• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Norman MacCaigs Assisi is an intriguing poem, in which a contrast is used to create an intense feeling of irony and sympathy. Discuss.

Extracts from this document...


Assisi Norman MacCaig's "Assisi" is an intriguing poem, in which a contrast is used to create an intense feeling of irony and sympathy. From the outset MacCaig uses shocking images to create sympathy for the beggar. The first image occurs at the beginning of the first line, which induces a feeling of shock within the reader. The beggar is described as a "dwarf", and goes on to say his "hands [were] on backward", which is at the end of the same line. He is also said to have "tiny twisted legs". Perhaps the best description of the beggar is the simile on line two, in which MacCaig compares him to a "half filled sack". The word "slumped" implies the shape of the beggar's back is like the arch of the sack. The leaky bag of sawdust could resemble the energy and life draining from him, and could also indicate that he was physically damaged. The common letter "S" in the alliteration of this image is onomatopoeic, and suggests the running of the sawdust. ...read more.


To contrast the description of the church, directly after it we are told about social injustice in the church's neglect of it's duty. MacCaig ironically tells us that it was built "in honour of St. Francis". As the church was dedicated to a saint, you would expect it's main purpose to be continuing the work of that particular saint. We are then told the Saint Francis was a "brother of the poor" indicating that he helped those who needed it most. This forces us to reflect on the position of the beggar, who was suffering outside the church, cleverly showing that the church was not continuing the work of Saint Francis and therefore if failing to fulfil it's duty. The beggar didn't have many things going for him. His only advantage over Saint Francis was "not being dead yet". This implies that he is close to death by the use of the term "yet", and indicates that he is desperate and pathetic. The sympathy we feel for him is built up, through the use of very black ironic humour. ...read more.


He is described as a "ruined temple", which brings Saint Francis and the beggar even closer together, indicating that the beggar is worthy of worship and salvation, as he has coped with harsh conditions when the people who are supposed to be helping him, are ignoring him. After these harsh terms, there is a change in tone showing MacCaig's attitude towards the beggar. He is said to have "a voice as sweet as a child's", indicating that MacCaig took the time to help him, which the beggar is grateful for emphasising the beggar's purity and innocence. This is well placed to contrast with the harsh conditions, thus enhancing the sense of innocence and vulnerability. The poem makes us feel sympathetic towards the beggar right up until the end. We are reminded of the beginning of the poem by the reference back to Saint Francis talking with birds. At this time at the beginning we are told that the beggar doesn't have long to live, leaving us feeling helpless, as it is too late to help him, and we can't change it. Assisi is a very moving poem, which allows us to reflect upon ourselves as well as the poem at the end. Claire Cuthbert ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Other Poets section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Here's what a teacher thought of this essay

4 star(s)

**** 4 STARS

A well written essay which uses accurate literary terminology and uses appropriately selected quotes to support statements throughout. Analysis is accurate, detailed and
perceptive. A slightly longer intro and conclusion are necessary.

Marked by teacher Katie Dixon 24/09/2013

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Other Poets essays

  1. Marked by a teacher

    Aftermath Poem Analysis

    4 star(s)

    One can see a sense of frustration and anger in the soldiers about the war in the third stanza. "And the anger, the blind compassion that seized and shook you then." (17) The reader can see the idea of frustration and violence.

  2. Marked by a teacher

    What methods does Browning use to tell the poem Fra Lippo Lippi Line 1-39?

    3 star(s)

    Also in this poem the monk mentions rats as he is trying to mock the watchmen's with the use of metaphor. Browning uses metaphor as a figure of speech in line (9-11) informing the readers that he resembled the watchmen's as rats.

  1. Anaylsis of the poem "Morning at the Window"

    The speaker evokes to the reader that he is "aware" of the unhappy working class.

  2. Write a close analysis of Penelope Explain how Duffy creates the female voice and ...

    It still remains that the world, the real world outside the realms of her 'cloth and scissors' is still one where man dominates. . 'Thetis' also shows the empowering of a woman as the poem progresses, in this poem Duffy again repeats 'I' seventeen times in order to present the

  1. "A Case of Murder" by "Vernon Scannel" is a poem which deals with ...

    Next is "Crack" the force put behind the stick forceful and deadly. Lastly "Hissed" the loud noise when the cat is hurting, the noise to let someone know the cat is in pain. Poetic techniques are a big part in the poem.

  2. The Glass Jar (Gwen Harwood) Analysis. The Glass Jar, dedicated to Vivian Smith, ...

    For the boy, his glass jar full of light is his hope or weapon against the dark, but as the poem develops we become aware that from a Christian viewpoint the boy's hope is futile while he harbours 'his most secret hate'.

  1. Wagan Watsons poetry is often read as a representation of race and racial tensions, ...

    behind us.' The description of the city as having a 'menacing glow' provides a negative connotation in itself, which could be said to display his bitterness towards the civilisation towards the city; examples of this include, '... haunted by the silhouettes of urban myth,' 'the city's tainted body,' 'the dying

  2. In The Trees Are Down poet Charlotte Mew seems to be using the trees ...

    and progress ? that is, ways of making ?easy money?, and fast, and stopped taking the time to appreciate the arts, and the world in which they lived. Forests were cut down, countryside was destroyed so that railroads and factories could be built and set up, and this is still being done, today!

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work