a tribe to experience the culture as a whole. Like the article points out, Boas's argument was "against seeing human culture in evolutionary terms, rising from the primitive to a summit on which the inventors of the evolutionary scheme inevitably perched. Boas liked to point out how recent most civilizations were and how time had revealed 'innate' abilities" (p55). In 1902, when the Jesup Expedition was finally complete, Boas's interest moved to yet another study. ...read more.


It is no surprise to me that Boas's stay at the Museum, although short lived, was an ideal force for erudition. This was the time when the American and European sense of revolution was striving at a ridiculous pace towards knowledge and extensive study; a time during which the ideals of freedom, liberty and democracy were challenged and re-defined. At the same time the presence of slavery and the idea of a subhuman race were accepted by the common man. Books like Grants "The Passing of the Great Race" were bestsellers and the Ku Klux Klan had over 4 million members. A scientist with radical and idyllic views was much needed. Boas entered the scientific discussion with a command on anthropological study. His successes far outnumber his failures both as a scientist and an anthropologist. During the course of his lifetime, he provided challenging theories based on factual information. The same cannot be said of other so-called scientists present during the same time. ?? ?? ?? ?? Nayar February 28th 2005 i ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our University Degree Anthropology section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related University Degree Anthropology essays

  1. Emotional Intelligence: A Closer Look.

    Without an amygdala he seemed to have lost all recognition of feeling, as well as any feeling about feelings. The amygdala acts as a storehouse of emotional memory, and thus of significance itself; life without the amygdala is a life stripped of personal meanings.

  2. A Child Called It

    So when they all got back to the car, David was ordered to lay on the floor of the back seat so his brothers could take turns stomping on his back for "mouthing off" to them. And when David and his family got home, David's mother made up the mixture of Clorox and ammonia again.

  1. The History of Cajun Cuisine

    boudin, various jambalayas and gumbos, coush-coush (a creamed corn dish), and etouffee. The symbol of Cajun cooking is perhaps the crawfish, but until 40 years ago, crawfish were used mainly as bait. It took too much effort to remove the meat from such a tiny crustacean.

  2. Ritual primitive form of theatre?

    telling them started acting first with their face and their hands, but finally with their whole body. But would that be theatre or ritual? Stories would have been educational and entertaining but could that be identified to be theatrical performance?

  1. This is a group project on the study of the business superstitions and mentalities ...

    Art forms like the ancient Indian form of martial art, Kalaripayattu is considered to be the origin of Chinese martial arts, more specifically the Shaolin martial arts. Kathakali is the oldest form of a dance and musical play in which all the performers are males.

  2. American Exports:Pop Art and Democracy?

    (Krau�e, 1995, p.114) The objects and images used by Andy Warhol, Roy Liechtenstein and others were primarily those which occupied a central place in consumer society - which was due to commercial advertisement - and were thus familiar to everyone.

  1. First They Killed My Father - account of the Khmer Rouge 'killing fields' in ...

    Secrecy is vital to mask the fact they are urban, educated, middle-class Chinese-Cambodians and the Pa was previously enlisted in the Lon Nol army. To maintain secrecy the family moves several times in order to prevent them from being found out and killed.

  2. Comics: American liberty or suppression?

    and to "its freedom from academic constraints" (173). "The millions who still left Europe, up to 1914, persisted in heading for the Americas" (Palmer, 2002, p.621). The many immigrants America welcomed, especially in the first half of the 20th century, contributed to the multiethnic character of its culture.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work