• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Exploring Consent and Surviving Work The work of Michael Burawoy (1979) makes a valid contribution to our understanding of the nature of work. Theorists such as Crozier (1964) and Mayo (1933) argue that employee's social 'game play'

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Exploring Consent and Surviving Work The work of Michael Burawoy (1979) makes a valid contribution to our understanding of the nature of work. Theorists such as Crozier (1964) and Mayo (1933) argue that employee's social 'game play' undermine management's position and delegation of work. However, Burawoy offers the notion that rather than these games posing a threat to management, they are in fact favourable (within limits) in creating 'manufacturing consent'. Such 'games' can be identified as being discovered through the work of Mayo (1933) and the Hawthorne studies. He discovered informal work groups form unofficial norms & sanctions of cliques to regulate group behaviour. Mayo stated that supervisors have to be aware of both individuals' social needs & power of the informal group, in order to align these to achieve formal or official objectives. More socially aware than scientific quality gurus such as Ishikawa (1985), Mayo's understanding of such informal 'game playing' is similar to Burawoy's research; Burawoy's positive conclusions about such behaviour are intentionally different. ...read more.

Middle

Management must have some involvement in the 'game playing' because although it can be beneficial, if one side disrupts the other's work, the system can break down. An example of this could be management delegating extra work without the consensus of the employees. Another major criticism of Burawoy is that his research ignores gender's impact on work/work groups, whereas in separate research (e.g., Crompton et al (2000)), gender is seen as having a massive impact on all work issues. Noon and Blyton (2002) argue that by viewing workplace survival strategies, we can unearth many complex patterns of action and meaning. Workplace survival refers to employee survival of the alienating tendencies at work via the employment of survival strategies. Marx (1930) states that there are four types of estrangement experienced by employees. They are: 1. Self-estrangement 2. Estrangement from the product of their labour 3. Estrangement from their species being 4. ...read more.

Conclusion

Durand and Stewart (1998) make clear research conclusions from the article 'Manufacturing Dissent'. It is concluded that 'game playing' can adopt two forms, being 'making out' and the 'transparency' effects. The former is the conclusion of consent and self-subordination via competition for the piece rate. The latter is different in that although adopted to establish the same benefits, it entails competing for management approval in teams. The transparency concept does form the basis of the manufacture of consent, but as Durand and Stewart (1998) state, "...it also constitutes the rules for the manufacture of dissent where employees attempt to 'recover' aspects of the transparency process so as to make the most of an exploitive environment." Another point to be taken is that transparency is not confined between formal management and sub-ordinate workers; it has been manipulated for use between shop floor workers themselves. This research unearths vital information about why workers work as hard as they do via the initialization of informal groups and extends Elton Mayo's research in the deliverance of the idea of 'game playing'. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE People in Business section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE People in Business essays

  1. Hagar Cohen's work, Glass, Paper, Beans.

    This need to know how things will turn out rules us in every way so that we must create predictable settings. In the workplace this works by creating predictable settings for employees an example of this would be the creation of the assembly line.

  2. Business at Work - ASDA

    Share prices are also very important, as any organisation would wish for more stakeholders to buy shares into the company. A decrease in share prices shows that there is something wrong within the organisation, therefore this in itself is a measure for the company's success.

  1. What is the purpose of management theory? Explain how knowledge to understanding of management ...

    This wide influence is due in part to the high level of practicality of Maslow's theory. This theory accurately describes many realities of personal experiences. Many people find they can understand what Maslow says. They can recognize some features of their experience or behavior which is true and identifiable but which they have never put into words.

  2. Rights and Responsibilities of Employer and Employee

    reverse supply chain into a powerful source of profit and customer satisfaction. In the NHS there are departments that serve as internal customers; their job is to check the service that will be provided for external customer. The internal customers help the NHS to provide high quality service to patients.

  1. The work of Elton Mayo in the "Hawthorne Studies"

    The experiment was this time divided into 2 different groups. The control group got stable illumination and the other group got a sequence of increasing light levels. There was a substantial rise in production in both group but there was no different between the groups.

  2. Communications in Health & Social Care.

    She feels as though she doesn't belong in the new group as she isn't as able as the other children. Communication skills will be needed to ensure her emotional safety and so that she doesn't feel rejected from the group.

  1. Business At Work

    The communication channels that run within B & Q are: o Internal and External; allows the businesses employees to communicate both with each other and with existing and potential customers. o Formal and Informal; allows employees to communicate both in and out of official business meetings which helps the smooth running of the business.

  2. Describe and evaluate the work of any one researcher who you consider to have ...

    In 1887 Taylor was promoted to the position of shop superintendent there.5 It was here that Taylor noticed a difference in employee work methods. He closely watched how work was done and would measure the quantity produced. He discovered that most methods were inefficient and led to low productivity.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work