• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Ugly or Quiet American

Extracts from this document...


Ashley Williams October 26, 2006 HIST 171 - Schwartz The Cold War in the Third World: Views of American Foreign Policy as Presented in The Ugly American and The Quiet American Although the popular view of Cold War is frequently characterized as a battle between two polar superpowers, the capitalist United States and the communist Soviet Union, it can be argued that the war's real battles were fought, not over red phones with threats of nuclear annihilation, but on the fringes of civilization with propaganda and foreign aid. Desperate to gain control over nonaligned nations and prevent each other from enlarging their ideological sphere of influence, the United States and Soviet Union competed for dominance in the Third World in a contest of diplomacy. Greene's The Quiet American and Lederer and Burdick's The Ugly American both present portraits of America's struggle to "save" Southeast Asia from the clutches of communism during the height of the Cold War. Although the authors have different goals and thus take different perspectives in their writing, both books serve a similar purpose. Through painting portraits of Americans abroad, describing the inefficiencies and excesses of American diplomatic programs, and suggesting that America has overstepped its boundaries only to lose its battle with communism, the novels offer striking criticisms of the failures of American foreign policy. In both The Quiet American and The Ugly American, the authors use the personalities and actions of their characters as a vehicle to reflect of the nature of American involvement abroad. ...read more.


Pyle's ultimate death, a result of his indiscretion and blundersome meddling, serves as Greene's warning to American leaders to rethink their foreign policy or risk suffering the same fate. In contrast with Greene's technique of presenting two characters within a single plot line, Lederer and Burdick frame The Ugly American as a series of interconnected fictional anecdotes designed to reflect America's involvement in international affairs in a range of scenarios. As such, it provides a subtler and less inflammatory critique of American foreign policy. With its reflections of Americans abroad as both helpful missionary types and egotistical interlopers, the novel caught the attention of President Eisenhower and encouraged his administration to review America's diplomatic and political strategy in Asia. The Ugly American, unlike The Quiet American, which was popularly dismissed as anti-American propaganda, enjoyed runaway success, largely because the Lederer and Burdick skillfully managed to include realistic criticisms and suggestions for change within a framework that praised the American people's goodhearted contributions to fighting the Cold War. The "good" characters of the novel, such as Colvin the well-meaning milkman, the fearless and devoted Father Finian, and Atkins the pragmatic, plain spoken engineer, offer an insight into the mindsets of concerned Americans who were willing to make personal sacrifices for what they believed to be a worthy and admirable cause. Amidst these tales of American goodwill, however, the authors plant the seeds of their critique. ...read more.


Ultimately, The Quiet American and The Ugly American succeed in crystallizing the nature of American intervention in Southeast Asia in terms of its economic, political, and social ramification. As the de facto colonial power in many Third World nations including those described in the two novels, the United States, despite its adamant disavowals of imperialist motivations, found itself embroiled in a situation where it was fighting to prevent the communists from adulterating its ideological satellites while simultaneously working to ensure that these nations would remain friendly to American policy. The establishment of a Third Force, thus, meant far more than simply finding a non-communist power to lead these non-aligned nations - it entailed choosing a government that could be trusted to resist the communist at all costs, a government whose tendencies were clearly and undeniably Western. By assuming the inherent weakness and inferiority of the Third World nations it was trying to aid, America alienated the individuals and groups it should have been considering as candidates to leadership, thus transforming their enmity into support for communism or other forms of anti-Western doctrine. As The Quiet American and The Ugly American suggest, the ultimate problem with Washington's strategy for defending Southeast Asia lies in the plan's lack of forethought and the obvious differences between its stated objectives and the political implications associated with the achievement of those goals. ?? ?? ?? ?? 1 ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level International History, 1945-1991 section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level International History, 1945-1991 essays

  1. Introduction to American drama.

    Second World War as the richest and most powerful nation in the world. The economic problems of the Depression had largely been solved by the war economy and, over the next fifteen years, many - but by no means all - American citizens would enjoy a substantial rise in their living standards.

  2. History of the United States

    He skillfully outmaneuvered the South Carolinians, forcing them to relent. In 1832 he vetoed the rechartering of the Second Bank of the United States on the grounds that it caused the booms and busts that so alarmed the country and that it served the wealthy while exploiting the farmers and working people.

  1. Post-Cold War Realities

    They were seen as illegitimate, imperialistic oppressors of their Muslim neighbours and religious brothers. Finally, while Russia remained neutral in the early stages of the Iran-Iraq War, when it seemed as if Iran would triumph, the Soviet Union began supplying Iraq with military hardware and technological assistance.

  2. Discuss the presentation of the differences in the social, personal, and sexual freedom of ...

    Women are demeaned through out the novel. When Pyle mentions how he "trusted" Fowler, Fowlers reply is "always a mistake when women are involved" inferring that women are trouble and to be distanced from. "Ho Chi Minh, the father of modern Vietnam, enshrined sexual equality in the country's constitution and women played an important role - often

  1. Many peoples have contributed to the development of the United States of America, a ...

    Radical Whigs insisted that a corrupt network of Church of England bishops, great landlords, and financiers had combined with the royal government to exploit the community at large, and that--frightened of criticism--this Tory conspiracy sought to destroy liberty and freedom.

  2. Jane Austen's novel Pride and Prejudice is a tale of love and marriage in ...

    The blame for the failure of the operation falls directly in the lap of the Central Intelligence Agency and a young president and his advisors. The fall out from the invasion caused a rise in tension between the two great superpowers and ironically 34 years after the event, the person

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work