• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

What Happened to Railtrack Shows the ultimate failure of Privatisation.

Extracts from this document...


What Happened to Railtrack Shows the ultimate failure of Privatisation. Discuss? The word Privatisation has been used in a variety of contexts, ranging from returning state owned companies to the private sector, contracting out services to the private sector and liberalisation and deregulation. Although the most common definition of Privatisation is the idea that involves transferring the production of goods and services from the public sector to the private sector. Privatisation generally involves two main objectives. Firstly there is the objective to reduce the role of the government in economic affairs and share ownership of the public. The other main objective is to make public organizations operate in a more cost effective manner, essentially the public asset is sold because it is felt that the private sector could more effectively provide that service. The main arguments for Privatisation are that historically, with communist countries, the state is not a good decider of how to distribute factors of production. The bureaucratic processes involved with decision making prevent efficiency gains which arise through the market mechanism. ...read more.


A further criticism is that several organisations have been taken over by foreign competitors. E.g. an American company owns Northern Electric while Northumbria Water are owned by a French company. This takes money out of the local economy and allows transfer pricing. The main case that will be focused upon in this argument is the failed privatisation of Railtrack in1996. Railtrack PLC was formed in 1994 to be the custodian of Britain's railway infrastructure. As well as the running and upkeep of track, signals, stations, depots, arches, bridges and viaducts, the company has one of the country's largest property portfolios, including over 40,000 commercial property units and thousands of hectares of land. Firstly, it is worth saying that, in theory, the privatization of the rail industry in 1996 wasn't necessarily a bad idea. British Rail was hardly doing an acceptable job of running the railways. Efficiency was non-existent, investment was kept to a minimum, and trains were just as late and just as untidy. ...read more.


It has had to make big penalty payments for poor reliability. In conclusion to this argument, Railtracks case does not show the ultimate failure of Privatisation. My opinion is that Railtrack is one example of fussy management and greed which then led to the failure of Privatisation, however the process itself was not at fault. There are many other examples of where Privatisation has worked well, these include BT (1984), British Gas (1986), British Airways (1987). Privatisation it seems only works well in industries with less regulation, which have the potential to work more efficiently with less interference. However some industries are regulated because they have the potential to exploit the customer, these industries would be more difficult and dangerous to privatise. Privatisation depends on the right set of internal and external factors to work successfully. Good management, workers, communication and motivation are essential as well as external factors such as the amount of help from the government to get it underway, the competition in the new private market, the customer response to the new system. Without these key factors to drive the process of privatisation, then it maybe unsuccessful, and this is simply what happened with Railtrack. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Markets & Managing the Economy section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Markets & Managing the Economy essays

  1. Marked by a teacher

    Discuss the merits of road pricing (25)

    4 star(s)

    more subsidies could be given to infant industries. These schemes will only reduce congestion to a certain extent, it will not be completely eliminated as private vehicles have an extremely inelastic demand because they give the road user flexibility and they are therefore willing to pay a high price to

  2. How successful has privatisation been?

    Almost all of the denationalisations involved under-valued share prices to encourage their sale. With hindsight, this encouragement was not really required as there were normally at least five times as many willing customers as there were shares. Obviously the shares rocketed in value as soon as they were issued, giving

  1. Explain why environmental pollution is regarded as a source of market failure? Evaluate three ...

    Taxes are said to be more effective on the economic front as they give faster results. Gordon Brown, the chancellor of the UK has introduced a new energy tax in the year 99, which would be imposed on industry from the year 2110.

  2. Discuss whether the privatisation of British Rail has been successful. Evaluate whether the new ...

    Consequently, subsidy is required in operate at this point. E1 = socially efficient output level Private monopolist would produce where MC = MR (i.e. price is Pm output Qm) Monopoly profits = the yellow shaded rectangle Deadweight loss under private monopolist = EZE1 KEY PROBLEM: losses are made in the long run, so subsidy is required.

  1. Is the Government to Blame for Higher Petrol Prices?

    When it was unknown how badly oil production in the area had fared prices spiked. Source: What Petrol Prices? As can be seen from the diagram after the initial speculation of damage and gradual replacement of the lost capacity in the Gulf occurred Petrol Prices began to tail off now

  2. Communism - A Failed Russian System

    His government would have not any opportunity to decide if they wished to be controlled by other parties. Marx had said in his writings that this was necessary to put down all opposition and put Communist reforms into place. Under his control the Soviet Union underwent many radical changes that led to the development of New Economic Policy (NEP)

  1. This case study will examine the regulatory failure of antitrust laws in relation to ...

    but did not benefit consumer by providing better price, product or service. 2. IBM had hindered the development of service and peripherals competitors by maintaining a single price policy for its machines, software and support services. It also has granted discount for universities and other educational institutions and by doing so, it has influenced those places to select IBM computers.

  2. The Rail Industry.

    2002 the not for profit organisation Network Rail took control of Railtrack's responsibilities. 1.3 The Current Status Of Regulation Of UK Railways The diagram opposite demonstrates the interactions between the various stakeholders in the railways of the UK at present.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work