• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Consider the Problems Faced by Psychologists in the Definition of Abnormality

Extracts from this document...


Consider the Problems Faced by Psychologists in the Definition of Abnormality Abnormality is a term that is difficult to define due to the wide range of behaviours displayed by people. There are not a certain set of characteristics which can be directly related to abnormality, which could therefore be used to define abnormal behaviour. Because of this, each of the separate behaviours must be judged by an independent individual in order to decide whether it ought to be classed as abnormal or normal. However, the judgement made may be affected by a number of factors, most prominently cultural relativism. In an attempt to define abnormality psychologists have put forward four key ways of determining the difference between normal behaviour and deviations from this. These are statistical infrequency, deviation from social norms, deviations from ideal mental health, and a failure to function adequately. The first of the four definitions is statistical infrequency. This method of classification uses deviation from an average in numerical form to show the boundaries of abnormality. This is a way of measuring specific characteristics statistically. A normal distribution curve of a certain behaviour belonging to the population would be drawn, to show the population distribution- the highest percentage should be seen around the middle at the average, with decreasing percentages as the graph moves out to either side, therefore the fewest number of people ought to be at the extremes of the graph. The 2.5% of the population at either extreme (unusually high or low scoring) are deemed to be abnormal in this particular definition. However 2.5% is not the set boundary- this can vary depending on the characteristics displayed in the graph. This definition is a good way to show abnormality because it places behaviours into simple numerical terms to give a visual and statistical representation of what it is to be abnormal. Using this definition it is easy to class someone as either normal or abnormal- if they lie within the boundaries they are normal, however if they lie outside of the boundaries they are abnormal. ...read more.


It is considered that a rapist or murderer's personality is displaying abnormality, not only their behaviour. If only the behaviour (not the character) was abnormal there is a suggestion that anyone would be capable of such an act. This is opposed by the fact that other people are either incapable of committing such a crime or are in control of themselves and so choose not to commit such a crime. There seems to be a key difference between those who would murder someone and those who wouldn't, which must be caused by personality differences. Most people have the capacity to pick up a knife and stab someone to death, however not everyone does- only those with a severe disturbance or psychological problem, other people have the ability to control themselves and prevent such a frenzy. Deviation from social norms can be used to monitor the behaviour of people in the same culture and in a known context by an independent judge. If the same judge were to enter a different culture or unknown context the reliability of their diagnosis of abnormality would be significantly less reliable. As most people are biased in someway; whether it be age group, culture or otherwise, it is difficult to find someone who can be a truly independent judge and can make an unaffected decision. It may be possible to determine whether a friend or family member starts experiencing psychological problems, as there will be a deviation from their normal behaviour; however it is more difficult to make a similar decision based on the behaviour of someone who isn't known as well. Deviation from social norms is so dependent on culture and other factors that this definition of psychological abnormality is severely limited. However it does have its strengths in some particular circumstances. The third definition is deviation from ideal mental health. This was originally suggested by Jahoda in 1958, and was unique at the time as it did not focus on what it was to be abnormal but instead what it was to be normal. ...read more.


For this reason the African-Caribbean immigrants are 2-7 times more likely to be diagnosed with schizophrenia that a British person, as discovered by Cochrane (1977). This may be due to their differences in communications, or their religious beliefs. Cultural changes may also affect a diagnosis- as times change, so do social norms. In the UK, women who were unmarried and pregnant used to be sent to mental asylums as they were seen to be abnormal and the situation was socially unacceptable. Today this is very different; single mothers are accepted in society and are seen as normal by most generations. Similarly with homosexuality; this was illegal in the UK until 1967, and was considered to be a mental disorder in the USA until 1973. Once again, cultural changes mean that homosexuality is now generally accepted and is no longer illegal, although some people still hold old values or religious beliefs and refuse to tolerate this. The definitions of abnormality offered by psychologists are subject to many biases and constrictions due to circumstances, especially being affected by cultural relativism. Each has its strengths and is applicable within separate cultures; however the limitations are also vast. Due to cultural differences not one single definition can be applied world-wide, and this is unlikely to ever be possible whilst maintaining a high level of reliability. It is important to understand the differences between cultures and the limitations of each definition so that psychologists are able to make well-informed and accurate diagnoses. The four definitions offered show much conflict between each other, due to the way in which abnormality is measured. An individual may appear to be normal according to one definition, but abnormal in another. Because of this psychologists must look at the whole picture- the circumstances, the person's personality, the culture, their ability to function appropriately, as well as other factors- in order to make an accurate and reliable decision of a diagnosis. A combination of aspects of each definition may be useful in doing this. ?? ?? ?? ?? 1 28/11/2008 ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level The Psychology of Individual Differences section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level The Psychology of Individual Differences essays

  1. Marked by a teacher

    Compare 2 models of abnormal behaviour in terms of their views on the causes ...

    3 star(s)

    There is good research support. As the patient plays a passive role in the "Medical" model, we must question the ethics of prescribing therapies that may alter or change a patient physically but for which he or she did not give consent.

  2. "Outline and evaluate two definitions of abnormality: statistical infrequency and deviation from social norms."

    why should being in the bottom 2.145% make a person abnormal yet being in the bottom 5% makes another person normal? And who or what is to distinguish between these two behaviours? Statistical definitions of abnormality entirely depend upon cut-off points which are often determined by standard deviations, a

  1. Outline and Evaluate the Biological, Psychodynamic and Cognitive Explanations of Abnormality

    The psychodynamic approach is likely to be affected by cultural relativism more than the biological model, as the approach is not appropriate for all cultures, whereas the biological model is suitable for everyone. Not all cultures would consider talking therapy or ideas about the psyche to be at all accurate, whilst a greater majority (although not all)

  2. Psychological Abnormality

    For example, a person who reacts to the banishment of a favourite football team by attempting to commit suicide. But then Davison and Neale (1994) only viewed unexpected behaviour as that which involves an over reaction. However a behaviour which is out of all proportion can equally refer to an under reaction as well.

  1. Define different theoretical perspectives used in counselling. Analyse the advantages and ...

    Erikson states that the degree that each person experiences these qualities in each stage, will determine the kind of person they are. The theorists that contributed to the behavioural approach were John Watson and Ivan Pavlov. Pavlov worked with dogs and from this he knew that they salivated even when they seen their food dish empty.

  2. Eating disorders

    It is a culture-bound syndrome of Westernised cultures. However, the concept of anorexia as a CBS is not without objectors. Hoek et al. (1998) set out to test the view that anorexia is rare in other cultures. The researchers examined the records of 44,192 people admitted to hospital between 1987 and 1989 in Curacao, a non-Westernised Caribbean Island where it is acceptable to be overweight.

  1. Definitions of Attitudes

    Most psychologists agree that attitudes are acquired through social learning, which is the process of acquiring attitudes through others. Social learning occurs through classical, instrumental and observational learning. Other factors include self-comparison and genetics. Classical conditioning is the process of learning by association, which involves the pairing of stimuli; when one (1)

  2. The contents of this essay will explain different psychological approaches to health and social ...

    Numerous individuals get apprehensive prior to meeting new people but find that, once they are with them, they have the ability to control their nerves and even enjoy the situation. A phobia is also a fear. Individuals have fears concerning such things as heights, spiders and the dark, but for

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work