• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

How does the concept of citizenship contribute to our understanding of the experience of disabled people?

Extracts from this document...


The concept of citizenship is essentially a contested one and can be difficult to define therefore the concept of citizenship will need to be explored. Disabled people will then be located within Marshall's model as they are often neglected from citizenship discussions. The experience of segregation, discrimination and oppression is argued to deny disabled people full citizenship rights. The negative experiences of disabled people can however be related to the dominance of the medical model in policy and practice which will be discussed. The social model brings a powerful challenge to this and seeks to eliminate the barriers to disabled people's full participation in society. The resulting Independent Living Movement then uses the concept of citizenship as a tool to argue for equal rights and empowers disabled people to have choice and control over their lives. Problems can arise however due to disparity in the way professionals and disabled people view independence and will be discussed. The Direct Payments Act (1986) will be analysed as it makes Independent Living possible for disabled people and the Care Standards Act (2000) highlights the tensions between the construction of disabled people as 'vulnerable' and their independence which will be explored. A conclusion will then be drawn. ...read more.


Goble (2004) argues that the key way in understanding the marginalised experience of disabled people lies in the way disabled people have been constructed as dependent, with dependency being defined as problematic. Blomberg (2003) therefore argues that the most critical issue when it comes to citizenship is that of full participation in society. The failure of social structures to accommodate disabled people and the obstacles to achieving this such as professional domination in services, lack of comprehensive civil rights legislation and lack of disabled people in positions of power results in disabled people having little influence over the issues which affect their lives. The empowerment of disabled people to have choice and control is therefore essential for their access to citizenship. Independent living has been built upon the concept of citizenship and that disabled people should have the right to the same standards of living in society as everyone else (Blomberg, 2003). The independent living movement, in line with the social model of disability argues for equal rights and embodies the most powerful challenge to the oppression disabled people experience. When considering disabled people's experiences alongside non disabled people, disabled people have considerably less choice and control in their lives and struggle for full and accessible citizenship (Lister, 2007). ...read more.


This maintains the second class citizenship status of disabled people. In conclusion, it becomes apparent that although policy rhetoric focuses on the independence, rights, choice and control, 'common sense' ideas about disability and links to vulnerability and risk are still 'disabling' people. Although disabled people use the concept of citizenship to argue for equal rights and full access to mainstream society there is still a lack of recognition of its validity across the spectrum of disability. The concept of citizenship helps us to understand the experiences of disabled people by drawing attention to the barriers faced to full participation in society in comparison to non disabled people. The majority of attention is focused on the welfare and services disabled people receive, however to achieve citizenship requires not only action in health and social care services but across the board in education, housing, transport, employment and leisure facilities (Hasler, 2004). Zarb (2003, cited in Hasler 2004) argues that the lack of action in the removal of barriers is a matter of finance as it widely regarded as 'too expensive' but without improvement in these other areas the achievements and progress made in health and social care settings as a result of the campaigns by disabled people will continue to be thwarted. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our University Degree Social Theory section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related University Degree Social Theory essays

  1. Learning Disability Research and Evaluation: Exploring Participatory and Emancipatory research in Learning Disabilities studies.

    the social and economical exclusion faced within the society that really disables the person (Richardson, 2000, Finkelstein 1980, Oliver 1993). Richardson (2000) explains that if the problem is created by society the society needs to change to resolve this, in order to resolve this disabled people and their organisations need to be in control of constructing and implementing research.

  2. This assignment will analyse critically key ethical, attitudinal, political issues and historical development of ...

    Perhaps Mrs. Hewitt and Mr. Bentley do not have right training to provide such intimate discussion. During the 1950s, real progress on s****l education for individuals with learning difficulties was made. Group of parents from the United States formed "association for retarded children (ARC) in 1950s, they lobbied the government for funding, parental education and

  1. Social Constructionism and Identity Concepts of Disabled People. This essays outlines social constructionisms ...

    People who suddenly become disabled first experience a profound consciousness of embodiment (Morris, cited at Phoenix, 2007, p. 85) and then develop a sense of continuity and meaning regarding their life-history by autobiographical narratives (Peet, 2007, Gracey, Palmer, Rous, Psaila, O'Dell, Cope, & Mohamed, 2008).

  2. To critically discuss the claim that citizenship is a contested and fluid concept, this ...

    Marshall's theory is seen as important as citizenship can lessen the impact of the capitalist market by redistributing resources based on rights but his theory is highly contested. Many commentators criticise his "optimistic" view of human nature in that people would seek to better themselves through participation in the market (Turner, 2002).

  1. A Critical Analysis of Care Policy for Older People in Hong Kong

    services which illustrates that state intervention is crucial even in the world's "freest capitalist economy" (McLaughlin, 1993). The Government takes a positivist non interventionalist stance on the care of older people and uses traditional Chinese Confucian values to justify this, stressing that welfare is the responsibility of the family, volunteer organisations and the market (McLaughlin, 1993).

  2. Notions of race, gender and disability have significantly informed the development of social policy ...

    As a result of this notion, disabled people are constructed as a burden, dependent and vulnerable. Segregative policies and practices are the result of this notion of disability (Oliver, 1990). The growing consciousness of disabled people and the notion that disability is socially created presents a powerful challenge to the medical model of disability and resulting interventions.

  1. What is the social ecological model? How can this perspective be used in practice ...

    Research by Feinstein (K218, Learning Guide 3, Section 3.2) demonstrates how difference in family backgrounds affects educational attainment. The research of Feinstein (2003a) analysed how high or low economic status affects children?s educational progress across time. The research shows that if you are from a higher income family, even if you start with a lower level of educational ability you are likely to catch up and do well.

  2. Discuss the extent of which citizenship continues to be a gendered concept and consider ...

    These characteristics applied to women have negatively impacted upon a women being active within the public domains such as within the labour market. This has formed questions to how informal care is viewed in relation to citizenship. It has been argued that T.H.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work