• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

French Revolution a Bourgeoisie Revolution?

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Why do some historians regard the French Revolution as a 'Bourgeoisie Revolution'? Why do some revisionists dispute this view? Historians who refer to the French Revolution as a 'Bourgeoisie Revolution' may do so considering several factors like, the bourgeoisie being the chief beneficiaries of the revolution; and the power struggle they were confronted with in the form of a socially exclusive nobility determined to preserve their rights of luxury from a 'wealthy, talented and progressive' bourgeoisie. Revisionists who dispute the claims that the bourgeoisie were the ultimate cause of the Revolution include many reasons such as the fact that the nobles and the bourgeoisie were infact not clearly differentiated as two separate class estates because of their many shared interests and the passage into nobility being only a matter of wealth or marriage. ...read more.

Middle

Not is it now possible to maintain that this elite grew less open as the eighteenth century went on thanks to some exclusive 'aristocratic reaction' Revisionists also tend to support the view that both groups shared liberal values of the philosophes. While the bourgeoisie were essentially moderate, the nobles acquired a capitalist mentality and both desired the extinction of monarchical despotism and reformation of France according to rational standards. The elimination of aristocratic privileges, according to revisionists, was never part of a preconceived bourgeoisie program, but an improvised response to the violent upheavals in the country side in july and august 1789. In addition to that, a struggle erupted over the composition of the Estates General, this lead to a sudden class consciousness among the bourgeoisie. Albert Soboul being one of the historians that support the 'Bourgeoisie Revolution' states, "the essential cause of the Revolution was the power of a Bourgeoisie arrived at its maturity and confronted by a decadent aristocracy holding tenaciously to it's privileges." ...read more.

Conclusion

For instance, they demanded a constitution representing the whole "nation". This aim was openly expressed in an immensely influential pamphlet that appeared in 1789 called 'What is the Third Estate?' written by Abbe Sieyes. The pamphlet answered the question arguing that the Third Estate alone constituted the nation, the nobility being nothing but privileged parasites: "The nobility...is truly a nation apart, but a bogus one which, lacking organs to keep it alive, clings to a real nation like those vegetable parasites which can live only on the sap of the plants that they impoverish and blight." This also further reflects the great class differences and the resentment and rage. The constitution also incorporated the Declaration of the Rights of Man and the Citizen that had been adopted by the National Assembly in August 1789. This was drawn up by and therefore favouring the bourgeoisie as they were the ones overlooking it. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Modern European History, 1789-1945 section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Modern European History, 1789-1945 essays

  1. Marked by a teacher

    Major Causes of French Revolution

    4 star(s)

    However, the important aspect was the economy couldn't provide decent living conditions for the people. Anger towards the 'well-off' spread. "Hatred grows more bitter and the state is divided into two classes: the greedy and the insensitive, and the murmuring malcontents"8 France's system of government was still the absolute system

  2. 'The French Revolution was directed by the middle class.' How valid is this comment ...

    revolt because they feared that they would lose some of the improvements they had had since the Assembly's rise to power. The fact that passive citizens were not admitted into the National Guard could explain the control the Assembly kept over France, as revolutionary groups did not have the organisation or weaponry they needed in order to take over.

  1. In the process of consolidating his position, Napoleons reforms, had by 1808, destroyed the ...

    - there is no liberty in this system; the French public are made to comply with the government's rules when it comes to religion. This is not free, and is a sign of a betrayal within a betrayal. Correspondingly, the Concordat also inaugurated the idea of free worship - Catholic

  2. 'In the context of the period 1715-1815 to what extent were economic factors the ...

    the French population for her Austrian heritage, extravagent behaviour, and unsympathetic attitude to the plight of the lower classes, indicated by such actions as the 'March of the Women on Versailles' demonstrating the mob's hatred of her. The King chose to implement his authority over the country through his 36 intendents.

  1. Why did the French Revolution end in 1799?

    He could give the people a long awaited leadership and help restore order in their lives. The Directory was a corrupt, self-serving government. For its entire reign it was moribund and bound for failure. When the government began in 1795 it was weak, with dangerous enemies from the left and right wing groups.

  2. To what extent were the Bourgeoisie responsible for the outbreak of Revolution in 1789?

    He asserted that French society in the 18th century was divided and sub-divided into different groups, and social diversification among each group was so diverse that it was impossible to talk in terms of clear cut class based revolution. It is this factor that accounts for the uniqueness of the French society.

  1. Notes and Reading on the causes of the French Revolution.

    The territorial jurisdiction of Paris is too large. The Cahier of the nobility of Bouzonville The third estate complained of the Ségur ordinance of 1781 which restricted commissioned entry into the army to those with four generations of nobility The profession of arms has become almost humiliating for the provisional nobility In contempt of seniority and of the

  2. The French Revolution Broke Out Because Of a Shortage of Bread Discuss.

    yet they were still ruled by an Absolute Monarch who claimed all power. They spread them to other people around France, hoping they would agree and help achieve these rights. Quite a lot of people now wanted to change the way France was governed.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work