Which theorist is most applicable to understanding work today, Marx, Weber, or Durkheim?

Authors Avatar

Q. Which theorist is most applicable to understanding work today, Marx, Weber, or Durkheim?

A. Most people spend most of their lives working. Some people work to live while others live to work. Some characterize work as holy while some regard it as something that has to be done from nine to five. In truth work is a vital part of our life and is the arena where the central resources of our society are created. With work playing such a dominant role in our society it is inevitable that sociology or the study of relationships determines our understanding of the modern day idea of work. 

Sociological thought is dominated by the insights, concepts and theories of Emile Durkheim, Max Weber and Karl Marx which serve to explain the workings of the twentieth century world and the way we approach our lives. Emile Durkheim concentrates on the division of labour and the way society shifts to individualism to form an integrate part of the modern organic society. On the other hand, Max Weber concentrates on the notion of rationality and the way society takes a pragmatic approach to everything. He goes on to say that logic supersedes emotions and religion and that society will necessarily attribute the happenings of the world to their own actions. Karl Marx gives a totally different explanation to the workings of society saying that work dominates our life and is about individual creativity. He explains that capitalism leads to exploitation, which then follows on with concentration of ownership and saturation of world markets. This according to Marx hinders progress and eventually leads to the death of capitalism. To me the work of Karl Marx, due to its intense focus on the nature of work and the way it changes with development best helps understand the modern day meaning of work.

Join now!

To get a firm grasp of Marx’s theories in relation to work its is imperative to understand his definition of work. Marx argues that work is not something that happens from nine to five, but is an ongoing activity, that work is about individual creativity and how we develop ourselves and our environment. Marx classifies work as an expression of our beliefs and assumptions, that every activity we do changes our outlook of the world. (Say we read a book, e.g. Harry Potter, it changes our thinking of magic and gives us the urge to be part of the fictitious world, ...

This is a preview of the whole essay