• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Are there any fundamental differences between photographic and painted portraiture

Extracts from this document...


Are there any fundamental differences between photographic and painted portraiture? In this essay I hope to define some of the fundamental differences between the above two methods. I will discuss the advantages and disadvantages of each as vehicles of portraiture. However, this is a very wide question and though it has great scope for deeper analysis, lack of words and space has prevented me from exploring each point in more detail here. When addressing this subject, I feel it is very important to recognise that artists have very different objectives when creating a portrait. For some, a portrait may simply be a study of physical likeness whereas for others it may be a study of the sitter's character, their inner personality. This distinction makes it a challenging task to compare photographic and painterly ideas of what a portrait consists of. I must also draw attention to the fact that photography has been caught up in an everlasting struggle to be recognised as a fine art in its own right. When first discovered, photography threw painted portraits to the sidelines of the art scene because of its obvious technological and economical advantages. Many people at the time thought nothing could exceed these imitations as portrayals of people. However, it was not long before photography was slated badly by many. Artists regarded photographs as mere regurgitations and made clear that '...imagination, rather than imitation is required of art.'1 On the contrary it has been said that photography was a new means of pursuing the ends of painting.2 This is the view that photography was ...read more.


Due to lack of any conclusive findings in the above paragraphs, the question of what function a portrait must fulfil becomes apparent. West defines: 'A portrait [...] serves magically to freeze time and to extend artificially the life of the represented individual.'7 With this comment brought to attention it appears that photographic portraits are the most technically accurate. The photograph records the sitters face exactly as it was at that precise moment in time, however the painting can often miss tiny details of the face which reveal its age and disposition. The photographic portrait, pre airbrushing and altering, does not omit any blemishes or imperfections. Painted portraits, however, can do this quite easily and the painter had never before had to face this problem of creating an exact likeness. There was nothing preceding photography that was any more visually correct than painting or drawing. For this reason many artists were '...found [...] in a bewildered and aggressive mood,'8 after the invention of photography. Referring back to West's quote above, the use of the word 'artificial' has negative connotations and this view really only covers a certain type of portraiture. Consider a portrait which does not really resemble the sitter but which is more a symbolic representation, for example Francis Bacon's painting of 'Isobel Rawsthorne in a street in Soho.' (1967) Clearly Bacon is not painting what he sees of the woman's physical features but extracting things from her inner-self which are not visible to the eye: perhaps her angst, sorrow, grief and emotional exhaustion. ...read more.


From what has been noted above, it has become evident that no sound comparison can be made between the two techniques. It is probable that many people are of the view that photography is a completely independent art form and exists on an entirely different plain to that of painting. To these people it is highly inappropriate to compare photographs with paintings in the first place. Furthermore, the arguments for and against the two methods seem empty and inconclusive considering that the function of the portrait is extremely variable. They are not always made to be displayed as works of art and often serve a broader function.14 They can act as emblems or reminders of people rather than images of exactly what that person's facial features were like -For example, on our currency. They can act as representations of a certain mood and a certain type of person, or indeed as a mere regurgitation of the sitter. They can also act simply as a way through which the artist can express him/herself. In any case, the different objectives artists strive for make it almost impossible to compare the two techniques. They are not on level ground. To summarise my findings over the course of writing this essay I would have to conclude that there are no fundamental differences between the two art forms but many differing advantages and disadvantages of one over the other and vice versa. Essentially, however, photographs are the most true depictions of ourselves whereas paintings are an imitation or copy of a real thing. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Art section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Art essays

  1. Francis Bacon analysis

    I also like the way it holds a tension, like you know the Pope is screaming but you can't hear it, which makes it feel like the painting is going to explode. The only thing I don't like about it is that it's really hard to draw, because his face his covered up by lines.

  2. Jekyll and Hyde double personality

    This shows Jekyll is an entertainer and likes the company of others. However, later in the book, he becomes reclusive and the reader begins to guess that something is not right with Jekyll. Jekyll is a scientist and focuses on the concept of duality.

  1. Waltons View on Photography.

    I agree that this seems to give photography a closer link to reality than painting. Walton makes the bold claim that when we look and photographs, we actually see what the picture is of, we don't only see a picture.

  2. The boundaries between culture and nature have collapsed and the body has become flexible

    The mirrors of the changing room reflected back the performative aspects of the work and reinforced the act of looking, both of the viewer as voyeur inside the changing room and the artists as both fashion model and photographer.

  1. Develpment in the History of Photography

    Sadly, Niepce died four years into the partnership. Daguerre received loyalties, from the invention of his former partner, when it was offered to the world. The Daguerreotype Daguerre presented a refined version of Niepce's, "heliography" at the academy of sciences in 1839.

  2. Steinberg and the Attention to Detail

    Leaning on his right elbow onto the dinner table, Judas subsequently separates himself from the remainder of the disciples demonstrating that it was he who would eventually betray Jesus. Shadows fall over his face and body, significant to both hide his face from the others as well as demonstrate the shame involved with his anticipated crime.

  1. History Never Repeats

    However each individual canvas is similar in the use of earthy colours and simplistic primitive style painting. The painting is difficult to interpret as its meaning appears different to some people. Papeck's reason for painting this style of picture is to "invite the viewer to contemplate universal beliefs within the

  2. Art gcse Final Evaluation (similarities and differences)

    However as I looked through my old works, I was inspired and ideas sparked. I began to synthesized ideas using my old pieces, taking some previous aspects and modifying them, changing them, refining them. During the timed piece, I believe I have created a piece to not only summarize the

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work