• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Is there a tension between ethics and aesthetics in design? BA Design Yr2

Extracts from this document...


Is there a tension between ethics and aesthetics in design? BA Design Yr2 Goldsmiths College Adam Coward Ethics are a fundamental element of any functioning society, essentially providing the codes of conduct that must be followed by a majority to ensure social survival. These, often unspoken rules, give us a sense of right and wrong but are not common to all cultures and are often subject to temporal change. This is evident if we examine the historical change in attitudes towards a subject such as suicide. For example, the ancient Greeks and Romans considered suicide as an honourable and heroic act, whereas in early Christianity it was pronounced a 'mortal sin'. In fact, in England suicide was considered a criminal act until as recent as 1961, perhaps due to the social importance of maintaining the family unit up to this point in time. This would suggest that ethics are not pre determined by our nature but rather are rationally constituted by a specific culture for its continued existence, depending on the conditions by which that society is to survive. Ethics can also be defined as moral ideals belonging to a culture and also those belonging to the individual. There is often much overlay concerning the two instances but it is important to recognise that every individual will inevitably put his or her unique spin on the dominantly recognised set of ethical values. So how does this relate to design? Firstly it would seem that there is a personal ethical responsibility on those involved in the production of objects, such as designers, material engineers, manufactures, business people, etc. Such elements for ethical consideration in this instance may include sustainability, socio-psychological well being, and a concern for the dehumanisation and cultural reduction that might result from mass production and globalisation. ...read more.


This best translates to the design of many existing refrigerators if we consider the use of colour white. White is most popular as it tends to signify ideals of purity and cleanliness, which might be explained logically by its ability to show up any substance that is considered unclean. As such the use of white constantly assures us of the absence of dirt. Examples of the use of white in other design objects include kitchen and bathroom appliances such as dishwashers, kettles, baths and bath towels. After all, it would be extremely uncomforting to use a bath after someone else if the bath was black and might be disguising remaining dirt from the previous person. Another manifestation of ethics concerning dirt is apparent in Raymond Loewy's 1935 refrigerator. As well as the use of white, the design also employs a streamlined, wipeable form and surface finish that conveys the 'physical embodiment of health and purity' (Forty, 156). As such it clearly has aesthetical advantage over previous designs that present an object similar to a standard varnished cabinet. 'Coldspot' refrigerator by Raymond Loewy 'Coldspot' refrigerator by Raymond Loewy designed for Sears The idea of using white to obsessively eliminate all that we consider to be impure and dirty is also in the chapter on 'dust' by Alastair Bonnett in 'City A-Z' by Steve Pile and Nigel Thrift. Bonnett explains the importance of white in 'Modernity's war against dust' (Pile and Thrift, 62) and explains how dust is threatening to the 'clean' simplicity and rational of Modernism. Nowhere else is this more evident than in the re-design of Hospitals from the end of the 19th century, as 'dust-free environments... with their endless 'spotless corridors, their regular white rooms and expanses of window' (Pile and Thrift, 62). ...read more.


One observation that is made involves the attitudes towards mobile phone etiquette by business people. As such Fox identifies two types of executive, those of low-ranking who tend to make a big ostentatious show of using their phones whatever the situation and those of 'higher-ranking people who have nothing to prove and so tend to be more considerate'. If we take the first of these two sections of society, who believe it acceptable to make a show of their use of a mobile phone, often using it to display their own self importance, then it is possible to design an aesthetic that compliments this ethic. An example of this is the development of mobile phone ring tones, which now allow the user to apply ever more elaborate tunes. In conclusion I hope to have demonstrated the importance of an ethical consideration in design. Firstly there is an ethical responsibility on those involved in the production of objects, such as government, captains of industry and designers. But more importantly I have shown that there is a definite link between the ethical values we hold and what is considered beautiful in the world. It therefore becomes essential to understand the ethics of different cultures and sub cultures in order to achieve aesthetical designs. This may then enable to foresee shifts in morals and in some cases perhaps challenge them. I have discussed some examples of sign associations with ethics and how they can be exploited by companies and products to convey false ethics, thus creating cynicism. Finally I think it is valuable to consider that transgressive sub cultures have their own set of ethics that are often in opposition to those of the dominant culture. In this instance the transgressive set of values are likely to manifest in an oppositional aesthetical style. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Practical Questions section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Practical Questions essays

  1. In this essay I will be looking at Ethics and the importance of using ...

    client of the same sex, would you then need to question your own sexuality? How would you feel if the client was of the opposite sex, if they were married or single? If you continued with the counselling are you showing true integrity and could we build up a good trusting relationship.

  2. The key difference between someone using counselling skills and a qualified and trained counsellor ...

    feelings in order to come to an appropriate and fair decision this is where Supervision is key.

  1. Business Ethics

    This is a prime example of agency theory; McDonald's is most of America's agent for lunch, dinner or the afternoon snack. (Mega essay in business ethics, 2001-2009, http://www.megaessays.com/viewpaper/62923.html.) As we enter into the marketing aspect of the business, it can be seen that business marketing had been developed rapidly in

  2. Religious Ethics are not the best approach to environmental ethics'. Discuss.

    the measure of extent or duration of happiness but instead on the satisfaction of desires or preferences. Singer measures the importance of an individual or being, not on their possession of a soul or reason, but on their ability to suffer.

  1. The Ethical Debate Concerning Cloning.

    Judaism and Christianity both oppose this technology, but for different reasons; likewise, the different denominations of Christians each have their own view of the subject. Both Christians and Jews believe that humans are created in the image of God. To some religious scholars, clones are also included as children of God.

  2. The 21st century has raised more problems for equality than it has solved. Examine ...

    Some argue that the Roman Catholic view of homosexuality fuels intolerance, due to their strong disagreement and unwillingness of acceptance. This has managed to create a divide between the church and the rest of the people, through their opposing views, but also it has divided the church itself, due to the unacceptance of homosexuality.

  1. Medical Ethics And Organ Transplants

    big impact on society for the good but is old A case study to show the importance of Quality of life in regards to organ donation is that of Elaine Stacy. Elaine died in 2010 after a car accident originally she was placed on life support but her family took her off.

  2. With reference to the topic of abortion , examine and comment on the controversies, ...

    but was not large enough for its movement to be registered by the mother. Others believe the foetus is a person when brain activity is recorded, however the brain activity at this stage is only a precondition and does not show that the foetus is conscious.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work