• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Choose two arias you have studied and write a comparison between the two (AQA AS Level MUSIC)

Extracts from this document...


Choose two contrasting arias from the music you have studied and write informatively about each. 1. Handel: The Messiah, 48: The Trumpet Shall Sound 2. No. 6 (tenor) from Ich Elender Mensch, Cantata 48, Bach 'The trumpet shall sound' is a Da Capo aria written for bass voice, a trumpet obbligato, strings and a continuo. This piece is hugely triumphant and demonstrates a sense of victory and celebration. Perhaps the most fundamental contribution towards this is it being based in a major key, and with a march like tempo. The tempo marking is aptly labelled as 'pomposo', meaning pompously and 'ma non allegro' which means but not allegro. This would help ensure the piece is performed with magnificence and majesty. The rhythms of the notes are also very basic being mostly crotchets with quavers for decoration and to add a sense of movement. Semiquavers are only used in conjunction with a dotted quaver and never consecutively as this would distort the picture that Handel has so carefully painted by added speed, which would remove some of the sense of exultancy. ...read more.


This section only has the basso continuo and the voice sounding, presenting an entirely new texture that we had not heard before within the piece. The sense of grandeur that was stated so thoroughly before has been lost and the listener is left with a feeling of emptiness and sadness. The "Piano" dynamic markings add to the gloom of this section and bring us to the end of the piece (the major section is however repeated due to the fact this is a Da Capo aria, in which the piece is repeated from the sign). Whilst the use of harmony and chordal progressions within 'the trumpet shall sound' is fairly basic, in the aria for tenor, Bach explores chromaticism and modulation to a much larger extent than Handel. The piece starts in the key of G minor but within 7 bars it has briefly modulated to F major. It explores harmony to a much greater depth than the Handel aria. This is reflective of the periods in which they were written, and the message they are trying to communicate. ...read more.


Whilst both of the melodies in the pieces seem quite controlled, there are some instances in the Bach aria where the gentle nature is questionable. There is an instance when the voice leaps a 7th, up to an Ab which provides quite a striking change (as it is to a diminished chord). This could be to show anguish and pain. It is only brief, however there some other such instances that follow, perhaps to convey the same emotion. The setting of words and word-painting is something that Handel is often acknowledged for. His melismatic phrases within this aria are quite common. The first such instance is to the word "chang'd" where the voice takes part in producing an elaborate run of quavers in a sequential pattern. The word change is used as the notes are also changing. Less uses of melisma occur in the Bach aria except for in the small cases of two consecutive rising semiquavers that are used near the beginning of the phrases. Other such word painting is the use of seventh leaps. Oliver Palmer Music Essay: Aria ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Music section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Music essays

  1. The Life of G.F. Handel

    There were also masterminds such as Hayden and Mozart who added to the culmination marking the development to what we consider classical music. Handel composed well over two hundred pieces in his lifetime. Ranging from oratorios, operas, cantatas, sacred and secular vocals, masques, odes, spurious to instrumentals and stage performances.

  2. What is the nature of employment in the music industry?

    Also a self employed person in the United Kingdom is known as a sole trader or the company is known as an incorporated limited liability company. Many people, who form a business, run it only part-time or concurrently while they're in a full time job.

  1. The stimulus we were given for our drama piece was a painting by Paula ...

    Therefore, we could remain in the style we wanted the dance to be performed continuously. As none of us in my dance group had ever done dance before, we were very systematic about the 3 main stages of performance studies development and were attentive when improvising to use the skills

  2. French Flute Music between 1935 and 1955: Varèse, Messiaen and Jolivet

    Since Var�se composed and published this piece of flute music the density of platinum has actually changed to 21.45. Var�se also footnoted that Density 21.5 should always be played in strict time and that the metronomic indication should be closely followed.

  1. Explain how Handel achieves a sense of majesty in his setting of The King ...

    Many musical devices are used within Handel's The King Shall Rejoice; these small details added to the music often convey ideas to the audience, such as the idea of the majesty of the occasion. Handel's use of rests within a certain phrase, gives the phrase the impression of short bursts of music, this device creates drama and also tension.

  2. An Experiment To Show Weather The Tempo (speed) Of A Piece Of Background Music ...

    There was a random mix of short and long words travelling in all directions. I chose a word search as they can be frustrating and you have to concentrate to find the answer. At one point one subject stated, '' Its hard to concentrate, you know the words are in there but they are hard to find.''

  1. Investigation of the people's reaction towards rap music.

    doesn't he will be asked to not answer anymore questions beyond that point. The same applies to question one, but the person must like music to carry on. My survey consists of questions as the following: *THIS INFORATION WILL BE DISPLAYED IN A TABLE. 1. Do you listen to music?

  2. Ground bass

    Below is an example of Pachelbel's ground bass. Pachelbel wrote numerous melodic variations over this ground bass: In its earlier form, developed in the 13th and 14th centuries, the ground bass never varied in harmonisation or pitch. Such example is the earliest known use of the ground bass 'Sumer Is Icumen In' (between 1240 and 1325).

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work