• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Do the advantages of economic and monetary union outweigh the disadvantages?

Extracts from this document...


EU10110 - European Integration Coursework essay: "Do the Advantages of Economic and Monetary Union Outweigh the Disadvantages?" (1634 Words) Pages: 9 Benjamin M. Unsworth (010800186) Do the Advantages of Economic and Monetary Union Outweigh the Disadvantages? "Euroland in grip of monetary paralysis"1 The European Economic and Monetary Union (EMU) is the most ambitious economic project undertaken in modern history. However, nearly every EU country has seen some kind of protest against monetary union, and three countries - Denmark, Sweden and the United Kingdom - have refused to participate (a fourth, Greece, did not qualify for economic reasons). Even Euro enthusiasts admit that there are a number of things that can go wrong. For the purpose of this essay, EMU is defined as a single market plus a single currency area, including a common external tariff vis-�-vis third countries, free movement of goods, services, capital and workers, a single currency and harmonisation of state's economic policies. First the context of the EMU's development will be presented, followed by the presentation of arguments in favour of EMU and against EMU. This essay is presented with a critical view towards EMU. Moves to EMU took place in the context of the collapse of the Bretton Woods international monetary system. The first serious attempt to tie together the value of national currencies came in the early 1970s, but collapsed in the face of turbulence in the global monetary system. ...read more.


The traditional short-term way for a nation to control this and create stability is to lower or raise interest rates. However, interest rates are specific to a currency and membership of EMU incurs a single rate of interest. EMU membership would therefore be too inflexible. This can be seen in Britain's economic crisis of 1991. Following withdrawal from the Exchange Rate Mechanism, Britain required 15% interest rates in order to control the economy and prevent total collapse. This interest rate may have been applicable to Britain, but it would be suitable to apply it to the other members of the EMU. If one EMU country suffered a boom or bust, the ECB would be caught in the dilemma of whether to let an economy collapse or hyper-inflate, or to introduce unsuitable interest rates to the other countries that would be unpayable or would in turn stimulate hyperinflation by overspending. A single rate of interest is therefore too inflexible for such a widely varied set of economies. The eleven-country Euroland makes such problems even more pronounced. The ECB initially set interest rates at 3%, and has since lowered them to 2.5%. Some politicians have complained that this is still too high. They should spare a thought for Europe's smaller economies. In Ireland, Spain and Portugal business is booming, and interest rates were high to prevent the economy from overheating. But already before the launch of EMU interest rates had to come down to the eurozone level and this has triggered higher rates of inflation4. ...read more.


However, each of the manufacturers are economic competitors and instead of being beneficial to the whole of the manufacturing sector, economic and monetary union would benefit the larger successful companies at the expense of farmers, smaller exporting companies and non-exporting companies who only target the domestic market. This is an inevitable feature of the capitalist system, which is only exaggerated by engaging more and more in globally cohesive trading (think globalisation - the rich few benefit more and more at the expense of the poor many - the third world is getting poorer and poorer. This would just be replicated within the EMU). EMU would only benefit the elite of the 10 per cent who export their goods. Conclusion The current main arguments supporting economic and monetary union centre around the benefits for the manufacturing sector, which would be shared out evenly and, coupled with the monetary stability that is generated, would enable stable economic growth for everyone. In this essay I have argued that this is in fact inaccurate because it overexaggerates the benefits, which would only be felt by the bigger businesses that are in a position to export their goods and reap the rewards of cheaper exportation costs. A single rate of inflation is too inflexible for the very divergent economies and the structure of the ECB is far too problematic. This 'one-size-fits-all' approach to economics is too idealist and does not take into account that each of the member states would solely be pursuing their own interests. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Economy & Economics section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Economy & Economics essays

  1. The Nature of Macroeconomics

    real purchasing power increases, higher level of national output (Y2) * If prices rise aggregate spending power declines, aggregate demand contracts * Demand contracts, stocks rise thus firms cut back on production and employment * Price level rises, national income, output and employment fall Pg 73 * Contraction or expansion

  2. Retailing In India - A Government Policy Perspective

    Adequacy in FDI policy implies that the overall policy mix should be adequate to achieve the overall policy objective. The Indian policy mix is quite inadequate. Stability in Indian plicies also has been a major area of concern. Critical policies change dramatically with every government change, and even at a per-budget level.

  1. Review of Strong Interest Inventory.

    Resulting GRS consists of 18,591 (9,467 female, 9,484 male) employed adults were selected on the basis of a set of criteria including job satisfaction, job experience, success, typicality of job description, and age with at least 3 years of job incumbency.

  2. Recession, Tax Cuts and Budget Deficits.

    The position of the president was correct for the fiscal situation at hand; the government should not be running a surplus during a recession because failing to inject as much money into the economy as it takes out will make a weak economy worse.

  1. This report will establish the opportunities and threats presented to Sony by the EU ...

    far off from the rest of EU members but has the fastest growing market. Italy: has a population of 59,225.7 million and their gross domestic product per head is $20,015, whereas the spending power per capita in PPP is $20,139.

  2. Free essay

    From an economic perspective should my council do more to recycle a greater proportion ...

    Furthermore, it will show whether the household members are recycling as much as they think they are and it could give suggestions, which could help me provide recommendations for the council to encourage recycling. To be able to compare between local, national, and my household's figures I will need to carry out secondary research.

  1. Analysis of some fundamental arguments claimed by Albert Hirschman and Gunnar Myrdal

    He disagreed with Hirschman however on the fundamental point of whether the trickle down outweighed the polarisation effects. Hirschman described Myrdal's ideas as being overly-dismal but Myrdal based his conclusions on the principle of circular and cumulative causation, a type of vicious circle which saw the more advanced regions become more advanced while the peripheral regions fell further behind.

  2. US Financial Crisis vs. Economic Crisis

    Estimates of losses in these other types of loans of up to one trillion dollars. Therefore, the total losses for the financial sector as a whole could reach $ 2 trillion. It is further estimated that the banks will suffer nearly half of the total losses in the financial sector.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work