• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

"Lesbians and gay men have always existed in every historical period and across all cultures."Discuss, with particular reference to the relationship between category labels

Extracts from this document...


"Lesbians and gay men have always existed in every historical period and across all cultures." Discuss, with particular reference to the relationship between category labels (or 'identities') and behaviours. Nowadays, when you look up in most of the dictionaries, you can find that the definition for "heterosexuality" is sexual orientation to and sexual activity with someone of the opposite sex, which means that heterosexual person are feeling sexually attracted to people of a different sex. And the meaning for "homosexuality" is sexual orientation to and sexual activity with someone of the same sex, which means that homosexual person are sexually attracted only to people of the same sex. "[A]lthough sex was the root of the matter... it was as likely to be expressed in drinking together, in flirting and gossip and in a circle of friends as in actual liaisons" (Bray, 1988: 84), do these terms simply direct to the behaviours of sexual orientation (love-making) or merely close relationships (consummate love with intimacy, commitment and passion) between couples? Or may be both? And for what we understand now, lesbians and gay men are homosexuals. But do lesbians and gay men have always existed? ...read more.


The next day, Qiu Jin appeared before Wu Zheying in a man's suit and presented her with a pair of shoes and a skirt, explaining to her dear friend that "These items were part of my trousseau. Now that I have decided to wear men's clothes, I have no need for them. Please keep them in remembrance of me after we part." ... June Chan, a Chinese American lesbian activist in New York City, includes pictures of Qiu Jin in her famous slide show on Asian lesbians. However, historian Mary Rankin, who has written the most extensive biography for Qiu Jin in the English language, does not explore the nature of the Qiu-Wu friendship. ... No other historian of modern China has dared to address the possibility of a lesbian relationship between Qiu Jin and Wu Zheying. (Ng Vivien, in Duberman Martin, 1997: 201) This article is rather ambiguous and leaves a question mark for the relationship between Qiu Jin and Wu Zheying. As what Vivien found was secondary information, a lots of them could not be proved and had past already, we just never know. In the past, many homosexual couples kept their relationships secretly might be because of people always wanted to stay in the majority group and did not want to look odd with the others so they keep their sexuality under. ...read more.


We are all just choosing a partner among the human beings, why does the gender thing matters so much? Hopefully this would be changed in future, just like the idea or meaning for the term "homosexual" has been changing a lot over time. The earliest descriptions for the term are not really the same as the modern conception that we are having now. It was emphasized on effeminacy where now in contrast more like "fag, queer, gay, bent" (McIntosh Mary, 1968). In conclusion, the homosexual behavour should have always existed in every historical period and across all cultures. However, it is not easy to prove for the past as we usually have to rely on secondary evidences but not on primary information or direct observations. The reliability and validity of such information are often questionable as the sources are usually have been processed by others (the writers or the researchers) and the material would have been subjected to the writers' schema or expectations. There is also a problem of temporal validity, as meaning of word might change over time and the social expectation is also changing. We could not subjectively using the knowledge and expectations that we are having now to interpret the past information. But, nevertheless, the existence of homosexual behavour in the past and over different cultures can not be disproved as well. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our University Degree Gender Studies section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related University Degree Gender Studies essays

  1. LGBT studies. History and future of same sex marriage in the US

    decision, stating that the Court "failed to appreciate the extent of the liberty at stake" and condemning the decision stating that it demeans the lives of homosexual persons. Lawrence v. Texas struck down all sodomy laws remaining on the books in the states that still had them, about one third of the states.

  2. Gender Studies

    Poverty as explained by Sen. (1999) is viewed from two perspective which are not related, 'lowness of income' as poverty and 'capability inadequacy' as poverty. Income is a means to capabilities and this will enhance the ability for a person to be more productive and earn a higher income.

  1. Gender Biography Section IV-VII

    Yes, this changed the sports in notable way because the game goes in favor of boys. There was deemed necessary to separate girls and boys because to see who does better and to whom game favors. This change altered my experience in terms of looking on a particular sports were always male are dominant in one way or the other.

  2. The Figure of the Mannish Lesbian in Nineteenth-Century Sexology

    supported by data, but rather was only found in a handful of cases. (Heterosexual women were not studied, however, so it is quite possible that an equal percentage of heterosexuals had large clitorises.) But as Margaret Gibson notices, the "ease with which these few cases became generalizations testifies to the

  1. How has AIDS focused the issue of identity for gay males in film?

    with its central image of an ice-pick wielding lesbian.4 It seems that in classic Hollywood film a story concerned with any form of homosexuality must contain controversy or deep psychological character subtext. A character cannot be deemed gay without reason.

  2. How might the relationship between depression and gender have been exaggerated?

    very rare for men to have to make these changes surrounding children. Carmen, Russo and Miller (1981) suggest women's personality roles that they have to adjust to be a 'good wife' such as being passive, submissive and inhibited are not fulfilling traits so they may in themselves lead to psychological dysfunction.

  1. How can gender be thought of as performative and regulatory category

    Our identity is continually constructed: However, she argues that sex does not "necessitate gender." Homosexuals and transgendered people, as well as heterosexuals who do not follow norms, subvert gender norms and draw our attention to the constuctedness of sex. Butler argues that our gender is never fully constructed.

  2. Debates on Contemporary Gay Culture

    and allegorical representation of the transsexual community itself, as opposed to the historically regular depictions of the transsexual gender role as negative or even sinister (Schippers, 1989). Ang Lee?s 2005 film, Brokeback Mountain was widely received as a critical success and made itself an exception not only in queer theory but in the Hollywood tradition.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work