• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

"Compare and explore the notion of 'status' and 'power' in No One Writes to the Colonel and The House of Spirits"

Extracts from this document...


"Compare and explore the notion of 'status' and 'power' in No One Writes to the Colonel and The House of Spirits" Latin America has a history, in only the previous century, of being an area of the world where dreams are kindled by revolutionaries talking of long away countries where democracy can work. Detached from the rest of the world, it gives the impression of a parallel universe - or so it would seem from the allusions created between the countries in The House of Spirits and No One Writes to the Colonel and the real countries of Chile and Columbia. In these two tales, the notion of status and power play a very big part, not least because of the role they have to play in South American history. In a land where governments are fickle and most families have lost someone to a revolution in the past, South America - and in particular Chile and Columbia - are heavily involved in politics. The House of Spirits and No One Writes to the Colonel deal with political themes in two very different ways, although there are certain similarities. An achievement of both writers is masking their political themes slightly - The House of Spirits follows several plot lines, and most of the book covers non-political events with politics very much an undercurrent of the main plot - that of a family saga. However, at the climax, politics is driven swiftly to the fore with terrible and tragic results. ...read more.


Socialism in The House of Spirits and No One Writes to the Colonel is much more achievable than communism, and many of the characters, particularly in The House of Spirits, are socialists - even some of the upper class characters such as the del Valle family and Jaime are strong supporters of socialism - Jaime in particular devotes his entire life to helping the poor and sick. This is an interesting display of social class, as the author doesn't paint a black and white picture of classes. Jaime almost seems to wish to atone for being born into the upper class, which is hardly surprising considering the sentiments of his father - "you're a hopeless loser, son" he tells Jaime, "you have no sense of reality" - sadly, this proves to be accurate by the end of the novel. Fate cruelly plays with Jaime, and after devoting his life to helping others he is killed by the fascist regime his father helped install. I believe that Jaime symbolises socialism more than any other character in the book. His desire to help others above all, his kind, gentle nature and his almost monk-like lifestyle seem to embody the core socialist ideals. Other characters, like Pedro Tercero or Miguel have other reasons aside from their socialist ideals that drive them - love for Blanca and hatred for conservatism and fascism retrospectively, but Jaime chooses to give up everything save that which he needs to help others. He believes that "helping one's neighbour is a value that exists." ...read more.


Gradually, she too gets drawn into the world of politics. She quickly becomes shrewd in this media, to the extent that even Esteban Trueba praises her for her political mind - "my granddaughter Alba, however, saw the true nature of the dictator long before I did." However, even as Alba has gained the respect of one of the most sexist males in the novel as a person, and not just his granddaughter, her new found equality is taken away from her. By being taken to a prison camp, all that the three women have strived for seems to be lost, it seems that the chain will end with Alba. Although she survives, the country, and the socialist dream, is in ruins. Compared to No One Writes to the Colonel, women are presented in a favourable light - whilst I don't believe that The House of Spirits is mainly a book about women, I believe that Clara and Alba in particular are very important characters. In contrast, No One Writes to the Colonel presents the wife of the Colonel, the main female character, as somewhat of an obstacle in the way of socialism. She is portrayed as practical but not at all aware of the bigger picture. I think that status and power are presented quite differently in The House of Spirits and No One Writes to the Colonel. They are both political novels, but neither chiefly so - The House of Spirits has a fatalism theme and No One Writes to the Colonel possesses an individualism theme, other themes can also be found in both stories. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Other Authors section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Other Authors essays

  1. To The Lighthouse--symbols & parallel

    Ramsay always opposes the idea of going to lighthouse. Yet, years after the war, with James' changed perception, when he ponders on the lighthouse again, he thinks of the tyranny that he really hates instead of his father. In short, the truth, the objects are there all the time, but

  2. "Strange Meeting" by Susan Hill. Explore and evaluate the ways in which ...

    Hilliard understands how this feels therefore he feels pitiful and that it is his duty protect him as when he first experienced death he dealt it by himself. " Come on" "we'd better go back" "David" Hilliard said Barton then replied "No.It's alright".

  1. (Creative Writing) Imagine that Baba writes a letter to Rahim Khan after he and ...

    You remember General Taheri, agha? A decorated general in Kabul, worked for the Ministry of Defence? He has a daughter. One that seems to have made an impression on Amir it seems. Her name is Soraya; there was some talk about her. That there was a man once, and things, didn't go well.

  2. How does Mansfield explore ideas on marriage in two of her stories

    A sense of frustration is created inside the reader as they see the foolishness of Bertha and her denial of the truth. Mansfield uses Miss Fulton to mock Bertha with her sarcasm at the end of the story of 'your lovely pear tree- pear tree- pear tree'.

  1. Howards End

    Wilcoxes feelings and how they block them out through 'fortresses' and hiding their emotions explains their materialism without it their would be 'panic and emptiness.' When discussing the matter of the letter Mrs Wilcox's name is never mentioned she is referred to as an 'invalid' which again shows the lack

  2. "This (novel) is a failure, and had to be, since it was written by ...

    Billy believes that even though there is always despair in life, there is always a bright side to everything. Billy believes that he is like the "the bug trapped in amber stone" unable to defy fate or destiny and that we have our entire life laid out for us.

  1. In death, Carlo is described as 'the perfect figure of the perfect man.' To ...

    by telling the woman a euphemised version of events and in doing so saved them further pain. However, some people may say that in euphemising the twist of events leading to Francesco's death, Carlo was a liar. It is a debatable question as to whether he should have told the unbearable truth, or a more tolerable contended but fictional anecdote.

  2. Presentation of Stevens - The Remains of the Day

    The emphasis on profession also reinforces to the readers how Stevens believes you can not do anything for fun, it all has to be for the most important profession there is, being a butler. Ishiguro presents Steven's obsession with his profession in more than one way.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work