• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Anaylse of the critiques of Religion and Morality.

Extracts from this document...


ANALYSE THE CRITIQUES OF RELIGION AND MORALITY The question that first arises when considering the link between religion and morality is whether someone can truly be moral without necessitating the existence of God? However, when high levels of moral behaviour are found outside the framework of any religious belief or teaching it seems hard follow Aquinas's line of reasoning that goodness is somehow 'a reflection of the supreme goodness of God'. As Bertrand Russell points out, this suggests that 'a man who loves what is truly good, loves god even if he doesn't advert to God'. In fact, isn't doing what is 'good', simply in the hope a divine reward, immoral and selfish in itself? Dawkins states that if someone needs God holds in order to be moral - to abstain from 'robbery, rape and murder' - then they are unveiling a fairly shocking characteristic. Firstly, it would seem that what needs to be considered is the nature of a morality if it is based on the Devine. Plato in his 'Euthyphro dilemma' asks the question 'is X good because God loves it or does God love X because X is good?' Therefore, for Plato we are left with two options, either an action such as murder is simply wrong because God commands or murder is wrong in its self? ...read more.


In relation to such events, Richard Dawkins states that 'modern morality, wherever else it comes from, does not come from the Bible.' Therefore, it is proposed, that Christians 'cheery pick' Holy Scripture, abstracting only those moral values conforming to the 'cultural norms' of our secular society. Certainly, Christians don't follow some of the commands in Levitcus to stone disobedient children or not eat shellfish. Michael Tanner states that 'the content was evidently for the continuance of the tribe, whose living conditions were vastly different in many ways from ours.' Therefore, the moral principles in the bible are bound to seem quite strange since they have been removed from their original context; this meaning that they have little use for situations in our modern society. For this reason Bertrand Russell describes religion as the 'principle enemy of moral progress in the world.' In fact, far from Morality having any correlation to the existence of a Deity, Richard Dawkins maintains that religion is the main cause of evil in the world. In the 'the selfish gene' (1989) he tries to account for the adaptation of culture in terms of a Darwinian origin and hypothesized the 'meme'; this is any cultural entity replicating through exposure to humans, by a similar method of natural selection, if it tends to promote biological survival. ...read more.


Furthermore, Dawkins in his book 'the selfish gene' (1989) adds that our moral 'altruistic' behaviour (selfless welfare for others) has a biological Darwinian origin. The contention is that the gene serves to guarantee its own survival and replicate itself. Hence, a gene that programs the individual to favour its own genetic kin (organisms with the same genes) has a higher probability of generating copies of itself. For this reason animals may care for, defend, warn of danger and share resources with its fellow individuals. In addition to this he adds reciprocal altruism, a 'you scratch my back and I'll scratch yours' principle; this meaning that we will be altruistic between our own species, and even others, in the intention of repayment. Kinship and reciprocal altruism for Dawkins are the 'twin pillars' for a Darwinian explanation of morality. To this he further adds such things as the 'power of reputation' in our culture for being altruistic; we want to be seen as 'good'. The Darwinian survival value being that we will not just be a good reciprocator but will have a reputation of being a good reciprocator. Therefore, Morality could be described as little more than a set of best practices, Moral terms such as "right" actually meaning 'best for survival' in terms of the Homosapien species. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Practical Questions section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Practical Questions essays

  1. (a) Examine the reasons why some argue that morality is linked ...

    Respect Nature 10. Support Worthy causes N.B. Humanists would argue that there are very good reasons as to why morality should not be linked to religion. They would cite for example the fact that Christian ethics has often bred intolerance (eg. different churches / religions have at times persecuted each other as well as people of other faiths.

  2. "Humanitarian intervention, which is ruled out by realism and the morality of states, can ...

    Of course, there is opposition to this as well, an example being the recent bombing of Iraq by the United States and Great Britain. The two allies class it as humanitarian intervention, yet other states have condemned it. In this case humanitarian intervention does not necessarily provide a glow of self-importance and self-interest.

  1. Religion and Morality

    There are theories in concurrence with Autonomy which allow still for a good, firm morality without dependency on religion such as Utilitarianism (greatest good for greatest number)

  2. The arguments for and against the view that morality is dependant on religion, and ...

    Or do you weigh up different parts of text to best suit your situation? Natural moral law, a deontological theory of St Thomas Aquinas, he believed that humans should act in a way that glorifies God, as He is the creator.

  1. 1. A) Morality is derived from religion and its teachings

    To begin with, heteronomy seems believable as it is evident that in our western society, we are influenced by strong religious values and Christian influences. This is apparent because even the very language that we use to discuss morality is derived from Natural Law and therefore religion.

  2. Outline the reasons why it may be claimed that morality and religion are linked. ...

    Such promises made to religious people provide an incentive for them to act with justice and morality at the forefront of their minds, and hence is proof that there is a definite link between religion and morality. Some would say, therefore, that religion gives a greater purpose to morality, as

  1. Discuss critically the belief that conscience is the voice of God.

    good and bad, and observes that it can be weak and mistaken (1 Corinthians 8:10-12; perhaps merely indicating a 'moral point of view' by which we struggle to make rational judgements about moral issues. St Paul believed that conscience was within the centre of the soul: 'They can demonstrate the

  2. Examine the key ideas of one critique of the link between religion and morality. ...

    He says he is ?astounded? as to why Christians would support an evil monster, when God could demand men to do something considered immoral. For example, Abraham being asked to kill his own son, Abel. Dawkins talked to Michael Bray, a friend of Paul Hill, the American pastor idolised by

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work