• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

It is often suggested that we now enjoy "new industrial relations" in Britain - Discuss the extent to which industrial relations have been transformed in recent years and analyse the role played by management.

Extracts from this document...


It is often suggested that we now enjoy "new industrial relations" in Britain. Discuss the extent to which industrial relations have been transformed in recent years and analyse the role played by management. Method In discussing the extent to which industrial relations have been transformed in recent years, one is immediately forced to consider the term 'industrial relations'. Arguably, there is now a dominant paradigm of a pluralist kind, wherein employers and employees are understood to be roughly comparable entities in terms of power. Thus the process of negotiation is conventionally understood as one in which 'Employees and organisations have reciprocal obligations and mutual commitments' (Strebel 1996:87), and that mutually advantageous outcomes are both possible and desirable. Here though I offer a rather different interpretation of industrial relations, one which is critical of the pluralist paradigm, and which seeks to explain why industrial relations have taken the turn they have in relation to broader developments. In particular, I stress the institutional effects of what has been characterised as the 'end of left and right' (Giddens 1994), the sea change in consciousness over the course of the previous decade and more, chrystallised by the collapse of 'the only rival to the capitalist market economy that the industrial world has ever known' (Marquand 1993:44). The consequences of this dramatic shift in the terms of political reference have proven to be widespread and thoroughgoing. From the Monarchy through Church and State and on to the Trade Unions, no section of society has been immune from a dynamic which has corroded established norms of authority and legitimacy. ...read more.


It is this which goes some way to explaining the apparent continuity of many institutions associated with industrial relations, whilst also explaining the extent to which those institutions have in substance been transformed. If this interpretation is accepted as a (very general) outline of the processes underlying and explaining the extent of the shift to a new style of industrial relations, then it remains to assess the role played by management. The role played by management In the conclusion to an authoritative survey of The New Industrial Relations (Millward 1994:133), it is noted how 'British industry and commerce appear to be moving towards the situation in which non-managerial employees are treated as a "factor of production"'. In one sense, of course, employees have always been a factor of production. In another sense though Millward is identifying a significant development, one which is a symptom of the extent to which industrial relations have been transformed in recent years. Millward is referring to the declining power of employees in the workplace: 'Few will doubt that trade unionism has been in retreat and that in many sectors of employment management has "regained the right to manage"' (117), he writes, before going on to outline some ways in which this has come about. In this he tells a familiar story, about falling union membership, the growth of single-union deals, the effects of legislation, and the changing composition of the labour market. The consequence of such developments is that employees now tend to be more distant from the structures of workplace representation, if such structure exist at all. ...read more.


The new industrial relations can only be understood in the context of the shifting sands of political legitimacy in general, and the collapse of the left-right spectrum in particular. Employers and employees constitute inseparable aspects of a social process: if one side moves, the other has traditionally been forced to respond; except that now there are few universally recognised rules of engagement. Social institutions today tend to exhibit a cautious, piecemeal outlook. Hubris is everywhere deprecated, nowhere more so than in the world of industrial relations, where the demise of the old rules of engagement leaves a substantial space that is only weakly filled by the discourse of HRM. What is notable here is the symmetry of symptoms, the fact that both management and employees tend to lack purpose or confidence. Adversarialism is dismissed as a symptom of an outdated ideology. For others though, the asymmetry of interests between employers and employees is not an idea but a concrete reality, brought home daily in the experience of wage labour. Perhaps it is for this reason that British Social Attitudes finds that 'government attempts to win over the hearts and minds of British workers to more flexible working patterns have not yet paid dividends' (Spencer 1996:89). Whilst one may well concur with the sentiment behind the argument that the '"New Industrial Relations" involves a systematic suppression of rank and file dissent' (Danford 1997:137), this would be to credit NIR with more purpose than it really possesses. Rather, it is the relative absence of systematicity which would seem to be its more essential attribute, and as such we can understand it as very much a product of its period. sbowler@onetel.net. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE People in Business section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE People in Business essays

  1. Analyze and evaluate the strategic decisions made by Marks and Spencer (M&S) in different ...

    Lewin assumes that in any situation there are both driving and restraining forces that influence any change. The method is used to get a whole view of all the forces for or against a plan so that a decision can be made which takes into account all interests.


    Finding out sickness rates helps Sainsbury's plan for the future. If there are shortage of employees when an employee is absent due to sickness, then Sainsbury's may recruit part-time staff for filling in. This would however cost the business to recruit them.

  1. This is a report on Marks and Spencer a well known retail company in ...

    In addition, the competitors such as Gap and Next have targeted different segment and also have impacted on the company operations. All in all, the competition in this industry is intense and if M&S still wants to be competitive, it has to change the way it is operating and that's

  2. Observations on Management and Leadership

    Yet, few argue for the level of intensity required to provide leadership of STAFF. It has been said that "You can fool the boss, but you can't fool your peers, Ah, the ones you REALLY can't fool are the human beings who comprise your STAFF!

  1. Managing Human Resources in Marks & Spencer.

    A jobcentre vacancy is defined as a job opportunity notified by an employer to a jobcentre or careers office (including 'self-employed' opportunities created by employers). Fig 1.4 This data is from the official national statistics UK site Above you can see that there is an increasing amount of vacancies.

  2. The HRM model emphasizes: The need ...

    The main aim of the feedback system is to inform the employee about the quality of his or her performance. (However, the information flow is not exclusively one way. The appraisers also receive feedback from the employee about job problems, etc.)

  1. The background of the Kettering Park Hotel and Spa

    need to know what they're doing right as well as wrong, as this will raise staff morale and allow the staff the chance to be verbally commended by management staff. Another way of measuring success is with the Park Hotel's loyalty card, this offers nothing but money using points, no

  2. The chief objectives of this report include:Ø Settlement of the power conflict between top ...

    Apart from the effectiveness of this position-based power strategy, the use of coercive power always causes negative consequences such as weakening relationships. In contrast, the pilots hold strong expert power. Pilots have high-value expertise. Referring to the strategic contingencies model3 which focused on individual power and how it is obtained,

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work