• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Who was responsible for the start of the Cold war?

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Who was responsible for the start of the Cold war? In many ways it can be argued that American aggression was responsible for the start of the Cold war although this is a claim much easier to make in hindsight. When analysing the way in which relations between the USA and USSR broke down after the defeat of the Nazis in Europe it is now possible to say that America was perhaps over suspicious of the spread of Communism within the Eastern bloc. Broken down into its simplest terms the Cold war can be viewed as a struggle of two economic systems; The success of one system in turn threatened the other and thus America viewed the spread of Communism as a direct threat to its prosperity which was based upon the principals of free trade. They believed that the rise of Communism in Eastern Europe was largely a Stalinist attempt to boost the economy of Russia by creating a large Soviet sphere of influence within the continent, obedient to Moscow yet historians are now able to look back upon the factors, which led America to this belief and conclude that they were in fact misinformed. In actual fact events such as the Greek communist revolt, into which Stalin had little or no input prove that Stalin's priority was first to insure the prosperity of Communism within Russia itself. In truth the success of Communism within Eastern Europe can ultimately be attributed to the fact that it was a political system which deeply suited the war torn economies in which it thrived In 1945 in Greece economic condition were awful. The country had been torn apart by war and it became a prime example of the type of central European country which could become susceptible to communist takeover. During that year Civil war broke out and many people were suspicious that Stalin had helped to stir up support for the Greek communists. ...read more.

Middle

In 1944 Stalin had marched troops into Iran but had agreed that six months after the end of the war he would remove them. The West did not recognise that oil was Stalin's one and only real motive aside from border protection for maintaining a presence in Iran or at least publicly this is the attitude they displayed. Instead they made out that it was a Stalinist attempt to expand communist ideas into Asia as a result the United States went to the United Nations to demand Stalin withdraw troops from the country. Initially Stalin ignored their demands but eventually succumbed in 1946. The West viewed this as a victory on their part; Stalin had realised that he could not do as he pleased just because he had played a major part in winning the war, the threat of Communism had be extinguished but the East on the other hand saw the Iran crisis as America bullying Russia into a corner and a generally hypocritical and favouritist politics. This was because currently Iran granted oil concessions to the U.S.A and Britain but not Russia. This was most unfair because Russia was the country which most definitely needed the oil the most and arguably deserved it the most too. The crisis, the end of the lend-lease agreement and rejection of reparations to Russia by the West had the cumulative effective of convincing Stalin that the U.S. was set upon the economic destruction of the Soviet Union. It became one of the factors that led to Truman prompting Kennan for his 'Long telegram' and sparked the wave of Anti-Sovietism that permeated the American media. U.S. paper Newsweek in a September 1946 addition lead with the headline, "The Soviet government has made up its mind that Capitalism must be destroyed if Communism is to survive" The battle lines were now well and truly beginning to be drawn between the two superpowers. ...read more.

Conclusion

And, given this, is it possible to argue that had neither side possessed nuclear weapons there would have been less self-restraint exercised by Stalin and Truman instead leading to the possibility of real and 'Hot' war which could potentially have had been far more disastrous implications that what in reality actually happened? In conclusion therefore, it is impossible come to any solid judgement as to when the Cold War actually began and further more who should hold responsibility for its beginnings. A historian must instead try to attach relative significance to each important event which occurred during the early Cold war period and attempt to infer in what ways each was significant to the conflict as a whole. In my opinion Truman's decisions to drop atomic bombs on Hiroshima and Nagasaki were highly important events which shaped the nature of the conflict to come. When in 1949 Stalin responded by developing his own nuclear arsenal this was also highly significant as it removed President Truman from his military high ground and left both sides careful where they trod politically. Ultimately though responsibility for the start of the 'Cold war' conflict has to be laid at the feet of the Americans. Hiroshima and Nagasaki were both acts of extreme aggression not just upon the Japanese but against the entire world - they sent out the message 'Don't mess with America or you'll live to regret it.' In a world already in a fragile state after two world wars in quick succession the U.S. was far too aggressive in it's immediate post-war foreign policies towards East Europe and the Soviet Union and showed no sympathy or willingness to allow this war-torn area to recover economically in a way which suited it. The incentive of increased American economic growth proved to be too great for Truman and his administration and although they were right to be weary of Stalin they took things too far and perhaps had ulterior motives in shielding European countries from communist regime change. ?? ?? ?? ?? Richard Overington 30/04/2007 1 ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level International History, 1945-1991 section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level International History, 1945-1991 essays

  1. This graduation paper is about U.S. - Soviet relations in Cold War period. Our ...

    When that venture failed, the United States nevertheless withheld its recognition of the Soviet government. Back in the United States, meanwhile, the fear of Marxist radicalism reached an hysterical pitch with the Red Scare of 1919-20. Attorney General A. Mitchell Palmer ordered government agents to arrest 3,000 purported members of the Communist party, and then attempted to deport them.

  2. How far was the USSR responsible for the outbreak of the Cold War?

    Czechoslovakia was also an example of the way the communists dealt with Eastern Europe in reality, after liberating it from the Nazis. As soon as there was a danger of communism being compromised as Czechoslovakia considered seeking aid from the Marshall Plan following an economic crisis, Stalin took hard-line measures

  1. To what extent was Hitler solely responsible for the Holocaust

    Instead, he claimed that he was forced to abandon his conscience in order to carry out his work, and that he never did anything without obtaining instructions from Hitler or his superiors. The bureaucrats who have been implicated with the final solution have often been labelled as 'desk murderers', as

  2. How far was Truman personally responsible for the development of the Cold War?

    Stalin believed that the anti-Communist aims behind the Marshall Aid would weaken his hold on eastern Europe. He also felt that the US was trying to dominate as many states as possible by making them dependent on dollars. One by one the USSR supervised European communist movements, from Prague in

  1. How far were White weaknesses responsible for Red success in Russian Civil War?

    it clear to them that they would have to give back most of the land they seized in 1917 urged them to desert the battlefields in their thousands or to revolt, which in Denikin's case, forced him to send troops back from the front and thus weakening his ability to push forward to Moscow.

  2. Superpower Relations 1945-90

    and SS-5 intermediate-range missiles on Cuba, was a cheaper and quicker way for the USSR to catch up in the arms race. o The USA had 15 Jupiter missiles in Turkey targeting every city in the south of the USSR.

  1. Why did the Cold War start

    Yalta Conference were not held, and adopted a new foreign policy of containment to keep communism within the areas where it was already in affect. Matters were made worse by the fact that within the regions of Soviet Control, soviet armed forces made it difficult for non-communist parties to gain political influence as opposition leaders were exiled, executed, or imprisoned.

  2. To what extent was Soviet expansion responsible for the outbreak of the Cold War ...

    But Truman still felt that communism was particularly attractive to poor and discontented people and it could best be resisted by economic prosperity, therefore, he thought that a prosperous Europe with close commercial links to the United States was less likely to fall under communist influence.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work