"This dead butcher and his fiend like queen" How far do you agree with Malcolm's assessment of the Macbeth's fiend Devil?

Authors Avatar
English Coursework

"This dead butcher and his fiend like queen" How far do you agree with Malcolm's assessment of the Macbeth's fiend Devil?

Macbeth is a play of murder and witchcraft. Many actors when performing it on stage are too superstitious to use the real name, and call it " The Scottish play" instead believing that this way they will avoid bad luck being brought on themselves. The quotation from Malcolm's speech (V.ix.36) seems to portray Macbeth as a mindless killer, and that it is his wife who is the scheming villain, who is fiend-like, thus emphasising her link with the dark forces in the play. I think that this is too simple a way to sum up two complicated characters. Therefore I shall look at both Macbeth's and Lady Macbeth's characters as they advance through the play and the other characters that influence them before I draw any conclusions.

This play was written and produced by Shakespeare during the reign of James I. We have to bear this in mind. Shakespeare was trying to impress the king who was a descendant of Scottish royalty. In the play Banquo represents King James' supposed ancestor. One of Shakespeare's aims in writing the play was to show his support for the king and that he was against the various uprisings which took place in James' reign.

At the start of the play Macbeth is a very strong and courageous nobleman of the king. He is a ruthless warrior and loyal to his country. These qualities are shown right at the beginning of the play when in battle he bravely but violently killed the captain of the other army: "he unseamed him from the nave to th'chaps."(I.ii.22). He therefore receives the title of Thane of Cawdor. But this had been foretold by the witches who also predicted that he would be king. Macbeth does not think that he should do anything about making the prophecy come true: "If Chance will have me king, why Chance may crown me/ Without my stir." (I.iv.43-44). However, when King Duncan places an extra obstacle in his way by naming his son, Malcolm, as his successor, Macbeth realises that, if he is to be king, then he must kill Duncan: "The Prince of Cumberland! That is a step/ On which I must fall down, or else o'erleap/ For in my way it lies. Stars hide your fires, / Let not light see my black and deep desires." (I.iv.49-52). The end of that quotation is important to the audience because it is the first real sign of Macbeth's evil thoughts.

When Lady Macbeth reads her Husband's letter she immediately believes that Macbeth can be king (she sees that other predictions have already been fulfilled). However she doubts that Macbeth has the particular qualities to make it happen; "Yet I do fear thy nature/ It is too full o'th'milk of human kindness/ To catch the nearest way. Thou would'st be great,/ Art not without ambition, but without/ The illness should attend it."(I.v.14-17). The illness or evil which he does not possess, but she does possess. Later in the scene we see her calling on the spirit world to, " unsex me here/ And fill me from the crown to the toe topfull/ Of direst cruelty." She needs to provide the evil determination which Macbeth lacks.

When Macbeth comes back to his castle to get the feast ready for the king, he starts to doubt his thoughts about killing him. He wrestles with his conscience and thinks aloud to the reasons for not killing him, " He's here in double trust:/ First I am his kinsman and his subject, / Strong both against the deed; then, as his host/ Who should against his murderer shut the door,/ Not bear the knife myself."(I.vii.12-16). He is thinking that Duncan has trusted him first as Thane of Cawdor and second as host. He also contemplates Heaven and Hell, and that if he killed Duncan then there would be a tremendous outcry from Heaven. This is because of the Divine right of succession and he knows that if he kills Duncan then this will be disrupted. In the days of Shakespeare the divine right of succession was considered holy and that if anyone disrupts it, it is an act against God.
Join now!


Meanwhile Lady Macbeth knows that Macbeth's conscience and indecision will hold him back firstly from carrying out the deed and secondly from his ambitions. So she decides that she will carry out the deed herself, " He that's coming/ Must be provided for, and you shall put/ This night's great business into my dispatch"(I.vi.64-66). But then later when Macbeth is feeling that the deed should not be carried out she knows what to do. She starts taunting him and makes him think that he is a coward; "Was the hope drunk/ Wherein you dressed yourself? Hath it slept ...

This is a preview of the whole essay