• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Assess the extent to which modern medicine challenges personal autonomy and well being in contemporary society and discuss whether sufficient efforts are being made to tackle these issues.

Extracts from this document...


Contemporary Health Issues Assess the extent to which modern medicine challenges personal autonomy and well being in contemporary society and discuss whether sufficient efforts are being made to tackle these issues. Assess the extent to which modern medicine challenges personal autonomy and well being in contemporary society and discuss whether sufficient efforts are being made to tackle these issues. How people think of medicine has changed very much over the years. Medicine in the early modern period used to be text based and doctors from within this period drew their wisdom from the ancient. However by the nineteenth century doctors started to realise that there was a lot more money involved in the profession and along with this the status of doctors began to rise. Then by the 1950's, doctors saw medicine as a curative factor. A very common definition of health that is given by the World Health Organisation (WHO) is 'A complete state of physical, metal and social well being and not merely the absence of disease or infirmity'. (�st�n & Jakob, 2005:83:802) This definition was given over half a century ago and it seems that medicine, now, has a negative approach to health and sees it as 'the absence of disease or illness'. (Blaxter, 2004: 6) With this in mind modern medicine can be seen as a threat to the wellbeing of the individual as it focuses on cure rather than prevention. However modern medicine has led to some benefits within society as it has helped to increase life expectancy over the years. On the other hand modern medicine has created a number of critiques such as; Illich who argued that modern medicine actually causes more risks than curing the individual, Parsons who believed that modern medicine is a threat to social order, Foucault who states that modern medicine is just an excuse for medical surveillance. There is also McKeown who argues that the only reason there was an increase in growth population was due to capitalism and not modern medicine. ...read more.


However Wilkes (1976) disagrees with the fact that they are good for the individual as all it does is reassure them. He argues that cough mixtures resembles homemade traditional remedies of warm water and honey. This just shows that even when it comes to minor illnesses such as coughs, individuals need the advice of a doctor as Wilkes (1976) suggested that an estimate of six million cough mixtures are prescribed in Britain by the NHS every year and this excludes those sold over the counter. In this case modern medicine has come about so it undermines individuals personal autonomy as people have transferred from using simple homemade remedies to consulting the doctor as their initial step. (Helman, 1978) On the other hand advice and consultation from the doctors is necessary when it comes to life threatening illnesses such as cancer. 'During 2003-2007, survival from prostate cancer five years after diagnosis was 79.7 per cent, 2.7 per cent higher than survival for men diagnosed in 2001 - 2006.' (Office for National Statistics, 2009) This shows that modern medicine is helping towards diseases such as cancer. Also treatments for some cancers and heart diseases have extended life expectancy. In a recent study it has been shown that there are certain treatments that can extend life expectancy for those who have prostate cancer. One of these treatments is with a drug called Taxotere. Life expectancy, for those men that took the drug, had increased by twenty per cent. Those that were given Taxotera lived an additional eighteen months but those that did not, lived only fifteen months. However there were side effects from taking Taxotera and these were nausea and hair loss. It could be argued that the difference with taking the drug is only three months and with the side effects it may not be worth it to take Taxotera. Nevertheless it shows that progress has been made towards the treatment for prostate cancer and that modern medicine is proving beneficial for the well being of the individual. ...read more.


Therefore a ban against animal testing may be the positive and beneficial move that is needed for modern medicine not to be harmful to individuals. To conclude, we could argue that modern medicine is a threat to personal autonomy as it is just a way for medical practitioners to exert their power and authority upon individuals in society. As Foucault (1973) stated that modern medicine is just another term for medical surveillance, a way in which doctors can keep control over their patients. For example the way in which the medical profession keep a close watch on pregnant women and childbirth. On the other hand, even though it does undermine the autonomy of the woman, it is debatable that it is not a threat to health. With childbirth taking place in a hospitalised room full of fully trained medical staff, it could be said that it is a lot safer and less harmful to the mother or the baby. Along with this we can also argue that modern medicine has helped towards increasing life expectancy and allowed for pain control and disease management to take place, for example insulin for diabetes and allupurinol for gout. But there have been cases where unnecessary drugs and medical interventions have proved harmful to the individual. Therefore measures that been taken to ensure that deaths caused due to medical faults are reduced. One measure that had been taken is to ban animal tests due to the fact that people have been killed from using drugs that have been proved by animal testing. Also a National Institute of Clinical and Excellence (1999) was set up to encourage doctors to start using newer treatments, mainly for clinical and cost effectiveness. Even with these efforts made there are still some cases where modern medicine is proving harmful to the individual. In this case it is arguable that there are always going to be positives and negatives within the medical industry and there will always be trial and error, just like everything else in society. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our University Degree Healthcare section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related University Degree Healthcare essays

  1. Medicine is the science and art of healing. Medicine is a science because it ...

    The role of medical research. Progress in medicine depends largely on the work of medical research. Medical researchers strive to increase our knowledge of (1) how the healthy body works; (2) how it is disturbed by disease; and (3) how disease can be prevented or cured.

  2. Nursing : An Example of a Clinical Incident

    I also believed that if I were to talk for too long I would loose the audiences' attention, as I was not as knowledgeable as the health visitor was. There were some factors that made me act in incongruent ways.

  1. Professional Autonomy and Accountability in Radiography

    For example after qualification a radiographer may specialise in a certain specified field of radiography such as paediatric radiography, by additional training and qualification, which must satisfy the HPC. Additionally should this individual also wish to return to practice in the wider field of radiography, they must satisfy the HPC

  2. The aim of this assignment is to critically evaluate the biopsychosocial perspectives and influences ...

    http://www.alcoholmonitoring.com Accessed 12 March 2012 BALDWIN RESEARCH INSTITUTE., 2006. Alcoholism is not a Disease. New York: Baldwin Research Institute website. Available from: www. addictioninfo.org/articles/447/1/Alcoholism-is-not-a-Disease Accessed 26 March 2012. BAXAMUSA, B., 2010. Alcohol dementia prognosis available from: http://www.buzzle.com/articles/alcohol-dementia-prognosis.html Accessed on 12 April 2012 BLAXTER, M., 1990. Health and Lifestyles. Tavistock: London BLOOD ALCOHOL INFORMATION, 2006.

  1. The Effectiveness of Brief Interventions in Reducing Binge

    Promotions and special offers are responsible for unhealthy patterns of alcohol consumption (British Medical Association, 2009). Yet other scholars do not agree that the over abundance of access to alcohol are reason enough for increase in alcohol consumption since it is not the case in all countries, especially in Mediterranean

  2. The aim of this study was to investigate the health and nutritional status of ...

    Longitudinal studies have shown that smoking is associated with an increased risk of death in current smokers and ex-smokers when compared with never-smokers, with the risk being greater for current smokers (Doll et al, 2004, Nazroo, 2008). The 2007 HSE has also found evidence of under-reporting of cigarette smoking status, possibly due to smoking becoming less socially acceptable (Craig, 2008).

  1. Critically assess the efficacy of treatment in changing addictive behaviour

    High-dose methadone can block both the physical and psychological effects of heroin, thereby discouraging its continued use by addicts. Adversely, chronic administration of methadone results in tolerance and dependence in the same way as heroin. However, the withdrawal syndrome develops more slowly and is less severe albeit more prolonged than that associated with heroin withdrawal.

  2. The business I have chosen to study is Nab wood School in Cottingley Manor ...

    The identification of key personnel (by name and/or job title) who are accountable to top management for ensuring that detailed arrangements for safe working are drawn up implemented and maintained. (c) The definition of the roles of both line and functional management. Specific job descriptions should be formulated. (d)

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work