• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

The Significance of the Irish Convention, 1917

Extracts from this document...


The Irish Convention. Holly Anderson. "The Irish Convention, 1917, had no real significance." Discuss. The Irish Convention was aimed at addressing the Home Rule question and other constitutional problems by involving all Irish parties in the hope of reaching a solution through means of compromise. Held in Trinity College Dublin, the delegates attending consisted of 26 Ulster Unionists, 9 Southern Unionists, 6 Labour representatives, 2 Liberals, and a Nationalist majority of 52. Of these Nationalists, however, none were members of the Sinn Fein Party, and so there was a lack of complete participation from all of the Irish parties and therefore, an insufficient representation of Irish political opinion. This would prove to be one of the crucial reasons why the Convention inevitably failed to accomplish it's original goals, but there were several other reasons why the idea was faced with problems from the start. The Ulster Unionists failed to partake in the Convention constructively and conflict was ripe between the party and the Southern Unionists. Seemingly unresolvable disputes over fiscal issues reinforced the Ulster Unionists' desire for partition. Although it failed to reach any real decisions on the answer to the Irish question, it did result in new problems for the parties involved. ...read more.


As the Ulster Unionists wanted Westminster to deal with Ireland's taxation, and the Nationalists wanted Irish parliament to be able to have their own control, Redmond and conservative Nationalists were keen to accept Midleton's Liberal Convention Policy. It allowed an Irish parliament to control internal taxation, but gave control of custom duties over to Westminster. Initially it seemed like a settlement was finally on the horizon, but more extreme Nationalists, such as Devil and Bishop O'Donnell, rejected the idea and Redmond was forced to withdraw his support. The Nationalists were becoming divided and humiliated in defeat and Redmond decided that he could no longer be of service to the Convention. But he wasn't the only party leader facing a conflict within his own party. Unfortunately for Midleton, not all Southern Unionist members agreed with the idea of abandoning their plans of a Home Rule opposition. Outside of the Convention on 20th February, a group of Southern Unionists met in the Shelbourne Hotel in Dublin, deciding they would not give up the fight for the Union. Forming a new Unionist party called the Southern Unionist Committee, or the 'Callers,' they tried to have the Executive Committee of the Irish Unionist Alliance to stop Midleton's policy, but to no avail. ...read more.


L. Lyons argues that "the convention had two important consequences; firstly it forced Nationalists to realise that Ulster Unionists were not bluffing in their rejection of HR, and secondly it increased Sinn Fein's advantage over the Irish Parliamentary Party." [2.] The Irish Parliamentary party were once again undermined because of their failure to apply Home Rule with immediate affect. Redmond's support for Midleton's policy had cause the initial split in the party, leaving it weakened and an easy opponent for the rising Sinn Fein party. Sinn Fein made a smart political move in avoiding the conference, as their absence was perhaps more valuable to them in the long run than their participation would have been. The Irish Conference may not have worked through the Irish question and constitutional problems it had intended to solve, but it's clear that it did have some real significance. The conference further weakened and helped to destroy the Irish Parliamentary Party, after taking one final chance on a last concession, Redmond had failed once more and died 'knowing that he had failed to deliver Home Rule.' (Rees) The relationship between the Southern Unionists and the Ulster Unionists had been severely weakened and a partition in Ireland was made more likely. [1.] The Unresolved Question - Nicholas Mansergh [2.] Ireland Since the Famine - S. F. L. Lyons ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Other Historical Periods section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Other Historical Periods essays

  1. How successfully did the Labour governments of 1945-51 solve the social problems of the ...

    The housing project was further hampered by a lack of construction workers and a major shortage and high cost of raw materials, with the result that the project was cut back on in 1949 at the Treasury's insistence. Consequentially, the emphasis was placed on the construction of council houses for rent and temporary prefabricated homes to try and meet demand.

  2. How and why did the Bolsheviks gain power in 1917?

    Being appointed Commander-in-Chief by Kerensky, General Lavr Kornilov soon had within his power the ability to cause great problems for the provisional government. Just before a conference to be held in Moscow between 12-15 August, General Kornilov ordered his troops to be within 200 miles of Petrograd, to the south.

  1. What was the short term significance of the Amritsar Massacre?

    Indeed, the Amritsar Massacre wonderfully succeeded to completely alienate the Indian elites and middle class who were previously Moderates or even pro-British. Tagore, the renowned Indian poet, rejected his knighthood, which was shameful "in their incongruous context of humiliation"10; Motial Nehru, who was so staunchly pro-British that he sent his

  2. Consider David Starkey(TM)s and Francis Pryor(TM)s respective versions of the nature and extent of ...

    The third stage is that of British rule up to around 550 when the Anglo Saxons begin to expand throughout the country. The last stage is continued expansion throughout the country. There were regional variations as one would expect considering the size of the country and the variety of society in this area.

  1. Who was more important in bringing about the end of Apartheid and minority rule ...

    However external pressure, economic sanctions, pressure from advisors and business leaders, terrible domestic unrest which threatened civil war and the collapse of eastern bloc communism (which meant the communist linked ANC seemed less of a threat) convinced him of the need to change the apartheid system.

  2. Discuss the course and consequences of the Arab Israeli Conflict

    It can then be established that, as Eliezer Ben-Yehuda declared, "We shall buy, buy, buy", and "...the Arabs will (not) know what we are after...we shall act like silent spies", that the Zionists had no intention of informing the Arabs', or being aware of the Palestinian Arabs' opinion on their intentions to establish a Jewish State.

  1. How effective was the leadership provided by prominent individual nationalists in Malaya?

    His attacks on the aristocracy and royal courts further alienated the common Malay man from Ibrahim's vision, which seemed far away and lofty. The pan-Malayan state did not connect with the Malays, who felt more aligned with their state and Sultan than with the country Malaya.

  2. Why was Ireland Partitioned

    The Ulster loyalist anti repeal union was also established. They had a conditional loyalty to the crown which means they supported it as long as it did not interfere with their interests5. In 1886 the Belfast anti-Unionist riots damaged the Home Rule cause in the North. Also in that year Queens University became an independent University instead of affiliating to the other British Universities.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work