• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Comparison of the opening sequences of two different versions of 'Romeo & Juilet' - Zefferelli & Luhrmann

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Media Assignment: Comparison of the opening sequences of two different versions of 'Romeo & Juilet' - Zefferelli & Luhrmann The objective of this essay is to compare two different film adaptations of William Shakespeare's Romeo & Juilet. Franco Zefferelli directed the first rendition of this play in 1968. This was the more conventional, traditional version of the play. It was slow, peaceful, and in my opinion, how Shakespeare would've wanted it. Despite it being old, it was a beautiful interpretation of Shakespeare's tragic love story. Here, Leonard Whiting played Romeo and Olivia Hussey played Juilet. The whole cast were kitted out in lifelike, accurate costumes, the settings and props were extremely realistic and in general, the film was a great success. The second interpretation of this play caused a lot of controversy. Directed by the very courageous and daring Baz Luhrmann in 1996, it was a first. Luhrmann bought Shakespeare's classic play about star-crossed lovers into the modern day. It was fast, action-packed and in-your-face. This film was an immediate hit with the audience. It made everyone excited and full of adrenaline - guns, loud music, fast cars and Romeo played by Leonardo DiCaprio. Those who wouldn't read a Shakespeare play would think again after seeing this! This film bought Shakespeare to life again with great effect - it's something everyone today can relate to. I consider the opening sequence an essential part of any film, as it sets the scene and gives the audience an idea of what to anticipate in the rest of the movie. Expectedly, the two films have entirely dissimilar openings. The Zefferelli version commences with two scenes - one of Romeo, and one of Juilet. ...read more.

Middle

and Tybalt (A Montague). The instant the camera focuses on Tybalt, the audience can clearly see that he is evil and arrogant - he speaks slowly and clearly - which also suggests status. He obviously wants to fight - it can be seen in his body language and facial expressions, whereas Benvolio is softer spoken, with a bit more fumbling. He doesn't make eye contact and from his look, it's clear to the audience that he wants peace. In Luhrmann's rendition, the costumes are extremely modern when compared with traditional Shakespearian costumes. In this film, the Montagues are the ones dressed in bright colours. They are clearly punks - pink hair and tattoos. The instant the audience sees them; they (the audience) can see that they are wild. The audience see the Capulets, in this film, as the gang that is to be 'feared' more. They are dressed in black, smart suits, metal studded boots and false metal teeth. Again, there is here a major contrast between Tybalt (a Capulet) and Benvolio (a Montague). Tybalt here speaks with a Latin - American accent, which immediately suggests to the audience that he's something to do with the Mafia. He is seen as evil - both through his appearance and his attitude - he has the mind to kill. Furthermore, his facial expression is very effective. The audience can clearly see that he is full of hate towards Benvolio. Benvolio, again is a lot more scared. He isn't as confident and outgoing as Tybalt. He speaks more softly, and from his facial expression, the audience can clearly see fear in his eyes. ...read more.

Conclusion

The Luhrmann presentation commences with some humour again - the Montagues are first shown joking amongst themselves in a car, this is the same when they reach the gas station and see the bus full of nuns. This, however, all changes when the Tybalt comes on to the scene. The audience can clearly see he is angry and full of hatred. When the camera then focuses on Benvolio, the audience, as I've previously mentioned, can see that he is the peacemaker here. When the fighting here, there is a lot of tension. This is broken up partly by some humour - one of the Montagues being hit with a lady's handbag, as he takes cover in her taxi. The close-up and extreme close-up shots of the characters show the audience the passion and emotions of the characters. This, in a way, allows us to feel the characters' emotions. Expectedly, the emotions in these two films are extremely dissimilar because they are both aimed at different audiences, and different audiences expect and enjoy different things. To conclude this essay, I would like to say that I thought the Luhrmann version had the more effective opening. It was quick, action-packed and in your face and contained props and landscape from my generation. This was the decisive factor, as I could identify with them. It held my attention, and was more gripping than the Zefferelli version, which, in my opinion, was aimed at an older audience. It was slower, had less drama, and old, Shakespearian props were used. True, it was a beautifully realistic adaptation of Shakespeare's tragic tragedy: Romeo and Juilet, but it just wasn't for me. I like films that are fast and full of action, but this was, as I've previously mentioned, slow. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Plays section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Plays essays

  1. In 'still life at the penguin caf' by David Bintley each section has different ...

    The costumes also help to show the characters. Task 2: Costumes play a big part in 'still life at the penguin caf�' because the designs reflect the characters play in the sections. They are very important because they help the audience to identify the characters easily. The kangaroo rat dress in dark blue baggy dungarees that are stitched with silver coloured buckle fastenings.

  2. Script/Stimulus: Romeo and Juliet

    This could also indicate that fate had a role in our performance, and everyone in it would die....they did.

  1. How to Plan and Prepare an Effective Presentation

    The introduction and conclusion must be carefully crafted to present the residual message. The transitions are the phrases that allow the speaker to move from one part of the presentation to another. Some authors suggest that the only part of the presentation that should be memorized is the transitions.

  2. Analysis of Brighton Rock by Grahame Greene

    therefore must deduce, from her naming that she will play some importance. This is another example of the audience being forced to make decisions regarding the relevance and purpose of information escaping from the plot. The text is well structured to enable the gradual release of information so as to

  1. DIGITAL SPECIAL EFFECTS

    * One said 'The first scene when we were rocking back and forward I wanted to rock too'. Felt uncomfortable at the sex scene. Sympathy and empathy. Q 3 - Were the seating arrangements effective? Why? * One said 'It broke up the visual audience relationship isolating us, expecting the

  2. What techniques does Luhrmann use to make the prologue and opening fight scene of ...

    The effect tells you a little about his character; that he is a 'tough guy'.

  1. Critically analyse the opening extract of Baz Luhrmann's Romeo and Juliet.

    This gives the audience the impression of importance and power as the noise is so singular. This scene is a contrast with the other scenes the audience has seen so far. It is neither loud and dramatic nor fun and happy go lucky.

  2. How would you direct the exchanges between Phedre and Oenone in two sequences from ...

    During this scene it should be very clear that Phedre has a close relationship with Oenone almost like mother and daughter. To show this to the audience I would have Phedre and Oenone contently exchanging loving glances and holding each other while delivering their lines.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work