• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

"Legal control of multinational corporations: problems and prospects".

Extracts from this document...


LAW 410 ASSIGNMENT 2 Suggested Topic #25 "Legal control of multinational corporations: problems and prospects" The greatest evil is not now done in those sordid "dens of crime" that Dickens loved to paint. It is not done even in concentration camps and labour camps. In those we see its final result. But it is conceived and ordered (moved, seconded, carried and minuted) in clean, carpeted, warmed and well-lighted offices, by quiet men with white collars and cut fingernails, and smooth-shaven cheeks who do not need to raise their voices. (C.S. Lewis, The Screwtape Letters) As the name "Multinational" suggests, today's corporate giants are no longer shackled by the constraints of international borders. Previously the bulk of world production occurred within national boundaries, but in recent decades trade and production has become increasingly globalised, and corporate activity has diversified and multiplied. The market is now global, as is capacity for production. Legal and political framework is traditionally based on the nation state, however economic activity is no longer such, and it is this mobility of capital that threatens to undermine the power of national governments to deal with traditional economic and social issues1. Critics charge that the ability of multinationals to manage production on a global scale and leap national borders in search of lower costs and higher profits now threatens democracy itself2. These monoliths are less attached than ever to their country of origin, they operate without territorial loyalty or connection, and as their loyalty fades so does any ultimate responsibility for their actions. There has been a growing voice from various quarters calling for a delimitation of the responsibilities of multinational corporations (MNCs) to reflect their increasing influence in society3. It is argued that corporations, though formed primarily to maximise profit, should be under more strenuous legal - as well as a moral - obligation to respect and promote national laws and social standards. ...read more.


But these acts fail to reach the real violator, providing only superficial justice, and in any case, corporations simply relocate if they encounter regulatory issues in a country of operation. MNCs have long outgrown the legal structures that govern them, reaching a level of transnationality and economic power that exceeds the power of domestic laws alone to impose basic legal and human rights norms18. Private internal codes of conduct have been touted as a possible regulatory solution. Internal codes are popular with MNCs in the textiles and clothing industries, including Gap, Levi Strauss and Nike, as a means of addressing labour rights in developing countries. In fact over 60 per cent of the top 500 companies have codes19. Internal codes offer a number of advantages. Firstly, in countries where law enforcement mechanisms are weak, self-regulation may be more persuasive and effective. Secondly they are efficient, as they avoid time-consuming negotiation processes inherent in national and international instruments. They are also flexible, allowing customisation to individual companies and countries. The key issue with internal codes relates to the weakness of enforcement provisions and compliance mechanisms. Usually the enforcement, compliance and monitoring provisions are either inadequate or simply non-existent20. The codes are not legally binding, so in effect flimsy. Furthermore, the codes often don't apply to subcontractors or subsidiaries, or universally across all operations, and they are costly to implement21. The elaborate rhetoric of company codes are often no more than a public relations tool. Internal codes lack bite. As UK Foreign Secretary Jack Straw said, "we must do what we can to encourage corporate responsibility, but we cannot leave companies to regulate themselves globally any more than we do in our national economies"22. Non-Government Organisations (NGOs) offer another avenue of regulation. However like an internal code, NGO regulation would be voluntary, and thus legally impotent. So to the second dilemma: what are the exact areas or activities which are to be regulated? ...read more.


The UN is not well placed, compared with WTO, to enforce legal control. As UN Assistant Secretary-General John Ruggie said about Global Compact: "this is not a code of conduct and the UN has neither the mandate nor the capacity to verify corporate compliance". Director of UNICEF, Carol Bellamy, warned that "it is dangerous to assume that the goals of the private sector are somehow synonymous with those of the United Nations, because they most emphatically are not"29. If any prospective regulation is to be successful then the 'home' countries of MNCs - the country of incorporation and profit repatriation - must play a role. Where MNCs operate at home they are answerable to their governments, yet developed countries have largely failed to take responsibility for the operations of their corporations overseas30. Home states are typically developed countries with a stronger legal and political infrastructure than the typical host states. Extraterritorial regulatory initiatives by home states of MNCs are important because, as compared to the host state, they usually have greater potential to be both viable and effective. The extent of corporation's responsibilities will provide long and complex debate, but a few core standards, aligned with current OECD and UN guidelines, should be fairly easily agreed upon. The standards would stipulate the minimum to be expected of the MNCs, and it would be normal business practice to meet them. In summary, the prospects for an international regulatory framework legally controlling MNCs are good. Moves have already been made by specialist international bodies, and an avid interest in corporate behaviour by NGOs will keep the topic high on the international agenda. As market liberalisation increases, and the power of MNCs with it, the major steps towards control will come. But, as demonstrated in this article, the problems associated with organising, implementing and enforcing control are many. Given the complex nature of the problems at least one thing is almost certain, an integrated regulatory framework, rather than single international, national or internal agreements, is needed. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level UK, European & Global Economics section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level UK, European & Global Economics essays

  1. Marked by a teacher

    What are some of the problems of WTO mechanisms will pose for national governments?

    3 star(s)

    For example, since the U.S. ban on DDT had more to do with what it did to birds than with what its effect on humans, they would not be allowed as a goal under WTO. The countries cannot seek to help the environment through food standards.


    While developed countries still accounted for three quarters of the global trade in 2000, developing countries have seen their share climb to one third. The dominant factor behind this growth has been an increasing share of manufacturing activities taking place in developing countries, as manufacturers are seeking low cost locations for many stages of the production chain.

  1. Flower Industry in Netherlands

    natural power to enhance production, such as often seen windmills and waterwheels. Netherlands is also a country where different cultures have lived together for centuries. 95% of her population is Dutch, the other 5% is Indonesians, Moroccans, etc. Netherlands is renowned not only for its accomplishments in the arts and

  2. There are 3 areas to judge for sustainability. 1. Economic sustainability. 2.Social sustainability. 3. ...

    Often the problem is lack of property rights, this means the resource is a free good with no one owning the right to limit its use and charge a price. Thus many sustainability problems are outside the price system and a major market failure.

  1. Why has GDP growth been so slow in Somalia?

    to take aid and disperse it between their clan will do so. Famine is not only costly for the government and agonizing for the populace, but it drastically slows the growth of a country. Children are too ill to go to school, disease is spread quicker and the government must spend money (which could have been invested elsewhere)

  2. Where does the World Trade Organisation fit in the overall scheme of international public ...

    Even a sceptic of global governance may concede that there are legitimate zones of intergovernmental collaboration, and that more of the latter is required compared with nineteenth century practice. However, clear thinking and good policy demand a specification of the problem; and, if concerted action is required, a keen sense of the extent and limits of such action.

  1. What as the impact of China's re-engagement with the international community been on its ...

    However, Other Asian states such as Japan also have a strong interest in the stability of the entire area because and disruption of commerce would be felt immediately throughout the Asia-Pacific region (loc.cit 176). ASEAN countries realize that their security , both at home and in the region, depends on a pluralism of power (loc.cit: 171).

  2. Free essay

    Multinational Corporations in context

    On another note BOC London Branch, the first overseas branch of the Chinese banks, was established in 1929 and from then on the firm has spread to several other regions. It is prominently recognised as the oldest bank in the People's Republic of China and currently operates in over 27 countries.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work