• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month


Extracts from this document...


PHILOSOPHY ESSAY TASK: 'HOW EFFECTIVE IS THE AUGUSTINIAN THEODICY IN EXPLAINING THE EXISTENCE OF EVIL & SUFFERING IN OUR WORLD?' Throughout history, the problems of evil and suffering have always been prevalent in the world. The problems can be split up into two types: moral evil and natural suffering. Moral evil is generally viewed as anything that is caused by humans and inflicts pain (physical or psychological) or death or obstructs life's freedom and/or expression; for example, murder, war, crime. Natural suffering is generally viewed as events that occur because of the physical world or environment; for example, earthquakes, volcanoes, flooding. Evil and suffering therefore present believers in the 'God of Classical Theism' with a logical problem- one of them being the 'Inconsistent Triad'. The 'Inconsistent Triad' consists of three premises: 1- God is omnipotent; 2- God is omnibenevolent; 3- there is evil in the world. All three premises cannot be true at the same time which means either God does not exist or there is no evil in the world. ...read more.


Augustine's theodicy essentially says that God is right not to interfere with problems of evil and suffering in the world, as it is perfectly justified that we should suffer and at the end of our lives- if we have accepted that God's forgiveness is necessary- we will go to Heaven, otherwise all non-believers will be punished in Hell for eternity. For some Christians- mainly fundamental Christians- Augustine's theodicy succeeds in justifying evil and suffering in the world. However, for non-Christians and even liberal Christians, the theodicy fails for a number of different reasons. The theodicy fails in some ways because of the advance in science. Augustine's theodicy is based on the Bible being interpreted as literal which opens him up to two scientific criticisms. In contrast to evolution theory, which is now widely accepted as an explanation for the existence of complex organisms through the gradual process of natural selection and random mutations over generations, if the Bible is taken as literal truth, then the theodicy is the reverse of evolution as it prescribes humans were created first. ...read more.


Not only that, the selection process for Heaven is discriminate as Heaven can be viewed as an exclusive club for people who have turned to Christ and accepted the need for God's forgiveness. Therefore, God is wasteful of good souls as they would be punished eternally for having no Christian belief- even if they had been morally good people their whole lives. This clearly questions God's omnibenevolence and fairness. At first evaluation, St Augustine's theodicy appears to make some good points about the reasons for evil and suffering in the world, particularly his comparison of evil to darkness and them being an absence of good and light respectively. However on closer inspection, there are some clear flaws with the theodicy which challenge the 'God of Classical Theism' as they criticise 'His' creation and more importantly- God's omnibenevolence. The theodicy works well for fundamental Christians, but is not effective in convincing other Christians and non-Christians into the reasons for the existence of evil and suffering in the world as it presents us with an arbitrary and flawed God. ?? ?? ?? ?? Pamela Bolla 13SM ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Philosophy section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Philosophy essays

  1. Augustine's theodicy

    'Reasoned arguments cannot account for all the evil in the world.' Discuss. Reasoned arguments are never going to account for any evil in any world of any type. Reasoning will only help us to understand what it is that accounted for this evil, but will never account for the evil itself.

  2. In what ways may suffering create philosophical problems for religious believers? Outline two solutions ...

    In his theodicy, Irenaeus argues that the creation of humans in the likeness and image of God. First, humans are made in the image of God; this stage of creation is Irenaeus claims, incomplete, so in order to achieve perfection, according to Jordan, it must be developed via free choice as well as co-operation with other humans as well.

  1. Explain the problem of evil (25 marks). Are the theodicies attempts to ...

    Augustine also argued that evil is part of the natural balance of the universe and although it may seem pain and suffering outweigh the good and appear to go unpunished in this life, justice is restored in the next life as those who have done wrong on earth are sentenced to life in Hell.

  2. How to create a completely peaceful world. To create a fully peaceful world, ...

    For example, no nation wanted to wage war from North America to the Middle East thousands of years ago. In fact, lots of nations were sort of isolated from the other nations. Thus, in the ancient time, there had no war of every nation against every nation.

  1. Explain how Augustine accounts for the existence of evil.

    We can also support Augustine's assumptions that free will is so valuable that it justifies the risk of evil. Because of its compatibility with, and reliance upon, the genesis account of creation, Augustine's theodicy appeals to Christians who accept the authority of the bible as the word of god.

  2. Explain and evaluate Augustine's Theodicy

    However, the fact that Adam and Eve, as God's creatures chose to disobey show that there was already at least a slight knowledge of evil in the world. Also, the existence of Hell poses a problem for Augustine's theodicy. Augustine portrays Hell as part of God's design of the universe,

  1. discuss the claim that any belief in life after death is a theodicy in ...

    surely they would not be happy to live forever with a disability they have had to suffer with on earth. Heaven is supposed to be a reward for dealing with all our suffering in life so if we have to continue suffering because our bodies stay the same, that is not giving us a reward.

  2. Irenaen Theodicy cannot justify the existence of evil. Discuss

    by setting fire to an anthill however the punishment was to help teach the child just as evil is used to teach humans morals.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work