• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Participant observation studies have little value in sociological research because they are too subjective. Explain and assess this claim

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

?Participant observation studies have little value in sociological research because they are too subjective.? Explain and assess this claim. 18/25 72% C The view above is supported by the positivist. They argued that sociologist should not be concerned with the internal meanings, motives, feelings and emotions of individuals which are the aspects looked from a participant observations method. Since these mental states exist only in the person?s consciousness, they cannot be observed and they cannot be measured in any objective ways. This shows that positivist supports the view above and provides a more suitable method for sociological research, quantitative method. According to Auguste Comte, scientific study of the society should be done by collecting information about phenomena that can be objectively observed and classified. By data, patterns can be found thus lead to explanation for sociological understanding. That is why they prefer the quantitative research method such as the questionnaires since it can covers wide group of society in short space of time and prevents researcher?s bias. Hence, their method has high objectivity and high representativeness rather than compared to qualitative method. ...read more.

Middle

The sociologist must interpret the meaning given to actions by the actors themselves. According to them, people react, reflect on their own behavior, and have awareness and consciousness of their lives, and therefore explanation for the pattern of their lives can never be found using the cold objective approach of the scientist. Hence to obtain their data, the Interactionist prefers methods like participant observation since it can uncover the true motives of each action taken by human. This method has great validity. This is evident in Erving Goffman study of mental hospitals, published as Stigma in 1968. Goffman worked in an asylum for the mentally ill as Assistant Athletic Director. His research was mainly covert, with only a couple of staff being privy to the knowledge of his research, and via this method he was able to uncover the 'unofficial reality' of life in a mental institution. Thus, this evidence contradicted the view above which proves that participant observation method is useful for sociological research. However, Interactionist methods are greatly criticized by the positivist. ...read more.

Conclusion

it may provide a better understanding of a phenomenon than if one method had been used and thus offers great potential in many instances. In a study of the Unification Church, or Moonies, Eileen Barker used participant observation, questionnaires and in depth interviewing. She claimed this combination methods allowed her to ?see how the movement as a whole was organized and how it influenced the day-to-day actions and interactions of its member?. She tried to test hypotheses formulated from qualitative data using questionnaires. Hence here we can see that through triangulation, a better understanding of the whole situation. This is supported by a study done by Delmont. She used the Flanders Interaction Analysis Categories in her studies of classroom interaction. These allowed her to categorize the different types of interaction and to time them in order to determine differences in the educational experience of the boys and girls. She used qualitative data to explain the reasons for the quantitative relationships she found. Thus it is combining the two methods can really give a more useful information in our study with better objectivity, representativeness, reliability and validity. Give more value to the study. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Sociological Differentiation & Stratification section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Sociological Differentiation & Stratification essays

  1. Marked by a teacher

    Examine the weakness of different types of documents used in a sociological research. Examine ...

    4 star(s)

    Positivist makes the fundamental assumption that society has an objective reality- like the physical world; the social word does exist out there. However, interpretivist opposed this view that society is an objective reality but rather society is subjective realities. They believed that social actors construct their own reality through meanings they create in their interaction with others.

  2. Assess the strengths and weaknesses of participant observation, as a research method

    Overt observation allows the researcher to avoid the ethical problem of being deceitful, whereas, covert forces the researcher to hide their identity. Overt, also allows the researcher to take notes openly. This is a disadvantage for using covert research, as if the study goes on for a long period of

  1. Assess the view that cults, sects and new age movement are fringe organisations that ...

    Also it could go under the inclusive definition of religion where in sects you deal with ultimate problems in life and try to make life better which NRMs do. It can be very hard to define religion. Yes it has been argued that NRMs could be increasing in contemporary society

  2. Examine The Problems That Some Sociologists May Find When Using Participant Observations In Research

    This cannot be done with participant observations, as it cannot be replicated under the same conditions, there are no fixed procedures, things happen and then observer just follows, therefore these random events won't occur again. An example is given from Robert Redfield's study (1930), in the village of Tepoztlan in Mexico.

  1. Choice of research method. here are various types of research methods available, such ...

    Moreover, structuralist prefers quantitative research method such as questionnaires as it is able to utilize larger samples, so generalizations are more justified. Statistical data produced from questionnaires ease the replication of research and checking of results, as well as provides a much more reliable and objective data, as compared to qualitative method.

  2. Participant Observation

    Participant observations however also have disadvantages to its 'usefulness.' The problem is representativeness. It is not possible to generalise as the research carried out as it only gives information about a small group of people, any conclusions can only apply to the specific group studied.

  1. Assess the claim that the main function of education is to maintain a value ...

    by assessing them in terms of their talents and abilities and matching them to appropriate occupations. Criticisms of Parsons include his failure to give consideration to the possibility that the values transmitted may be those of the ruling class and not of society as a whole and also that his

  2. Assess the usefulness of interactionist approaches to the study of society

    Symbolic interactionism provides the theoretical basis of labelling theory. During social interaction, a person defines situations as real. For example, if someone is suspected of having an affair, many of their actions are defined in those terms. So, quickly putting the telephone down is seen as suspicious rather than simply a wrong number.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work