• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

To what extent are gender differences socially constructed? To what extent are gender differences socially constructed

Extracts from this document...


To what extent are gender 'differences' socially constructed? Many sociologists believe gender is socially constructed (i.e. it is mostly created by society and is not completely natural, as gender identity varies between societies and within societies). Some sociologists argue that gender is the result of environmental influences, particularly the way we are taken care of by our parents or guardians. On the other hand a number of sociologists argue that gender is the result of nature, due to the effects of 'hormones, brains or genes of the two sexes.'Haralambos and Holborn (1995) In terms of how we understand identity 'a distinction between sex and gender must be drawn.' Nick Jorgensen, John Bird, Andrea Heyhoe & Bev Russell (1997). "Sex deals with what are often biological differences, while gender is about a socially constructed role. Therefore, labels 'women' and 'man' are about both biological and social differences." Jorgensen, Bird, Andrea & Russell (1997) Pg 23 Gender roles have a big influence on our lives, and there is a lot of evidence that suggests 'gender roles are culturally rather then biologically produced.' Oakley (1972 cited in Haralambos and Holborn 1995) this means individuals are taught the behaviour that is expected of males and females within their society. ...read more.


they were also organised with schoolwork and homework. However, the stereotype of the male was the 'macho male' that did not care about authority and just liked to be in the company of other males. Researchers felt some of the boys were already fulfilling this stereotype in their approach to school. Moreover "sociologists argue that teachers spend more time with boys and concentrate their efforts more on them." (Moore 1987 Pg 53) Like parents who are more likely to label their sons as less interested in school and education at an early age (Eccles study) teachers have different expectations of from boys and girls. "Boys are expected to be more boisterous, girls to be quieter and more obedient. As a result, teachers are likely to treat the children differently according to their sex." (Moore 1987 Pg 53) There are also many other ways in which socialisation into gender roles takes place. Identification also takes place; children see themselves as their parents or television heroes. So as well as imitating their parents they also play at being parents/hero figures. Peer group pressure is also applied by friends, as friendships develop along sex lines with boys playing with boys and girls playing with girls, both playing different types of games. ...read more.


Some sociologists argue that "social scientists who assume that human beings behave simply in terms of their culture and society are ignoring what they call human biogrammer." (Haralambos and Holborn 1995 Pg 583) This is a genetically based programme which inclines people to behave in certain ways. Although it is similar in men and women, "Tiger and fox argue that compared to women, men are more aggressive and dominant and that these characteristics are genetically based." (Haralambos and Holborn 1995 Pg 584) This is partially because genetic inheritance and because a genetic 'adaptation to a hunting way of life.' Male's hunt which can be found to be an aggressive activity. To conclude, to support a biological case we would need to establish that a universal difference exists, that men and women across societies are characterised by more or less identical behaviours. We would also need to show that this difference is actually caused by biology and not in the similarities in upbringing. "The more segregated the worlds that women and men inhabit, the harder it is to demonstrate that nature, rather than nurture, accounts for gender difference. (Bilton, Bonnet, Jones, Lawson, Skinner, Stanworth & Webster 2002 Pg 132) Sociologists have tried to move away from the debate as to whether sex and gender shapes male and females behaviour "Both David Morgan and Linda Birke argue sex and gender interact. Sex differences and vice versa. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our University Degree Gender Studies section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related University Degree Gender Studies essays

  1. Is gender behaviour learned or innate?

    While these prejudices would have a moulding effect of males, so they could fit the stereotype and be socially acceptable, there is also the other effect as many gender prejudices fall away. The numbers of openly homosexual men has risen, and more men are entering jobs that were traditionally dominated by women.

  2. Examine the Factors that Influence Gender Identity.

    These stereotypes that occur shape the way the different genders are perceived and expected to behave. These are our gender roles and gender identities that don't conform to these roles are seen as abnormal. It is however notable that the way society treats an individual can still not fully shape their gender identity.

  1. Gender and Biology. The basic assumptions about human gender, sexual identity and sexual ...

    Since the 1950's, medical professionals have obtained a comprehensive knowledge of surgical techniques, and sophisticated understanding of hormonal and biochemical functions of the body; because of this, physicians are able to eliminate the outward manifestation of hermaphroditism. Medical professionals are able to "catch" intersexuals at the time of birth and perform surgery to eliminate "abnormal" physical genital traits (www.isna.org).

  2. The Development of Gender in the Individual.

    Toys and games can be seen as imposing gender identities, as I mentioned earlier when describing gifts we would give to different sexes. Girls are not usually given guns or soldiers to play with and boys are not normally offered dolls or doll's houses.

  1. To what extent does gender influence the processes of securing paid employment, the status ...

    Candidate No. 229695 Hochschild (1983) uses the examples of the friendly, smiling flight attendant against the stern, deflating bill collector as a way projecting the strikingly polar opposite ways in feelings are managed. Hochschild (1983) states that the employee?s feelings and emotions are given to them at work, meaning that they lose

  2. Thesis Proposal -examining gender differences in the use of spoken language.

    It is really important to analyze this difference, because it can help us to find if the fact that you belong to a kind of sex forces men and women to behave and speak in certain way and as future teachers know how to explain in the better way for both men and women.

  1. Discuss the influence of gender on identity in contemporary Western Society.

    Bono on ?Dancing with the stars? for fear that their children would be influenced to swap gender.

  2. Argumentative paper. Discuss problems associated with the ways that gender is constructed in ...

    There has been further evidence to support their argument in the form of data that shows that children?s educational performance and overall development is enhanced when both parents are employed (O?Brien and Jones, 599-621 ), negating the belief that the conventional societal feminine role construct held any real scientific basis.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work