• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

How Planned was the Soviet Economy Between 1924 and 1939?

Extracts from this document...


How Planned was the Soviet Economy Between 1924 and 1939? As Marxists claim that capitalism is 'anarchic, planless, inefficient and wastes human and natural resources', what with the modern advances made by Russia in such a short space of time, one would assume that the Soviet economy between 1924 and 1939 was meticulously planned and controlled. However, many facts would beg to differ and instead suggest the contrary. It is true that institutes of planning existed in Russia in the period concerned. As of July 1922, VSNKh operated its control over industry by "methods of a production-planning character". The institution was responsible for the drafting of production and disposal plans amongst other things. Another institution in existence was Gosplan which was known as the state general-planning commission. Set up in February 1921, Gosplan was to "work out a single general state economic plan and means of implementing it." However, although such institutions were in place, there was no evidence of a thoroughly worked out production and allocation programme; there was no "command economy." Gosplan did not produce plans in the sense of orders from which one could act upon, but produced "control figures" which were in part a prediction and in part a guide for strategic investment decisions. ...read more.


However, far from being planned, it was a panic measure resulting from domestic and foreign problems. In 1926, a General Strike took place abroad, in Britain. As part of the government's action against the strikes, the Russian oar company was raided in London under the pretence that the Russians were using their trading network to encourage a revolution in the city. Diplomatic relations were broken off with Russia following the Arcos raid and as war usually follows such an action, the Russians feared a military strike from Britain. We now know that Britain would not have declared war on Russia and that her actions were more for the sake of propaganda in her own country. However, at the time the Russians did not know this and feared that with her backward army and weak agricultural economy, Russia would fall once under attack. A massive shortfall in grain deliveries to the state formed the basis of the domestic problems experienced by the regime at the time. Although agriculture was in the private sector the state controlled the price of the grain and agricultural produce. In an effort to reduce the cost of industrialization the state deliberately kept the price of grain very low; so low that the peasants preferred to hoard their food (to create a shortage) ...read more.


During rapid industrialization a real threat to the regime was posed by the Kulaks, as one would be told by Russian propaganda of the time. The creation of a modern state involved economically ridding itself of the 'backward' peasantry who formed approximately 80 per cent of the population. The state showed a chilling ability to plan to get rid of the peasantry by pretending to liquidate the kulaks as a class and replacing them with workers. In truth, liquidation of the kulaks and collectivisation was destroying the peasantry as a whole, with the kulaks being used as an excuse. With reference to agriculture, the government failed to predict the horror that would emerge with forced collectivisation. For hundreds of years Russia had been an exporter of grain, however, ever since forced collectivisation she has been an importer of grain. She has never recovered. The Second Five Year Plan was a little more thought out, less ambitious and possibly more fruitful. The targets, being a little more realistic were better met. However, it is also claimed that the Second Plan was probably more successful as it set about clearing up the mess made by the First Plan. "The First Five Year Plan...landed the country in such chaos that it took at least two years to straighten things out." ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Economy & Economics section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Economy & Economics essays

  1. In a Planned Economy, the government decides what is produced, by whom and for ...

    was launched. The Soviet economy grew rapidly during the 1930s, but because of the great destruction inflicted during the years of World War II (1941-45) many of the gains were eliminated. The economy was largely rehabilitated by 1948, and again growth was rapid through the 1950s and '60s.

  2. Chinese economy sets for soft landing in 2005.

    Such a huge growth rate spurred policy-makers into aggressive action against the frenzy of investment, particularly in several "overheated" industries like the steel sector. Now, the monthly growth of fixed investment has been reduced to 18.3 per cent, bringing down the aggregate growth in the first five months to 34.8 per cent.

  1. Free essay

    different sectors of economy

    That's why it is secondary organization. It operates worldwide although Volkswagen Group's core market is Europe. Volkswagen group is made of Volkswagen passenger cars and Volkswagen commercial vehicles but also Audi, SEAT, Lamborghini, Bentley, Bugatti, Skoda, Scania AB and MAN AG.

  2. The structure of the airline industry.

    As the airlines struggle with the additional cost of this regulation and the ability to pass this cost along to passengers or take the hit individually will no doubt affect profitability. After September 11, the insurance industry reinstated war risk liability coverage at extremely increased premiums.

  1. The Quest for Optimal Asset Allocation Strategies in Integrating Europe.

    As financial integration proceeds, higher risk country specific factors should become less important in the pricing of investments and lower risk, EU wide, factors become more important. As a consequence, risk sharing among member countries should increase leading to an overall reduction in the cost of equity capital.

  2. Marketing Plan: Handywares Plc.

    Hungary and Poland are tipped to join the EU by 2002 and this would lower trade barriers, encouraging foreign investment develop the economy and encourage immigration inviting even larger numbers to the urban centres. This makes it an excellent opportunity to gain a market share before the possibility of a large influx of foreign competition.

  1. Industrial revolution in Russia

    West European industrial countries such as Germany and France, were quite aware of Russia's vast potential. The huge population, though largely peasantry and with a traditional agriculture, presented a tempting market to target. Smaller business class in Russia made the foreign presence there even more noticeable and its role in guiding industrialisation even greater.

  2. Global Business Plan.

    When our product leaves our production facility, we would like for the equipment to be made available in local markets. We expect to sell our air conditioners in malls, electronic stores, and the Internet. We realize that the market that we are targeting will probably be regular users of the Internet.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work