• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Marxist approach to criminology

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

INTRODUCTION There is no society without crime (Macionis and Plummer 2002) however what differs is the extent to which an action goes to be regarded as a crime, this has led to the need for Law to govern Individuals as according to Beccaria (2003:16) Laws were created by the society tired of constant war, they gave away part of their freedom in order for peace to reign supreme, it was not by choice but a necessity. The Law is meant to curb crime and maintain order in the society however Michael and Adler (1993) are jointly of the opinion that the criminal law is the primary cause of crime, this is due to the fact that the criminal code determines what a crime is or is not,it therefore follows logically that the law was created to avoid crime and to punish criminals. There have been different approaches to criminology such as the conflict, functionist, positivist and labelling(Macionis and Plummer 2002,Giddens 2001).The functionalist theorists claim that crime is as a result of lack of moral regulation within society, The positivist theorist include caesare Lombroso(1835-1909),Sheldon glueck and Eleanor Glueck(1950),Rave and Osgood(1984,Jenucks(1987),Wilson and Herrnstein(1985),Raffaele Garofalo(1895-1934) and Enrico Ferri 1856-1929.) and the Conflict theorist who base crime as emanciating from society and class relations such as Karl Marx, Richard quinney,Spitzer(1980) and Ian Tayol to mention a few. ...read more.

Middle

MARXIST ON CRIME Marx himself did not speak at length on the topic of crime however his followers referred to as Marxist give extended views of his opinion,they are characterised as conflict theorist and link crime directly to capitalism(Bilton et al 2002).To fully comprehend this theory on crime it is important to have background knowledge on the general views of Karl Marx capitalism as a system of government which dwell on the state and its means of production. In his opinion, there are two classes in a capitalist society; the ruling class who own the means of production (known as the Bourgeoisie) and the working class (known as the proletariat) who have to work so as to earn a living. He sees crime as the product of class society (Bottomore 1983:100).That is crime is dependent on ones social stand in society whether rich or working class.,He goes on to explain that they are of the belief that capitalism creates crime as the means of production are not equally distributed resulting in a very visible line between who is rich and who is poor, this inevitably leads to class conflict . The type of crimes and laws depend on the means of production whether it is owned by the state, small group of workers or other strata. According to Chambliss (2003:249),the capitalist societies are more prone to crime than others because there is a desire to consume by all (both the ruling and working class) ...read more.

Conclusion

is pushed to feel insignificant and helpless aggression is transferred to the nearest neighbour hence the working class are still fighting the system but through the nearest individual whom is not even the main source of their disgruntlement.I agree with Marxist view on crime because the state which comprise of the ruling class protect themselves directly or indirectly to the detriment of the lower class and renders them voiceless with nowhere to go for justice this frustration is manifested in form of needless strikes and riots resulting mostly in unemployment and possibly death. Marx never argued that the ruling class do not commit crime, they do but through bribery and redrafting the law they averted punishment he just said it was more rampant in the working class due to economic factors. Another criticism on Marxist approach to criminology is that they fail to give working solutions to crime but shift focus to capitalism (Lea and young 1993), that is concerning themselves with class and constantly blaming the rich in the society instead of objectively looking for ways to stop crime. Conclusion Although the concept of crime is complicated, a working definition of crime has been clearly show as any act that goes against the criminal law. There have been brief explanations of the different theories of crime which are conflict, positivist, Functionist and labelling and I have dwelt on the Marxist theory of crime who base their argument on capitalism. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our University Degree Criminology section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related University Degree Criminology essays

  1. Reflective Essay on working with a Team

    that they were not pulling their weight, and ask them to contribute more. Unfortunately, "confrontations involving blame and recrimination are some of the most difficult to approach, let alone solve"8. As such, approaching this subject would have required a significant level of diplomacy and tact, and I must confess that

  2. Examine the contribution of feminism to contemporary criminology

    Female criminologists recognise these two problems and usually concern there study with one or the other, the research and studies that have gone into these problems have helped to change the debates that surround criminology.

  1. Compare positivist approaches to crime with at least two other perspectives discussed in the ...

    In addition, biological positivism helped develop and shape some other criminological theories and relevant research. A number of theories emerged from this type of positivism to express and develop their own explanation of crime. On the other hand, biological positivist approach can be said to have some weaknesses.

  2. Term paper of criminology

    In Differential Association Theory, there are many characteristics that describe the process of an individual learning criminal behaviour and becoming a deviant. This theory has an inherit assumption that when the definitions towards crime prevail over the definitions against crime, criminal behaviour will transpire.

  1. Feminism and Criminology

    Edwards also argues that most criminologist spend a lot of time studying men. Feminism has been neglected from mainstream criminology which skewed criminologists from looking at gender, and crime has become something that is committed by men not women. Of the population born in 1954, 34% of men but only

  2. The Rise Of Female Criminology and Female Crime.

    However women do not represent the large population of prison. Today the roles of the criminal has altered beyond recognition, and this is due to the uprising of the new Feminist Criminology. Women do not represent a large proportion of the total of offenders involved with the criminal justice system

  1. How has feminist thought influenced the discipline of criminology?

    Carol Smart (1997 cited by Newburn 2007, p.306) was perhaps the first to examine this concept when she claimed that women offenders were treated as ?doubly deviant? An area where feminist thought has been influential in the discipline of criminology has been with the development of a gender based theory of female delinquency focusing on social control systems of women.

  2. Social Ethics and the Justice System. Should abortion be legalised?

    Deontologists argue that when an ethical decision needs to be made one must have a duty to treat others with respect and fairness, and to abide by certain rules (Hayes, Stobbs and Lauchs 2006, 10). To follow the law at all times is a great example of deontology because it is deemed the ?right? thing to do.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work