• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

To what extent can it be claimed that "positive discrimination" towards disadvantaged ethnic groups is an advisable government policy?

Extracts from this document...


To what extent can it be claimed that "positive discrimination" towards disadvantaged ethnic groups is an advisable government policy? (25 marks) Positive discrimination or "affirmative action" is defined as policies and programs meant as a corrective measure to redress discrimination against certain groups in society in the name of fairness and equal opportunities. Ethnic Groups, as defined by Yinger, refer to: "A segment of a larger society that is different in some combination of language, religion, race and ancestral homeland with its related culture" In order to decide to what extent Positive Discrimination in favor of disadvantaged ethnic groups is an advisable government policy, one needs to refer to the various sociological perspectives and their views of society. Functionalists such as David and Moore would argue against Positive Discrimination, on the basis that society rewards those who work hard and are capable- through the meritocratic system. "New Right" "sociologists" arguing against Positive Discrimination would believe that ethnic minorities are disadvantaged because of their own doing, through laziness and a refusal to integrate. Marxist sociologists would argue in favor of Positive Discrimination on the basis that Racism is a social construction used to subjugate other classes. Left-wingers and social democrats would argue that Positive Discrimination is needed to cancel out the effects of racism and ethnic prejudice on the life chances of ethnic minorities. ...read more.


Murray and Herrstein, who advocated the elimination of welfare programs in "The Bell Curve" based on the argument that it allowed women with lower IQ's to produce children with equally low IQ's, would probably use the same argument to advocate the abolition of Positive Discrimination, as it would allow ethnic minorities with lower IQ's to produce offspring of the same stripe. "New Right Sociologists" would argue that this would be a disadvantage to the government as it would lead to an eventual reduction in the nation's talent pool. However, it is important to note that the methodology used in the production of "The Bell Curve" is both dubious and highly doubtful. This is most vividly illustrated by the article Inequality by Design, written by the Sociology Department of UC Berkeley, which claims that the statistics used by Murray and Herrstein were flawed due to omissions and technical errors. On the other hand, "New Right Sociologists" also argue that ethic groups are disadvantaged because they refuse to integrate into their host society. A refusal to integrate may include a refusal to take on the norms and values of the host culture; or to learn the language. This prevents them from seeking opportunities and hence leaving them at a disadvantage. "New Right Sociologists" would henceforth argue that the state would have no responsibility whatsoever for self-made choices, and therefore that Positive Discrimination would be pointless and a waste of both time and resources. ...read more.


This clearly shows that Positive Discrimination in favor of disadvantaged groups is desirable as it allows for the disadvantages caused by ethnic discrimination and its knock-on effects to be limited if not redressed, hence increasing the nation's pool of talent and preventing those who are capable from languishing behind due to disadvantageous conditions. Henceforth it can be said that Positive Discrimination in favor of disadvantaged ethnic minorities is both beneficial and disadvantageous depending on which perspective it is viewed from. However, it could be concluded with a degree of certainty that Positive Discrimination in favor of ethnic minorities is both a good government policy and advantageous to the country in question- as it allows ethnic minorities put at a disadvantage to compete on what amounts to nearer grounds to those from other ethnic groups that may enjoy an advantage, whether it be through wealth, power or better overall life chances. This allows for the meritocratic principles of Functionalism to occur on fair and even grounds- facilitating competition for roles and jobs between everyone on fair and even terms, hence allowing the best and brightest, regardless of ethnicity, to reach the very top and bring mutual benefits for society as a whole. ?? ?? ?? ?? Edwin Loo 12K 23/01/2007 Sociology Essay Page 1 of 2 ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Sociological Differentiation & Stratification section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Sociological Differentiation & Stratification essays

  1. The education system is meritocratic

    The New Right are a political view like the social democrats but they criticises the system in a different way. The New Right claim that schools and the whole educational system are too soft and easy as children are not encouraged to be independent and this is mostly due to

  2. Poverty and Health

    However, some would say that this point of view fails to ask why it is that these groups have such poor diets and high alcohol and cigarette consumption in the first place. Other's point out that there could be reasons why people are 'forced' into an unhealthy lifestyle such as,

  1. Gender Roles

    will go to clubs that will demonstrate their masculinity such as football whereas girls will join clubs that are more delicate and 'girly' such as dancing.

  2. Examine the extent to which husbands and wives now have a relationship based on ...

    This shows that there are many areas that sociologists neglect, such as the emotions of the individuals within the marriage and that this may mean that women do a lot more work than the statistics of things such as household tasks may show.

  1. Is the Underachievement of Ethnic Minority Children due to a Racist School System?

    Yet he found that it was the teachers views of black culture that held the children back, "a widely held belief among teachers that black parents are particularly likely to fail to provide adequate support...(has) proved to be a myth".

  2. Free essay

    Inequalities in Health

    Gender Inequalities Through research we have found than women on the whole are healthier than men and that women's mortality rates are lower than that of men. According to Hilary Graham (2002), men have fewer consultations with GP's and have lower levels of illness.

  1. Comparison of the discrimination faced by two contrasting groups

    In total they number 300 million people - more than the population then the United States. For more than 300 years, the Dalits have been oppressed by the Hindu religion, which created them to serve the caste system. The Dalits are excluded from the caste system, so literally they are outcasts.

  2. Introduction to social policy-To what extent is social policy fair?

    Having gained a little bit of a better understanding into social policy, I then went on to gather some further research on social policy with reference to race/ethnicity related issues, Many argue that ethnic minorities are not considered in social policy and are left in poverty, as policies are increasingly

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work